FRANCISCO MARTINEZ, PLAINTIFF AND APPELLEE, VS. PEDRO MARTINEZ, DEFENDANT AND APPELLANT.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Martinez versus Martinez
The Case
Francisco Martinez, the plaintiff, sued Pedro Martinez, the defendant, and won before the trial court. The defendant appealed, and the Supreme Court reversed the judgment and sent the case back for a new trial, with costs against the plaintiff as appellee. The plaintiff then asked the Court to reconsider that award of costs, arguing that when a judgment is reversed the appellee should not be made to pay. This case matters far less for the merits of the land dispute than for a precise procedural point every litigator must know: when the Supreme Court reverses and remands, an award of costs reaches only the costs of the appeal, not the costs already accrued or still to accrue in the court below.
Procedural History
The case began in the trial court, where judgment was rendered in favor of the plaintiff, Francisco Martinez. The defendant, Pedro Martinez, brought the case up to the Supreme Court by bill of exceptions. On January 23, 1903, the Court reversed the judgment in favor of the plaintiff and remanded the case for a new trial, with costs against the appellee — that is, against the plaintiff. The plaintiff then filed a motion asking the Court to revise that order as to costs, relying on provisions of law in force before the present Code of Civil Procedure. The Court denied the motion as grounded on repealed law, but clarified its earlier order by amendment.
Facts
Francisco Martinez sued Pedro Martinez. The trial court decided in favor of Francisco, the plaintiff. Pedro, the defendant, appealed to the Supreme Court by bill of exceptions.
The Supreme Court reversed the judgment in favor of the plaintiff and remanded the case for a new trial, ordering that costs be paid by the appellee, Francisco.
Francisco moved to revise the order on costs. He argued that when a judgment is reversed it is improper to compel the appellee to pay costs, and he cited provisions of law in force before the enactment of the present Code of Civil Procedure. The Court held those old provisions inapplicable because they had been repealed, and the matter of costs is now governed by the articles of the present Code. The Court then explained what its award of costs actually covered, and amended the decision to remove any ambiguity.
Issues
- Whether or not the provisions of law in force before the enactment of the present Code of Civil Procedure, invoked by the appellee against an award of costs upon reversal, still govern the matter of costs.
- Whether or not, when the Supreme Court reverses a judgment brought before it by bill of exceptions and grants a new trial, an order of costs against the appellee covers the costs already accrued in the lower court or which may accrue there after remand.
Applicable Provisions
The decision refers to the articles of the present Code of Civil Procedure governing costs, without quoting them, and states that the earlier provisions are repealed. The governing text, as the Court describes it, is identified thus:
Such provisions are inapplicable for they have been repealed by that Code whose articles 487-495 now govern the matter of costs.
This fixes the applicable law: the old cost provisions invoked by the appellee no longer control, and the cost rules of the present Code govern.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the provisions cited by the appellee are inapplicable. They were repealed by the present Code of Civil Procedure, whose articles 487 to 495 now govern the matter of costs. The motion therefore could not rest on repealed law.
On the second issue, the Court held that when a case is brought up by bill of exceptions and the judgment is reversed and a new trial granted, the order of the Court in regard to costs refers only to the costs of the Court itself — those arising by reason of the appeal. It decides nothing as to the costs already accrued in the lower court or which may accrue there after the case is remanded. Those costs remain as they are, without any order in respect thereto, until the final determination of the suit. The Court stated the rule in these words:
When a case is brought here by a bill of exceptions and the judgment is reversed and a new trial granted the order of this court in regard to costs refers only to the costs of this court - that is, those arising by reason of the appeal.
Finding that its order might be ambiguous on this point, the Court amended the decision of January 23, 1903, by adding after the words "the costs" in the last line the words "of this second instance."
Doctrine
First, the cost provisions of the present Code of Civil Procedure, articles 487 to 495, govern the matter of costs; the earlier provisions are repealed and cannot be invoked.
Second, when the Supreme Court, on a bill of exceptions, reverses the judgment and grants a new trial, an order of costs against the appellee covers only the costs of the appeal — the costs of the second instance. It decides nothing about costs already accrued in the lower court or those that may accrue there after remand. Those costs await the final determination of the suit.
Third, to avoid ambiguity, an order of costs in such a case should be read, and where necessary amended, to refer expressly to the costs of the second instance.
Disposition
The motion to revise the order of costs was denied, and the Court ordered its decision of January 23, 1903, amended by adding after the words "the costs" the words "of this second instance," so that the award covers only the costs of the appeal.
Remember This
Memorize the line: on reversal and remand by bill of exceptions, the award of costs reaches only the costs of the second instance, never the costs in the court below. Examiners use this case to test the scope of a cost award on appeal and the rule that repealed procedural provisions cannot govern costs.