HIJOS DE I. DE LA RAMA, PLAINTIFFS AND APPELLEES, VS. VICENTE BENEDICTO, DEFENDANT AND APPELLANT.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Hijos de I. de la Rama versus Benedicto
The Case
This is an early twentieth-century agrarian case from the Philippine Supreme Court, decided in November 1902, in which the plaintiffs, the heirs of I. de la Rama, sued Vicente Benedicto to eject him from agricultural land they had leased to him. The action was brought for ejectment and for that alone, on the ground that the tenant failed to deliver to the lessors the share of the crop that the contract stipulated as rent. The case matters because it draws a sharp line between two Civil Code provisions: the article on the tenant's liability for crop losses, which does not excuse a failure to deliver an aliquot share of the harvest, and the article allowing the lessor to eject a tenant who fails to pay the rent. It also reminds us that ejectment is a real action to recover possession, not a personal action to collect the value of what was not delivered.
Procedural History
The case began in the trial court, which rendered judgment in favor of the plaintiffs. The defendant appealed to the Superior Court of Negros, and that appeal was allowed in both effects, meaning the appeal was given effect in both its suspensive and its devolutive aspects. The case then reached the Supreme Court of the Philippines by appeal from the judgment of the Superior Court, which had affirmed the trial court. The Supreme Court, speaking through Justice Willard, affirmed the judgment with costs against the appellant.
Facts
The plaintiffs, the heirs of I. de la Rama, owned agricultural land which they leased to the defendant, Vicente Benedicto. Under the agreement between them, the rent was not a fixed sum of money but an aliquot part of the crop, specifically one-fourth of the harvest.
For the crop year 1899, the defendant failed to deliver to the plaintiffs a part of the crop due them under the agreement. The testimony of Felix Labayan, Casiana Capilar, and Timoteo Unson clearly proved this failure. The plaintiffs then brought this action to eject the defendant from the land, relying on the contract and on the Civil Code provision allowing a lessor to eject a tenant who fails to pay the rent.
The suit was brought before the crop year 1899 to 1900 had ended, but only after the defendant had already failed to deliver part of the crop at the time specified in the contract. The defendant set up a counterclaim, which the trial court rejected, and he suggested in argument that he had already abandoned the land, a fact that did not appear anywhere in the record.
Issues
- Whether or not the defendant's failure to deliver part of the 1899 crop was excused by the Civil Code provision on the tenant's liability for crop losses.
- Whether or not that failure to deliver part of the crop was a failure to pay the rent that entitled the plaintiffs to eject the defendant.
- Whether or not the action, brought before the termination of the crop year, was premature.
- Whether or not the defendant's counterclaim was properly rejected.
Applicable Provisions
Article 1575 of the Civil Code, on the tenant's liability for losses of the crop, provides:
The tenant shall be liable for the loss or deterioration of the fruits, except in the cases mentioned in article 1574.
The Court held that this article cannot be applied to excuse the defendant's failure, because it does not refer to a contract in which the stipulated rent is an aliquot part of the crop, such as one-fourth.
Article 1569, section 2, of the Civil Code, on the lessor's right to eject, provides:
The lessor may eject the lessee from the leased property in the following cases: 1. When the lessee fails to pay the rent agreed upon, or the amount of the increase of the same, in the manner and at the time agreed upon. 2. When the lessee fails to pay the rent agreed upon, or the amount of the increase of the same, in the manner and at the time agreed upon.
This is the provision on which the plaintiffs' right to eject rested, once the failure to deliver part of the crop was treated as a failure to pay the rent.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the failure to deliver part of the 1899 crop was clearly proved and that Article 1575 cannot be so applied as to excuse it. That article does not refer to a contract in which the stipulated rent is an aliquot part of the crop, for example one-fourth, as it was in this case.
On the second issue, the Court held that the failure to deliver part of the crop was a failure to pay the rent, and therefore gave the plaintiffs the right to eject the defendant under Article 1569, section 2. The Court stressed that the action was brought for that purpose and for that alone, and was in no sense a personal action to recover the value of the part of the crop not delivered.
On the third issue, the Court held that the fact the suit was brought before the termination of the crop year 1899 to 1900 was not important, because it was not brought until after the defendant had failed to deliver part of the crop at the time specified in the contract.
On the fourth issue, the Court held that the defendant's counterclaim was properly rejected for the reasons stated in the opinion of the trial court. As to the suggestion that the defendant had already abandoned the land, the Court said that such fact did not appear in any way from the record; on the contrary, the appeal to the Superior Court of Negros was allowed in both effects.
Doctrine
First, where the rent under a lease is an aliquot part of the crop, the tenant's failure to deliver that share is a failure to pay the rent, and the lessor may eject the tenant under Article 1569, section 2, of the Civil Code. Second, Article 1575, on the tenant's liability for crop losses, does not apply to a contract in which the stipulated rent is an aliquot part of the crop, such as one-fourth, and cannot be invoked to excuse a failure to deliver that share. Third, an ejectment action based on nonpayment of rent is a real action to recover possession, not a personal action to collect the value of the undelivered crop. Fourth, the action is not premature merely because it is brought before the crop year ends, so long as it is brought after the tenant fails to deliver at the time specified in the contract.
Disposition
The Supreme Court affirmed the judgment in favor of the plaintiffs, the heirs of I. de la Rama, with costs against the defendant and appellant, Vicente Benedicto.
Remember This
Memorize this line: when the rent is an aliquot part of the crop, failure to deliver that share is failure to pay the rent, and Article 1575 does not excuse it. Examiners use this case to test the distinction between an ejectment action for nonpayment of rent and a personal action for the value of the crop, and the rule that a suit brought before the crop year ends is not premature if the tenant has already defaulted.