THE UNITED STATES, COMPLAINANT AND APPELLEE, VS. PATRICIO ANTONIO, DEFENDANT AND APPELLANT.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
United States versus Antonio
The Case
This is a criminal case for perjury brought by the Government of the United States against Patricio Antonio. The charge is that Antonio, testifying in an earlier criminal case against Gabriel Dancel for discharging a firearm and for lesiones menos graves, falsely swore that Dancel fired only one shot, when in truth two shots were fired. The case matters because it fixes the standard of proof for the falsehood element of perjury: the prosecution must establish with certainty that the accused actually perverted the truth, and where the evidence is evenly balanced, that burden is not met.
Procedural History
Antonio was charged with perjury in the trial court, which convicted him and rendered judgment against him. He appealed that judgment to the Supreme Court, which reversed the conviction and acquitted him, with the costs of both instances de oficio, that is, at public expense.
Facts
Gabriel Dancel was prosecuted for discharging a firearm and for lesiones menos graves, less serious physical injuries, inflicted upon Miguel Marunao. In that case, Eustrasio Guerrero was killed and Marunao was wounded. Patricio Antonio testified for Dancel that Dancel fired a single shot from the gun, which caused the death of Guerrero and at the same time wounded Marunao. The perjury complaint against Antonio alleged that this was false, because there were really two shots: the first killed Guerrero and the second wounded Marunao.
The record of the Dancel case showed that Antonio was not alone in saying there was only one discharge. Four other witnesses, Pablo Antonio, Escolastico Laureta, Rafael Dancel, and Pedro Asuncion, testified to the same effect, that Dancel fired the gun but once. Three witnesses, Andres Arcellano, Damaso Arcellano, and Juan Sahagun, testified that the gun was fired twice.
In the perjury case itself, the evidence was equally contradictory. The prosecution called four witnesses who said there were two shots; the defense presented four witnesses who affirmed there was only one. The defense witnesses were near the place of the occurrence and had conveyed the body of Guerrero to the town; they testified that had there been two shots they must necessarily have heard them, given the short distance. They had not taken part in the quarrel and so preserved the presence of mind to observe its details. The prosecution witnesses had all participated in the occurrence; they testified that upon hearing the first shot they were frightened and ran away, and were still running when they heard the second. Marunao himself said he was wounded while running, yet the wound was on the knee, which appeared to indicate he received it while facing the aggressor. The experts opined that it was very possible, and indeed they were inclined to think, that Marunao was wounded by the same shot that killed Guerrero, considering the distances and the positions of both victims relative to the aggressor.
Issues
- Whether or not the accused perverted the truth when he testified that Gabriel Dancel fired only one shot on the occasion in question.
- Whether or not the evidence for the prosecution established the alleged falsehood with the certainty required to sustain a conviction for perjury.
Applicable Provisions
The decision does not quote any statutory provision in its text; it applies the crime of perjury as charged in the complaint, which alleged that the accused testified falsely under oath. The Court's ruling turns not on a quoted article but on the burden of proof: the prosecution must show with certainty that the testimony was false.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that it could not, upon the merits, reach with certainty the conclusion that the accused perverted the truth when he testified that Dancel fired only one shot. The Court weighed the conflicting evidence and found it evenly divided: four prosecution witnesses said two shots, four defense witnesses said one. The defense witnesses were disinterested bystanders near the scene who would necessarily have heard a second shot, while the prosecution witnesses admitted they were running away when the second shot was heard, making it hard to understand how they could say the second shot wounded Marunao. Marunao's knee wound suggested he was facing the aggressor, not fleeing. The experts thought it very possible, and were inclined to believe, that one shot caused both the death and the wound.
On the second issue, because the evidence was equally contradictory and the possibility of a single shot could not be excluded, the prosecution failed to establish the falsehood with the certainty the law demands. The Court stated its conclusion in these words:
Upon the merits of the case we can not with certainty reach the conclusion that the accused perverted the truth when testifying that Gabriel Dancel fired only one shot on the occasion referred to.
Accordingly, the conviction could not stand.
Doctrine
In a prosecution for perjury, the falsehood of the accused's testimony must be established with certainty; it is not enough that the prosecution's evidence merely balances or contradicts the defense. Where the evidence is equally contradictory, the doubt must be resolved in favor of the accused, and the constitutional presumption of innocence prevails. The Court's own formulation is the rule to retain:
Upon the merits of the case we can not with certainty reach the conclusion that the accused perverted the truth when testifying that Gabriel Dancel fired only one shot on the occasion referred to.
A Bar answer should state that perjury requires a willful and deliberate assertion of a falsehood, and that the element of falsehood must be proved with certainty, not by a mere preponderance of conflicting testimony.
Disposition
The Supreme Court reversed the judgment of conviction and acquitted the accused, with the costs of both instances de oficio.
Remember This
The line to memorize is that the Court cannot, with certainty, conclude that the accused perverted the truth; perjury demands certainty of falsehood, not evenly matched evidence. Examiners use this case to test the burden of proof in perjury and the rule that equipoise in the evidence means acquittal.