THE UNITED STATES, COMPLAINANT AND APPELLEE, VS. TAN JENJUA, DEFENDANT AND APPELLANT.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
United States versus Tan Jenjua
The Case
This is a criminal case from the early years of the American regime in the Philippines, brought by the United States as complainant and appellee against Tan Jenjua as defendant and appellant. The decision itself does not narrate the charge or the evidence at trial; what it resolves is a post-judgment petition filed by counsel, Attorney Francisco Ortigas, asking the Supreme Court to reopen the case on the ground of newly discovered evidence. The case matters to a reviewee because it states, cleanly and briefly, the rule on when a judgment may be reopened for newly discovered evidence, and because it shows the Court refusing to disguise a claim of judicial error as newly discovered evidence.
Procedural History
The case was tried in an inferior court, where judgment was rendered against the accused. The cause was then remanded, meaning it had already passed through this Court and was returned to the lower court. After remand, Attorney Francisco Ortigas filed a petition in the Supreme Court soliciting the reopening of the case under Section 42 of General Orders, Number 58. The Supreme Court resolved that petition in the decision before us, denying it.
Facts
Tan Jenjua was convicted in the inferior court. The record as narrated in this decision does not set out the offense or the evidence, and the Court expressly leaves those matters untouched.
After the case had been remanded, counsel for the accused came to the Supreme Court with a petition to reopen it. The petition rested on Section 42 of General Orders, Number 58, the provision allowing a cause to be reopened upon newly discovered evidence. The petition pointed to an absent witness and, apparently, to the manner in which the judge of the inferior court administered the oath to a Chinese witness.
The petition was not accompanied by any affidavit setting forth the facts relied upon, although Section 42 requires one. Nor did the petition show that the testimony of the absent witness was unknown to the accused or his attorney before trial, or could not have been known by proper diligence.
Issues
- Whether or not the case may be reopened under Section 42 of General Orders, Number 58 on the ground of newly discovered evidence, where the accused or his attorney knew, or could have known by proper diligence, what the testimony of the absent witness would be.
- Whether or not the alleged error of the inferior court judge in administering the oath to the Chinese witness may be presented as newly discovered evidence.
Applicable Provisions
Section 42 of General Orders, Number 58 governs the reopening of a cause, and the Court applies it strictly:
The reopening of a cause under section 42 is only available when there exists newly discovered evidence.
That single condition is the test the petition had to satisfy, and it is the test the petition failed.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the reopening of a cause under Section 42 is available only where there is newly discovered evidence. If the accused or his attorney knew what the testimony of the absent witness would be, or could have known it by the exercise of proper diligence, then the proofs were not discovered after the trial. The Court put the rule this way:
If the accused or his attorney knew what would be the testimony of the absent witness or could have known it by the exercise of proper diligence, it can not be said that he has discovered these proofs after the trial.
The Court also noted that no affidavit whatever setting forth the facts on this point accompanied the petition, as Section 42 requires. The petition therefore failed both on substance and on form.
On the second issue, the Court held that the error of the inferior court judge, if error it was, in the manner of administering the oath to the Chinese witness could not be presented as newly discovered evidence. The Court said so plainly:
It is, of course, evident that the error of the judge of the inferior court, if error it was, in the manner of administering the oath to the Chinese witness, can not be presented as newly discovered evidence.
The Court deliberately declined to decide two further questions: first, whether the judgment had become final as soon as it was registered in this Court, which would make the motion inopportune; and second, if it had not become final, whether the motion should have been made before the lower court, since the cause had been remanded and was no longer pending before this Court. The denial thus rests on the absence of newly discovered evidence, not on finality or on the proper forum.
Doctrine
Reopening a cause under Section 42 of General Orders, Number 58 requires newly discovered evidence. Evidence is not newly discovered if the accused or his attorney knew what the testimony of the absent witness would be, or could have known it by the exercise of proper diligence; what could have been known before trial is not discovered after it. The petition must be supported by an affidavit setting forth the facts relied upon, as Section 42 requires. And an alleged error of the trial judge, such as the manner of administering an oath to a witness, is a matter of judicial error, not newly discovered evidence, and cannot be made the ground for reopening.
Disposition
The Supreme Court denied the petition, with costs taxed against the moving party, and the judgment against Tan Jenjua stood.
Remember This
Memorize the line that reopening lies only upon newly discovered evidence, and that what the accused or his attorney knew, or could have known by proper diligence, is never newly discovered. Examiners use this case to test the requisites of a motion for new trial or reopening based on newly discovered evidence, and to distinguish newly discovered evidence from mere judicial error.