THE UNITED STATES, COMPLAINANT AND APPELLEE, VS. JUAN CARDONA, DEFENDANT AND APPELLANT.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
United States versus Cardona
The Case
This is a criminal appeal from the early years of the American occupation, the case of the United States against Juan Cardona. Cardona was charged with robbery for taking a caraballa from Juan Jose at the point of a revolver, and the appeal asks the Supreme Court to review his conviction and the penalty imposed upon him. The case matters to a reviewee for three reasons: it fixes the elements of robbery by violence and intimidation under the old Penal Code, it shows how the aggravating circumstance of committing the offense in an unfrequented place is treated, and it settles that the date alleged in the complaint is not a material ingredient of the offense, so the Government is not bound by it in its proof.
Procedural History
Cardona was tried and convicted in the court below, which found him guilty of the offense and imposed a penalty within the maximum grade. From that judgment he appealed to the Supreme Court. On appeal he raised several matters: that the evidence should have been restricted to the date stated in the complaint, that the testimony as to his good character should be weighed in his favor, that the trial was void because the evidence was not read over to the witnesses before they signed it, that he should be discharged under the amnesty proclamation of July 4, 1902, that his official position should not have been taken against him, and that article 11 of the Penal Code should be applied in his favor as an attenuating circumstance. The Supreme Court reviewed the record and affirmed the judgment.
Facts
In the fall of 1901, Clayton J. Bailey was an inspector of the Constabulary in command of the forces stationed in the Province of Tarlac. Inhabitants of Gerona complained to him that the defendant had robbed them of carabaos and horses. After investigating, Bailey seized about ninety head of stock in the possession of the defendant's tenants and deposited the stock in the Government corral at Tarlac.
Juan Jose testified that about the fifth or sixth of March, while he was going toward Gerona with his caraballa and its calf, accompanied by his uncle Paulo Jose and Cipriano Jose, he met Cardona with four other persons in an unfrequented part of the road. Cardona, holding a revolver at his head, told him to take himself off and leave his animals there together with the cart to which the caraballa was harnessed. Juan Jose at once departed with his companions. He had the certificate of transfer in his pocket, but Cardona made no inquiry for it. His uncle corroborated him as to the occurrence on the road.
At the trial, Bailey testified that he had personally compared the brands on one of the animals taken from Cardona's farm with the brands set forth in the certificate of transfer to Juan Jose, and that they were the same. Felix Llorente, an inspector of Constabulary, likewise testified that the animal had been taken from Cardona's farm and that its marks were identical with those on the certificate. The defense sought to show that Cardona was in Tarlac and not in Gerona about March 25, that he had good character, and that one Paulo Tanedo had bought the caraballa at a public auction held in Gerona in August 1901. Tanedo could only say that he did not know whether the caraballa he bought was the one taken from Juan Jose, and the documents showed that only one of the three marks corresponded.
Issues
- Whether or not the evidence was sufficient to prove that Cardona, by violence and intimidation, took the caraballa from Juan Jose.
- Whether or not the Government was limited in its proof to the date alleged in the complaint.
- Whether or not the testimony as to the good character of the accused could overcome the positive and uncontradicted evidence of his guilt.
- Whether or not the trial was void because the evidence was not read over to the witnesses before they signed it.
- Whether or not the accused was entitled to discharge under the amnesty proclamation of July 4, 1902.
- Whether or not the offense was committed in an unfrequented place and how that fact should be considered in fixing the penalty.
- Whether or not the accused took advantage of his official position in committing the crime.
- Whether or not article 11 of the Penal Code should be applied in his favor as an attenuating circumstance.
Applicable Provisions
Article 503, Number 5, of the Penal Code, which the Court held covers the offense proven, provides the definition of robbery by violence or intimidation against persons. The Court applied it to characterize the taking of the caraballa at the point of a revolver as robbery.
Article 503, Number 5, of the Penal Code.
Article 10 of the Penal Code, which the Court used to treat the commission of the offense in an unfrequented place as an aggravating circumstance, provides the general rule on aggravating circumstances. The Court applied it to raise the penalty to the maximum grade.
Article 10 of the Penal Code.
Article 7 of General Orders, Number 58, which the Court cited to hold that the Government was not limited in its proof to the date stated in the complaint, provides the rule on the sufficiency of the complaint as to time. The Court applied it to reject the argument that the evidence should be restricted to March 25.
Article 7 of General Orders, Number 58.
Article 32 of General Orders, Number 58, which the accused invoked to claim that the trial was void because the evidence was not read over to the witnesses, provides the requirement for reading the evidence to the witnesses before signing. The Court held that it did not affirmatively appear that this was not done, and that in any event it would be a defect of form.
Article 32 of General Orders, Number 58.
Article 10 of General Orders, Number 58, which the Court cited to hold that a defect of form would not reverse the judgment, provides the rule on reversible error. The Court applied it to reject the claim of a void trial.
Article 10 of General Orders, Number 58.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the evidence was ample to show that Cardona, by violence and intimidation, took from Juan Jose his caraballa and sent it to his farm, from which it was taken by the Constabulary. There was no attempt to contradict the statements of Juan and Paulo Jose as to the forcible taking, and the identification of the animal was only sought to be overcome by Tanedo, whose testimony fell far short.
On the second issue, the Court held that the date was not a material ingredient of the offense, and under the provisions of article 7 of General Orders, Number 58, the Government was not limited in its proof to the date stated in the complaint. The testimony as to the whereabouts of the defendant on March 25 was therefore unimportant, since the evidence showed the robbery was committed about the fifth or sixth of March.
On the third issue, the Court held that the testimony as to good character could not in any event outweigh such positive and uncontradicted evidence as was produced to show the defendant's guilt. It noted that some of the defendant's witnesses admitted on cross-examination that they had heard his reputation prior to the American occupation was bad.
On the fourth issue, the Court held that it did not affirmatively appear that the evidence was not read over to the witnesses, and even if it were not, this, without anything more appearing, would be a defect of form for which the judgment could not be reversed under article 10 of General Orders, Number 58.
On the fifth issue, the Court held that the petition for discharge under the amnesty proclamation of July 4, 1902, must be denied.
On the sixth issue, the Court held that the offense proven is covered by article 503, Number 5, of the Penal Code. The complaint did not allege that the offense was committed in an unfrequented place, but the Court found it unnecessary to decide whether without such an allegation the defendant could be convicted under article 504, since it arrived at the same result reached by the court below by considering the fact that the offense was committed in an unfrequented place as an aggravating circumstance under article 10.
On the seventh issue, the Court held that there was not sufficient evidence to show that the defendant took advantage of his official position as provincial secretary so as to make applicable article 10, Number 11, of the Penal Code. Juan Jose testified that he did not know Cardona held this office, and his belief that Cardona was one of the authorities of Gerona was not sufficient to justify saying that the official position was a material factor in the crime. Juan Jose was induced to abandon his property by the revolver held at his head and by the fact that four men accompanied Cardona.
On the eighth issue, the Court held that it was not warranted in applying article 11 of the Penal Code in favor of the defendant as an attenuating circumstance.
Finally, the Court held that the presence of the aggravating circumstance taken into consideration raises the punishment to the maximum grade, and the penalty imposed by the judge below is within that grade.
Doctrine
Robbery by violence or intimidation against persons is committed when the taking of personal property is accomplished by force or intimidation, as when a revolver is held at the head of the victim. The date alleged in the complaint is not a material ingredient of the offense, and under article 7 of General Orders, Number 58, the Government is not limited in its proof to the date stated therein. Testimony as to good character cannot outweigh positive and uncontradicted evidence of guilt. A defect of form, such as the failure to read the evidence over to the witnesses, will not reverse the judgment absent a showing that it was not done and that prejudice resulted. The commission of the offense in an unfrequented place may be considered as an aggravating circumstance under article 10 of the Penal Code, raising the penalty to the maximum grade. The taking advantage of official position as an aggravating circumstance under article 10, Number 11, requires proof that the official position was a material factor in the commission of the crime. Article 11 of the Penal Code is not to be applied as an attenuating circumstance absent the conditions it requires.
Disposition
The Supreme Court affirmed the judgment of conviction against Juan Cardona, with costs of the instance against the appellant.
Remember This
The single line worth memorizing is that the date alleged in the complaint is not a material ingredient of the offense, so the Government is not limited in its proof to that date. Examiners like to use this case to test the elements of robbery by violence and intimidation, the treatment of an unfrequented place as an aggravating circumstance, and the rule that good character evidence cannot overcome positive and uncontradicted proof of guilt.