EULALIO HERNAEZ, PLAINTIFF AND APPELLANT, VS. ROSENDO HERNAEZ, DEFENDANT AND APPELLEE.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Hernaez versus Hernaez
The Case
This is an early Philippine decision on collation — the bringing back into the mass of a succession of property or money that a forced heir received gratuitously from the decedent during the latter's lifetime. Eulalio Hernaez sued his brother Rosendo Hernaez, asking that the values of two estates owned by Rosendo, the Naga estate and the Panaogao estate, be collated and included in the inventory of the intestate estate of their father, Pedro Hernaez. The case matters because it states, cleanly and early, the rule a Bar candidate must be able to recite: collation rests on a gratuitous transfer from the decedent, and he who alleges it must prove it.
Procedural History
The action was brought in connection with the proceedings on the administration of the intestate estate of Pedro Hernaez. The plaintiff, Eulalio Hernaez, sought by collation to have the values of the Naga and Panaogao properties included in the inventory of the mass of the intestate succession. The complaint was dismissed, and the case went up on appeal. The Supreme Court, speaking through the decision, affirmed the dismissal, with the costs of both instances taxed against the plaintiff.
Facts
Pedro Hernaez died, leaving an intestate estate and two sons, Eulalio the plaintiff and Rosendo the defendant. Eulalio alleged that when Rosendo returned from his student life in Manila he was a poor man and was supported by his father; that shortly afterwards he purchased the Naga estate while not engaged in any profitable trade or industry; that he was the administrator of the property of his parents; that the money with which he purchased the Naga estate belonged to his father; and that the Panaogao estate was purchased by Rosendo after the death of their father.
The public instruments showed that the Naga estate was acquired by Rosendo from his brother Julian on the twenty fifth of November, 1881, and the Panaogao estate from Pedro Garganera on the second of November, 1898. The Court noted that there was not the slightest indication that the money with which these estates were purchased was or could be other than that of the purchaser himself.
On the evidence, none of the alleged facts was proven. Two witnesses testified that they had never seen any articles of copartnership in a public or private instrument, and Rosendo himself testified that he had been an industrial partner and that no written articles had been executed. Three relatives — Domingo and Magdalena Hernaez, brothers of both contending parties, and Peregrina Jarapa, a nephew — denied that Rosendo purchased the Naga estate with money belonging to his father, and testified instead that it was purchased with money acquired by his own labors.
Issues
- Whether or not the Naga estate, acquired by the defendant forced heir during the lifetime of the decedent, may be brought into collation as property received gratuitously from the decedent.
- Whether or not the Panaogao estate, acquired by the forced heir after the death of the decedent, has any connection with the question of collation.
Applicable Provisions
Article 1035 of the Civil Code is the legal principle upon which the plaintiff relied, and the Court framed it thus:
A forced heir in certain cases is required to bring into the mass of the succession properties or moneys which he may have received gratuitously from the decedent during the lifetime of the latter.
This provision bears on the case because it fixes the two elements of collation — a forced heir, and a gratuitous receipt from the decedent during the decedent's lifetime — and the plaintiff failed to prove the second.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the action cannot be maintained. Of the facts set up in the complaint, the only one relevant to the issue was the fourth, concerning the acquisition of the Naga estate with money belonging to the father. But whatever might be said about the facts alleged, none of them was proven. It not having been proven that the property sought to be collated was acquired gratuitously from the intestate, the complaint was dismissed.
On the second issue, the Court held that the allegation concerning the Panaogao estate was irrelevant. Apart from the fact of its irrelevancy, it was not apparent what connection the simple statement that a forced heir acquired the estate after the death of the causante could possibly have with the question of collation — for collation under the provision reaches only what was received during the lifetime of the decedent.
Doctrine
Collation under Article 1035 of the Civil Code requires that the property or money have been received gratuitously from the decedent during the lifetime of the latter. Property acquired by a forced heir after the decedent's death is outside the reach of collation, and an allegation to that effect states no ground for relief. The burden lies on the plaintiff: the heir who seeks collation must prove that the property was acquired gratuitously from the intestate, and absent such proof the action cannot be maintained.
Disposition
The Supreme Court dismissed the complaint, with the costs of both instances to the plaintiff, Eulalio Hernaez; the defendant, Rosendo Hernaez, prevailed.
Remember This
Memorize the line: it not having been proven that the property sought to be collated was acquired gratuitously from the intestate, the action cannot be maintained. Examiners use this case to test the elements of collation and the rule that a forced heir's acquisition after the decedent's death is irrelevant to collation.