🎧 Case Brief Lecture

ESCOLASTICA MONTESCLAROS SON, AND HEIRS OF ANASTACIO SON, PETITIONERS, VS. CARMELINO SON, TEOFISTA SON, PRIMITIVO SON, CIPRIANA SON, ANATALIA SON, LAREANO SON, GERARDA SON AND T…

G.R. No. 73077. December 29, 1995 December 29, 1995

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

Son versus Son

The Case

This is a petition for review on certiorari brought by the heirs of Anastacio Son against the children and heirs of the late Pedro Son, decided by the Supreme Court in December 1995. The private respondents sued to annul a Deed of Absolute Sale dated 5 November 1957 over a portion of land in Medellin, Cebu, on grounds of forgery, and to recover possession of that land. The case matters for two reasons: it is a clean statement of how a pre-trial order delimiting the issues may be relaxed, and it shows the Court applying the rule that issues tried by implied consent of the parties are treated as if pleaded. It is a procedural case with a property dispute at its heart.

Procedural History

The private respondents filed their complaint for annulment of the 1957 deed and recovery of real property before the Court of First Instance of Cebu. At the pre-trial conference, the parties agreed to limit the issue to the validity or invalidity of that deed, and the trial court issued a pre-trial order to that effect. The trial court then rendered judgment for the private respondents, declaring the 1957 deed null and void and ordering the petitioners to return the land and pay a share in the produce and attorney's fees. On the petitioners' motion for reconsideration, the trial court reversed itself, set aside its decision, and dismissed the complaint. The private respondents appealed to the Court of Appeals, which reversed the trial court and reinstated the annulment of the 1957 deed, holding that the petitioners had waived the defense based on the earlier 1951 Deed of Sale with Right to Repurchase because they raised it only in their motion for reconsideration. The petitioners then came to the Supreme Court by petition for review on certiorari under Rule 45.

Facts

Pedro Son inherited from his parents, Juan Son and Susana Perilla, a parcel of land in Caputatan Norte, Medellin, Cebu, containing two hectares and seven centares. Pedro died in November 1957, and his wife Marcelina Tudtud died on 2 January 1972. The private respondents are their children and heirs. The petitioners are the heirs of Anastacio Son, Pedro's brother.

In 1972, the private respondents discovered that a portion of the land, 6,324 square meters, was being occupied by the petitioners, and they demanded its return. The petitioners refused, claiming ownership under a Deed of Absolute Sale allegedly executed by Pedro Son on 5 November 1957. The private respondents then sued in 1976 to annul that deed for forgery and to recover the land.

At pre-trial, the parties agreed to limit the issue to the validity of the 1957 deed. After the trial court first ruled for the private respondents and then reversed itself on reconsideration, the petitioners defended on a second document: a Deed of Sale with Right to Repurchase dated 17 December 1951, by which Pedro Son had allegedly sold one half of his share to the petitioners with a right to repurchase within one year, which Pedro never exercised. The Court of Appeals held that this 1951 deed was a new issue barred by the pre-trial order, but upheld the finding that the 1957 deed was simulated and forged.

Issues

  • Whether or not the 1951 Deed of Sale with Right to Repurchase, though not among the issues fixed at pre-trial, may be admitted in evidence, considering that it was pleaded in the answer and that the adverse party failed to object to its presentation and even cross-examined on it.
  • Whether or not the Court of Appeals gravely misapprehended the facts in holding that the land covered by the 1957 deed is part of the same land covered by the 1951 deed.
  • Whether or not the Court of Appeals erred in concluding that the 1957 deed is null and void, allegedly relying on speculation and on supposed discrepancies in the testimonies of the notary public and Anastacio Son.

Applicable Provisions

Section 4 of Rule 20 of the Revised Rules of Court, on the record of pre-trial results, provides:

Section 4. Record of pre-trial results. After the pre-trial the court shall make an order which recites the action taken at the conference, the amendments allowed to the pleadings, and the agreements made by the parties as to any of the matters considered, such order shall limit the issues for trial to those not disposed of by admissions or agreements of counsel and when entered controls the subsequent course of the action, unless modified before trial to prevent manifest injustice.

This is the provision the Court of Appeals applied strictly, and the provision the Supreme Court reads together with the exception below.

Section 5 of Rule 10 of the Revised Rules of Court, on amendments to conform to or authorize presentation of evidence, provides:

Section 5. Amendment to conform to or authorize presentation of evidence. When issues not raised by the pleadings are tried by express or implied consent of the parties, they shall be treated in all respects, as if they had been raised in the pleadings. Such amendment of the pleadings as may be necessary to cause them to conform to the evidence and to raise these issues may be made upon motion of any party at any time, even after judgment; but failure so to amend does not affect the result of the trial of these issues. If evidence is objected to at the trial on the ground that it is not within the issues made by the pleadings, the court may allow the pleadings to be amended and shall do so freely when the presentation of the merits of the action will be subserved thereby and the objecting party fails to satisfy the court that the admission of such evidence would prejudice him in maintaining his action or defense upon the merits. The court may grant a continuance to enable the objecting party to meet such evidence.

This is the exception the Supreme Court applies: the failure to object to evidence on an unpleaded issue amounts to implied consent, and the issue is treated as if pleaded.

Ruling

On the third issue, the Court held that the principle that a plaintiff must rely on the strength of his own evidence and not on the weakness of the defense was misplaced. What the petitioners were really attacking was the credibility of the private respondents' witnesses, and the matter of credence is best addressed by the trial judge, who is in a better position to appreciate the weight of testimony. The Court found no reason to depart from the findings of both lower courts on the contradictions in the petitioners' evidence.

On the first issue, the Court ruled for the petitioners. A pre-trial order controls the subsequent course of the action, but the rules are not applied with rigidity, and Section 5 of Rule 10 admits an exception. The Court found that the petitioners had pleaded the 1951 deed in their answer, and that the private respondents failed to object when it was offered in evidence, cross-examined the petitioners' witness on it, and even had their own witness, Teofista Son Arcipe, identify her father's signature on it. This failure to object, the Court held, was an implied assent to depart from the pre-trial order, and the private respondents were not caught in surprise because they had every opportunity to present rebuttal evidence.

On the second issue, the Court held that the land subject of the 1951 deed and the land subject of the 1957 deed were the same. Both deeds referred to Pedro Son's share in the property he and Anastacio inherited from their parents, and the 1951 deed expressly referred to lot number four as his share under the extrajudicial partition. The differences in area and consideration did not defeat identity, and the Court found nothing peculiar in Anastacio's explanation that he acceded to his brother's plea to reduce the area, close family ties being a common Filipino trait.

Doctrine

A pre-trial order that delimits the issues controls the subsequent course of the action, but it is not absolute. Under Section 5 of Rule 10, when an issue not raised by the pleadings is tried by express or implied consent of the parties, it is treated in all respects as if it had been raised in the pleadings. The failure of a party to object to evidence on an issue outside the pre-trial order, coupled with cross-examination on that evidence, amounts to implied consent and confers on the court the authority to try the issue. The rules of procedure are to be liberally applied in clearly meritorious cases to prevent manifest injustice.

Disposition

The petition was granted, the decision of the Court of Appeals was reversed and set aside, and the judgment of the trial court dismissing the complaint was reinstated. The petitioners won.

Remember This

Memorize this line: a pre-trial order limits the issues for trial, but failure to object to evidence on an issue outside it is implied consent under Section 5 of Rule 10, and the issue is tried as if pleaded. Examiners use this case to test the interplay between the pre-trial order under Rule 20 and the amendment to conform to evidence under Rule 10.