🎧 Case Brief Lecture

SANPIRO FINANCE CORPORATION, PETITIONER, VS. INTERMEDIATE APPELLATE COURT, LAGUNA TRANSPORTATION CO. INC., AND LAURO LOPEZ DE LEON, RESPONDENTS.

G.R. No. 72200. March 30, 1993 March 30, 1993

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

Sanpiro Finance Corporation versus Intermediate Appellate Court

The Case

This is a petition for review on certiorari brought by Sanpiro Finance Corporation against the Intermediate Appellate Court, now the Court of Appeals, and against Laguna Transportation Company Incorporated and Lauro Lopez de Leon. Sanpiro asks the Supreme Court to set aside the appellate court's decision and resolution, which had annulled a writ of seizure issued by the Regional Trial Court of Makati in a replevin suit and had ordered the seized passenger buses returned to Laguna Transportation. The case matters because it is the classic teaching vehicle for the rule on lis pendens, the pendency of another action, and for the duty of a court to respect the prior jurisdiction of a co-equal court. It also shows how a finance company that takes an assignment of the same debts already assigned to a bank cannot, by the mere expedient of a replevin suit, seize the debtor's buses ahead of the court that first took cognizance of the controversy.

Procedural History

Laguna Transportation and Lauro Lopez de Leon filed a complaint in interpleader before the Regional Trial Court of Laguna against Sanpiro, the Philippine National Bank, and Delta Motor Corporation, asking the court to determine which of the defendants was entitled to the monthly amortizations on fifteen diesel buses. Four days later, Sanpiro filed a complaint for replevin with damages before the Regional Trial Court of Makati against Laguna Transportation, de Leon, Francisco Magante, Delta, and John Does. The Makati court issued a writ of seizure, and the sheriff took six buses. Laguna Transportation moved to dismiss on the grounds of lack of cause of action and pendency of another action, and later filed an omnibus motion to set aside the writ and stop the scheduled sheriff's sale. When the Makati judge failed to resolve the omnibus motion, Laguna Transportation filed a petition for certiorari and prohibition before the Intermediate Appellate Court. The appellate court granted the petition, declared the writ of seizure null and void, ordered the buses returned, and directed the dismissal of the replevin case without prejudice. Sanpiro's amended motion for reconsideration was denied. Sanpiro then came to the Supreme Court by petition for review on certiorari.

Facts

From March to September 1980, Laguna Transportation and de Leon purchased five M.A.N. diesel buses from Delta Motor Corporation, covered by promissory notes and deeds of chattel mortgage. On February 27, 1981, Delta assigned to the Philippine National Bank, by way of security for letters of credit and other credit accommodations, the lien to be constituted in its favor from the sale on installments of units assembled from completely knocked down kits imported from the proceeds of the letter of credit accommodation. From July 1982 to July 1983, Laguna Transportation and de Leon bought eight more M.A.N. diesel buses from Delta, again covered by promissory notes and deeds of chattel mortgage.

On January 6, 1984, Delta executed a deed of assignment in favor of Sanpiro in the amount of 26,075,246 pesos and 60 centavos, transferring on a with recourse basis its rights over the instruments of indebtedness and the chattel and real estate mortgages securing them. On January 9, 1984, Delta executed another deed of assignment in favor of Sanpiro in the amount of 2,661,056 pesos and 38 centavos, in the same terms. In April and May 1984, the Philippine National Bank sent letters of demand to Laguna Transportation, enjoining it to make all payments directly to the bank and warning that the bank would not recognize any payments made to Delta. Meanwhile, Delta itself was demanding payment of the installments due, and on September 6, 1984, it sent a letter demanding immediate payment of the arrears. Laguna Transportation replied by bringing the bank's demand letters to Delta's attention. On September 25, 1984, Sanpiro also demanded payment.

Caught between conflicting claims, Laguna Transportation filed its interpleader complaint in Laguna on October 1, 1984. On October 4, 1984, Sanpiro filed its replevin complaint in Makati. The next day, the Makati court issued a writ of seizure, and on October 6, 1984, the sheriff took six buses. Laguna Transportation moved to dismiss and to discharge the writ, citing the pendency of the Laguna case. The Makati court ordered the surrender of the remaining seven buses, denied reconsideration, and set the sheriff's sale of the six buses for October 26, 1984. When the Makati judge failed to resolve the omnibus motion despite the urgency, Laguna Transportation went to the appellate court.

Issues

  • Whether or not the pendency of the interpleader case in the Regional Trial Court of Laguna is a ground for the dismissal of the replevin case in the Regional Trial Court of Makati under the rule on lis pendens.
  • Whether or not the Makati court acted with grave abuse of discretion in issuing the writ of seizure and ordering the sale of the buses despite its knowledge of the pending interpleader case.

Applicable Provisions

The decision applies the requisites of lis pendens as the Court itself states them:

The requisites for lis pendens are: (1) identity of parties, or at least such as representing the same interests in both actions; (2) identity of rights asserted and reliefs prayed for, the reliefs being founded on the same facts; and (3) identity in both cases is such that the judgment that may be rendered in the pending case would, regardless of which party is successful, amount to res judicata in the other.

These requisites are the test the Court applies to decide whether the Makati replevin case must yield to the earlier Laguna interpleader case.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held that all three requisites of lis pendens are present. On identity of parties, the Court found that Sanpiro, Laguna Transportation, de Leon, and Delta are parties in both cases, and that the addition of the Philippine National Bank, Mauro Vera Cruz, and Francisco Magante does not alter the situation. On identity of rights and reliefs, the Court held that in both cases the rights asserted spring from the deed of assignment executed by Delta in favor of the bank and the deeds of assignment executed by Delta in favor of Sanpiro, that these deeds covered the very same debts of Laguna Transportation and de Leon, and that both the bank and Sanpiro were demanding payment of the very same debts. On res judicata, the Court held that if the Laguna court should rule that the assignment to the bank prevails over the assignment to Sanpiro, that judgment would be binding on the Makati case and would leave Sanpiro's cause of action without basis.

On the second issue, the Court held that the Makati court acted with precipitate haste, imprudence, and lack of judicial caution, amounting to grave abuse of discretion, in ordering the seizure of the buses while fully aware of the pendency of the Laguna case. The Court quoted with approval the appellate court's observation that Sanpiro can make no claim that it owns the vehicles, and that until the question is resolved as to which assignment should prevail, Sanpiro cannot be considered to have established a clear right to possession. The Court stressed that the earlier assignment to the bank, made in 1981, may even be the stronger probability against an assignment of the same credit made three years later, and that to bestow absolute recognition on Sanpiro's alleged right of possession was a glaring disregard of the comity and respect due to a co-equal court.

Doctrine

For the Bar candidate, the rules to retain are these. First, lis pendens requires identity of parties, identity of rights asserted and reliefs prayed for founded on the same facts, and identity such that any judgment in the pending case would amount to res judicata in the other. Second, the addition or elimination of parties does not destroy identity of parties where the same interests are represented. Third, where two courts of equal standing are involved, the court that first takes cognizance of the controversy acquires jurisdiction to the exclusion of the other, and the second court commits grave abuse of discretion in proceeding, especially by seizing property, with full knowledge of the pending case. Fourth, a party claiming under a later assignment of the same credit cannot be deemed to have a clear right to possession while the priority of assignments remains unresolved in the earlier case.

Disposition

The Supreme Court denied the petition, with costs against Sanpiro, thereby affirming the appellate court's annulment of the writ of seizure, the return of the buses to Laguna Transportation, and the dismissal of the Makati replevin case without prejudice.

Remember This

Memorize this line: the court that first takes cognizance of a controversy acquires jurisdiction over it to the exclusion of co-equal courts, and proceeding despite knowledge of the pending case is grave abuse of discretion. Examiners use this case to test the requisites of lis pendens, the rule on priority of jurisdiction between co-equal courts, and the limits of a replevin suit brought by an assignee of a credit already assigned to another.