🎧 Case Brief Lecture

IN THE MATTER OF THE PETITION OF J. GARCIA BOSQUE FOR ADMISSION TO THE PRACTICE OF LAW IN THE PHILIPPINE ISLANDS.

G.R. No. 666. January 14, 1902 January 14, 1902

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

Bosque versus the Philippine Islands

The Case

This is In the Matter of the Petition of J. Garcia Bosque for Admission to the Practice of Law in the Philippine Islands, one of the earliest and most instructive rulings of the Supreme Court of the Philippines on citizenship and on who may lawfully practice law in the Islands. Bosque, a Spaniard who was residing in the Philippines when sovereignty over the archipelago passed from Spain to the United States under the Treaty of Paris of December 10, 1898, asked the Court to admit him to the practice of law. The Court had to decide whether he had become a Filipino subject by operation of the treaty, or whether he remained a Spanish subject, and whether, as a Spanish subject, he could be admitted to the bar. The case matters because it fixes the rule on the right of option of Spanish subjects under Article 9 of the Treaty of Paris, and because it holds that the practice of law is a profession for which the law requires a diploma of proficiency granted by the authorities, so that foreign residents cannot engage in it.

Procedural History

The case reached the Supreme Court as a petition for admission to the practice of law in the Philippine Islands. Bosque had earlier presented a petition for the same purpose, and the Court, in the decision now before us, refers to the present application as a new petition. The Court, speaking through Chief Justice Arellano, resolved the petition directly and denied it. There was no intermediate appellate court in the path of the case; the matter was decided by the Supreme Court itself.

Facts

By the Treaty of Paris of December 10, 1898, Spain ceded the Philippine Archipelago to the United States. The treaty gave the subjects of the ceding power a right of option. They could elect to leave the country and free themselves of subjection to the new sovereign, or they could continue to reside in the territory. If they chose to reside, the lapse of eighteen months without an express declaration of intention to retain Spanish nationality resulted in the loss of that nationality, and they became subjects of the new sovereign in the same manner as the natives of the Islands.

The period of eighteen months began to run from the exchange of the ratifications of the treaty, on April 11, 1899, and expired in October 1900. Bosque left the Islands on May 30, 1899, and remained absent during the whole period. He returned to the Islands in January 1901, after the period had expired.

Bosque then petitioned for admission to the practice of law in the Philippine Islands. The question was whether he was a Filipino subject, and if not, whether a Spanish subject could be admitted to the bar.

Issues

  • Whether or not Bosque lost his Spanish nationality and became a Filipino subject by reason of his absence from the Islands during the period fixed by the Treaty of Paris and his failure to make an express declaration of intention to preserve his Spanish nationality.
  • Whether or not Spanish subjects resident in the Islands constitute an intermediate class between other foreign residents and the natives of the country, in whose behalf specially favorable conditions were stipulated.
  • Whether or not Bosque, as a Spanish subject on the same footing as other foreign residents, could be admitted to the practice of law in the Philippine Islands.

Applicable Provisions

Article 9 of the Treaty of Paris provides:

Spanish subjects, natives of the Peninsula, residing in the territory over which Spain by the present treaty relinquishes or cedes her sovereignty, may remain in such territory or may remove therefrom, retaining in either event all their rights of property, including the right to sell or dispose of such property or of its proceeds; and they shall also have the right to carry on their industry, commerce and professions, being subject in respect thereof to such laws as are applicable to other foreigners.

This provision is the source of the right of option and of the rule that Spanish subjects who remain are subject, in the practice of their professions, to the same laws as other foreigners.

Article 5 of the royal decree of May 11, 1901, cited by the Court, provides:

Persons who are natives or residents of the ceded or relinquished territories can not, in their relations with the Government or authorities of such territories, lay claim to Spanish nationality preserved or recovered by virtue of said decree, except with the consent of such Government, or under treaty stipulations.

This shows that the Spanish Government itself treats the dates fixed in the treaty as the starting point, and that the courts of the Islands should not give the presumptive nationality under Article 9 an extent not warranted by its conditions.

Article 27 of the Civil Code, also cited, provides:

Foreigners in Spain shall enjoy the rights which the civil laws accord to Spaniards, subject to the provisions of article 2 of the constitution of the State.

This confirms that foreigners, including Spanish subjects in the ceded territory, are subject to the same limitations as other foreigners.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held that Bosque did not lose his Spanish nationality and did not become a Filipino subject. The conditions for the presumptive change of nationality were residence in the ceded territory and the lapse of eighteen months without an express declaration to the contrary. Bosque left the Islands on May 30, 1899, and remained absent during the whole period, so neither condition was fulfilled. By absenting himself from the territory, he elected the first of the two courses open to him under his right of option, and he continued to be a Spaniard. The Court explained that the declaration of intention to preserve Spanish nationality is required only to overcome the effect of continued residence, which in itself implies subjection to the new sovereign. Without residence in fact, the declaration is of no significance.

On the second issue, the Court held that Spanish subjects resident in the Islands do not constitute an intermediate class between other foreign residents and the natives. No such proposition was made in the discussions preceding the treaty. The American Commissioners simply said that Spanish subjects, natives of Spain, have the fullest right to dispose of their property and remove from the territory or remain therein, to continue to be Spanish subjects or elect the nationality of the new territory. They also have the right to carry on their industry, commerce, and profession, subject to such laws as are applicable to other foreigners.

On the third issue, the Court held that Bosque, as a Spanish subject on the same footing as other foreign residents, could not practice law. The laws applicable to other foreigners were the Law of Foreigners for the Ultramarine Provinces of July 4, 1870, and Article 27 of the Civil Code. The Law of Foreigners authorized foreigners to engage in any kind of industry and to practice any profession for which the laws did not require a diploma of proficiency granted by the Spanish authorities. The legal profession is one for which the law required such a diploma. Hence, if other foreigners could not then engage in the practice of law, and by the express prohibition of the Code of Civil Procedure in force could not do so at the present time, neither could Spanish subjects, who were in every respect upon the same footing as other foreigners.

Doctrine

The following rules must be retained:

  • Right of option under the Treaty of Paris. Spanish subjects residing in the ceded territory could elect to leave the country and free themselves of subjection to the new sovereign, or to remain. The lapse of eighteen months from the exchange of ratifications, without an express declaration of intention to preserve Spanish nationality, resulted in the loss of that nationality and the acquisition of the nationality of the new sovereign.
  • Residence is indispensable to the presumptive change of nationality. The conditions for the change are residence in the ceded territory and failure to make an express declaration to the contrary within the period fixed. Absence from the territory during the whole period means the person elected to leave and continued to be a Spaniard. The declaration of intention is required only to overcome the effect of continued residence.
  • No intermediate class. Spanish subjects resident in the Islands are on the same footing as other foreign residents. They do not constitute a class between foreigners and natives.
  • The practice of law requires a diploma of proficiency. The legal profession is one for which the law requires a diploma granted by the authorities. Foreigners, including Spanish subjects, cannot engage in it, being subject to the same laws as other foreigners.

Disposition

The Court denied Bosque's new petition for admission to the bar of the Philippine Islands.

Remember This

The single line worth memorizing is that the presumptive change of nationality under Article 9 of the Treaty of Paris requires residence in the ceded territory coupled with failure to make an express declaration to the contrary within the period fixed; absence during the whole period means the person elected to remain a Spaniard. Examiners use this case to test the right of option of Spanish subjects under the Treaty of Paris and the rule that the practice of law is a profession for which the law requires a diploma of proficiency, so that foreign residents cannot be admitted to the bar.