🎧 Case Brief Lecture

MANILA GOLF & COUNTRY CLUB, INC. PETITIONER, VS. INTERMEDIATE APPELLATE COURT AND FERMIN LLAMAR, RESPONDENTS.

G.R. No. 64948. September 27, 1994 September 27, 1994

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

Manila Golf and Country Club versus Intermediate Appellate Court

The Case

This is a petition for review brought by the Manila Golf and Country Club against the Intermediate Appellate Court and Fermin Llamar. The question is whether caddies who render services to club members and their guests on the club's golf course are employees of the club, and therefore within the compulsory coverage of the Social Security System. The case matters because it fixes the control test as the decisive measure of employment in social security coverage, and because it teaches that a certification election ruling does not bar a later adjudication of the same employment question.

Procedural History

Fermin Llamar and sixteen others, styling themselves caddies of the club affiliated with a labor organization, filed a petition with the Social Security Commission for coverage and benefits under the Social Security Act. All but two withdrew; the case proceeded only as to Fermin Llamar and Raymundo Jomok. The Commission dismissed the petition for lack of merit, holding that the caddies were not employees of the club. Llamar appealed to the Intermediate Appellate Court. Jomok later withdrew his appeal, leaving Llamar as the lone appellant. The Intermediate Appellate Court reversed the Commission, declared Llamar an employee of the club, and ordered that he be reported for social security coverage and paid the corresponding benefits. The club then came to the Supreme Court by petition for review.

Facts

The caddies were allowed into the club premises to render caddying services to individual members and guests playing the golf course. The players themselves paid the caddies' fees, not the club. A player issued a caddy's claim stub, and the management kept the other portion so it would know how much a caddy was to be paid. The caddies observed no definite working hours and earned no fixed income; their earnings depended on the number of players engaging them and on the players' liberality.

The club promulgated rules and regulations on the assignment, deportment, and conduct of caddies, and maintained a group rotation system assigning each caddy a number for his turn to serve. The club also suggested the rate of fees payable to the caddies. The club issued identification cards to accredited caddies, which could be withdrawn anytime for loss of confidence.

Three proceedings on the same employment question arose almost simultaneously: a certification election case, where the Med-Arbiter found an employer-employee relationship and was upheld by the Director of the Bureau of Labor Relations; a compulsory arbitration case, dismissed for lack of merit by the Labor Arbiter and affirmed by the National Labor Relations Commission on the ground that no employer-employee relationship existed; and the social security case before the Commission. Llamar invoked the favorable certification ruling as res adjudicata before the appellate court.

Issues

  • Whether or not the decision in the certification election case operates as res adjudicata on the question of employer-employee relationship between the club and the caddies.
  • Whether or not the caddies rendering services to members and guests are employees of the club under the control test, so as to be within compulsory social security coverage.

Applicable Provisions

The decision applies the control test as the decisive standard for the existence of an employer-employee relationship, expressed in the rule quoted by the appellate court and adopted in the discussion:

Whether the employer controls or has reserved the right to control the employee not only as to the result of the work to be done but also as to the means and methods by which the same is to be accomplished.

This test bears on the case because the caddies' coverage under the Social Security Act depends entirely on whether such control existed.

On res adjudicata, the Court states the requisites of bar by prior judgment:

There must be a final judgment or order; said judgment or order must be on the merits; the court rendering the same must have jurisdiction over the subject matter and the parties; and there must be between the two cases identity of parties, identity of subject matter and identity of cause of action.

These requisites bear on the case because the certification ruling invoked by Llamar must satisfy all four, including the requirement of a contentious proceeding.

On the nature of a certification proceeding, the Court quotes its own prior ruling:

A certification proceeding is not a litigation in the sense in which this term is commonly understood, but a mere investigation of a non-adversary, fact-finding character, in which the investigating agency plays the part of a disinterested investigator seeking merely to ascertain the desires of the employees as to the matter of their representation.

This bears on the case because a non-adversarial proceeding cannot produce a judgment that bars a later action.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held that the certification case ruling does not operate as res adjudicata. For bar by prior judgment to apply, the prior proceeding must be adversarial or contentious, one having opposing parties and affording the other side notice and an opportunity to contest. A certification proceeding is a mere investigation of a non-adversary, fact-finding character. The Court added that if any ruling could operate as res adjudicata, it would be that of the compulsory arbitration case, where the issue was squarely litigated and the Labor Arbiter and the National Labor Relations Commission both found no employment relationship. The Court also declined to let Llamar benefit from the conflicting rulings, since he actively sought them simultaneously from separate fora.

On the second issue, the Court held that no employer-employee relationship existed. The club's rules on conduct, dress, and language did not so circumscribe the caddies' actions as to leave them little or no freedom in carrying out their services. Caddies must submit to some supervision while enjoying the privilege of working within club premises, but they observed no working hours, were free to leave anytime, and could stay away as long as they liked. The only discipline was barring them from the premises, which the club could do in any case. The suggestion of fee rates showed the club lacked the measure of control an employer would possess. The group rotation system was less a measure of employee control than an assurance that work is fairly distributed. The club had no means of compelling a caddy's presence, and a player could choose any caddy regardless of rotation.

Doctrine

First, the control test is decisive: an employer-employee relationship exists only where the employer controls or has reserved the right to control the employee not only as to the result of the work but also as to the means and methods by which it is accomplished. Second, the mere promulgation of rules on conduct, dress, and discipline, the maintenance of a rotation system, and the suggestion of fee rates do not amount to such control where the workers observe no working hours, earn no fixed income, are paid by third persons, and may be barred from the premises at will. Third, for res adjudicata to bar a later action, the prior judgment must be final, on the merits, rendered by a court with jurisdiction, and there must be identity of parties, subject matter, and cause of action; implicit in these requisites is that the prior proceeding be adversarial. A certification proceeding, being a non-adversary fact-finding investigation, cannot operate as res adjudicata.

Disposition

The Court reversed and set aside the decision of the Intermediate Appellate Court, declared that Fermin Llamar is not an employee of the Manila Golf and Country Club, and held that the club is under no obligation to report him for compulsory coverage to the Social Security System.

Remember This

Memorize this line: the control test is decisive, and a certification proceeding is not a litigation, so it cannot bar a later suit. Examiners use this case to test the control test in social security coverage and the requisites of res adjudicata against a certification election ruling.