SAFIRO CATALAN AND GERARDO SERUE, PETITIONERS, VS. TITO F. GENILO, RICARDO C. CASTRO, CECILIO T. SENO, FEDERICO O. BORROMEO, GRAPHIC ARTS SERVICES, INC., RESPONDENTS.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Catalan versus Graphic Arts Services
The Case
This is Catalan versus Graphic Arts Services, a petition for certiorari brought by two dismissed rank-and-file employees, Safiro Catalan and Gerardo Serue, against their employer Graphic Arts Services, Incorporated, and against the labor officials who upheld their dismissal. The petitioners ask the Supreme Court to set aside the rulings of the Labor Arbiter and of the National Labor Relations Commission, which sustained their termination for allegedly drinking inside company premises. The case matters because it is the classic teaching vehicle on the employee's constitutional right to security of tenure, on the strict reading of company rules before they may be used as a ground for dismissal, and on the rule that procedural technicality must yield to substantial justice.
Procedural History
The petitioners first filed a complaint for illegal dismissal with the Ministry of Labor and Employment. The Labor Arbiter, Tito Genilo, rendered a decision dismissing the complaint, although he directed the company to pay each complainant one-half salary for every year of service. The petitioners appealed to the National Labor Relations Commission. The Commission, through a resolution promulgated in July 1981, dismissed the appeal outright, not on the merits, but because the appellants failed to show that a copy of the appeal had been served on the adverse party. The petitioners then filed a petition for relief from judgment, which the Commission treated as a motion for reconsideration; in August 1982 the Commission denied it, saying it found no valid reason to disturb the appealed decision. The petitioners came to the Supreme Court by petition for certiorari. The Second Division gave due course to the petition and required simultaneous memoranda, which the parties submitted.
Facts
Safiro Catalan had worked as a press helper for almost eight months, and Gerardo Serue as a stitcher for more than one year. Both were regular employees. Their workshift ran from midnight to eight in the morning. On the morning of 3 July 1979, feeling tired after working the whole night, they had a few bottles of beer at a sari-sari store about fifty meters from the company compound, to relax before going home. They became engrossed in conversation and noticed it was almost lunchtime. Since the store served no lunch, they headed for the company canteen. The security guard at the gate let them in, as employees commonly entered the premises even when off duty.
Inside the canteen they ordered food. Before they could finish eating, the security guard came and ordered them out, allegedly by order of management. They stood up, paid for their order, left the canteen, and went out of the premises. When they later reported for work, they received a memorandum requiring them to explain why they should not be terminated for violating company rules. They submitted their explanations on 8 July 1979. The next day, 9 July 1979, they were served memoranda terminating their services effective 25 July 1979. The company's stated ground was drinking in the company premises or coming to work under the influence of alcohol, which its rules punished with immediate dismissal. The company filed applications for clearance to terminate them, and the petitioners filed a complaint for illegal dismissal.
The company's version was that the two sneaked into the compound drunk at about two in the afternoon, proceeded to the canteen, and caused trouble. The Labor Arbiter, however, found that the petitioners drank beer outside the compound after their tour of duty and came in only to eat lunch, a fact supported by the company personnel's own report that found Serue eating in the canteen.
Issues
- Whether or not the dismissal of the petitioners for alleged violation of company regulations is justified.
- Whether or not the failure to furnish the adverse party a copy of the appeal warrants the outright dismissal of an otherwise meritorious appeal.
Applicable Provisions
The decision rests on the constitutional guarantee of security of tenure, which it invokes in these terms: the right of an employee to security of tenure is protected by the Constitution and must be respected unless a just cause exists for the termination of employment. The company rule itself, quoted in the decision, provides:
DRINKING IN THE COMPANY PREMISES OR COMING TO WORK UNDER THE INFLUENCE OF ALCOHOL …… IMMEDIATE DISMISSAL.
This rule is the very ground invoked by the employer, and the case turns on whether the petitioners actually violated it.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the outright dismissal is not justified. While violation of a lawful and reasonable company rule is a just cause for dismissal, the application of the rule must be done without abuse of discretion, for what is at stake is not only the worker's position but his means of livelihood. Here, no actual violation was committed: the petitioners did not drink beer in the company premises, and they did not report for work under the influence of liquor because it was not their tour of duty. Their obedience in leaving the premises when ordered negates any deliberate intent to defy company rules. The Court quoted its own rule from the Batangas Laguna Tayabas Bus case:
However, in order to constitute disobedience, the employee's conduct must have been willful or intentional, willfulness being characterized by a wrongful and perverse mental attitude rendering the employee's act inconsistent with proper subordination.
The Court added that this was, at most, a first offense and an isolated incident, since the petitioners had no previous violation; the outright imposition of the supreme penalty of dismissal is not commensurate with the misconduct. The company suffered no material injury, and the claim of unusual noise was not substantiated. Even assuming a violation, dismissal was too harsh a penalty.
On the second issue, the Court held that the failure to furnish the respondent a copy of the appeal is a mere technicality not warranting outright dismissal of a meritorious appeal. The Commission never touched the merits and relied only on that absence of proof of service. Since the appealed decision was rendered with grave abuse of discretion amounting to lack or excess of jurisdiction, it may be set aside on certiorari.
Doctrine
First, an employee's right to security of tenure is constitutionally protected and may be defeated only by a just cause, the existence and sufficiency of which must be determined with fairness and in good faith. Second, a company rule punishing drinking in the premises or coming to work under the influence of alcohol is violated only when the employee actually drinks within the premises or reports for duty intoxicated; drinking outside the premises while off duty is not a violation. Third, disobedience as a ground for dismissal must be willful or intentional, characterized by a wrongful and perverse mental attitude, and the rule violated must be reasonable, lawful, known to the employee, and related to his duties. Fourth, the penalty must be commensurate with the offense; a first, isolated infraction does not warrant the supreme penalty of dismissal. Fifth, procedural technicality, such as failure to serve a copy of the appeal on the adverse party, must yield to substantial justice and cannot justify dismissing a meritorious appeal.
Disposition
The Court set aside the Labor Arbiter's decision and the two resolutions of the National Labor Relations Commission for grave abuse of discretion, and ordered the petitioners reinstated with three years of backwages.
Remember This
Memorize the line that a company rule must be applied without abuse of discretion, for what is at stake is not only the worker's position but his means of livelihood. Examiners use this case on security of tenure, on the requisites of willful disobedience as a just cause, and on the proportionality of the penalty to a first offense.