🎧 Case Brief Lecture

MANUEL GARCIA GAVIERES, PLAINTIFF AND APPELLANT, VS. T. H. PARDO DE TAVERA, DEFENDANT AND APPELLEE.

G.R. No. 6. November 14, 1901 November 14, 1901

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

Gavieres versus Pardo de Tavera

The Case

This is an action by Don Manuel Garcia Gavieres, as successor in interest of the deceased Doña Ignacia de Gorricho, against Don Trinidad H. Pardo de Tavera, as universal heir of the deceased Don Felix Pardo de Tavera, to collect the unpaid balance of an obligation originally fixed at 3,000 pesos. The plaintiff says the money was a deposit; the defendant says it was a loan, already paid and, in any event, long since extinguished by prescription. The case matters because it shows how the Court characterizes a contract by its substance rather than its label, and how lapse of time and the death of the parties shape the proof a court will accept.

Procedural History

The action was commenced on the tenth of January 1900 in the Court of First Instance of Tondo. That court ruled against the plaintiff, holding that the writing evidenced a loan rather than a deposit, that the action had prescribed, and that in any event the debt had been paid. The plaintiff appealed. The appeal came before the Supreme Court, which affirmed the judgment of the Court of First Instance, with the costs of appeal taxed against the appellant.

Facts

On the thirty-first of January 1859, Don Felix Pardo de Tavera signed a writing in Binondo acknowledging that he had received from Doña Ignacia de Gorricho the sum of 3,000 pesos in gold, as a deposit payable upon two months' notice in advance, with interest at six per cent per annum, secured by a hypothecation of the goods he then owned or might thereafter own.

Nearly a half century later, the contracting parties having long since died, the plaintiff as successor in interest of Doña Ignacia sued the defendant as universal heir of Don Felix for a balance of 1,423 pesos and 75 cents, said to remain due on the original obligation.

The defendant resisted on three grounds: that the writing was not a deposit but a loan; that the original obligation had been paid; and that the action had prescribed. On the question of payment, the record showed a document dated the eighth of January 1869, executed by Don Felix Garcia Gavieres, husband and legal representative of Doña Ignacia, acknowledging receipt of 1,224 pesos from Don Manuel Darvin, representative of the deceased Don Felix Pardo de Tavera, that sum being declared the balance due upon a debt of 2,000 pesos.

Issues

  • Whether or not the writing of January 1859 is a contract of deposit, as the plaintiff maintains, or a contract of loan, as the defendant contends.
  • Whether or not the action has been extinguished by prescription.
  • Whether or not the defense of payment has been sufficiently established.

Applicable Provisions

Article 1768 of the Civil Code provides:

Article 1768. A contract is onerous when each of the parties aspires to procure for himself a benefit through the giving of an equivalent.

The Court invokes this article to explain that once the depositary is allowed to make use of the money and to pay interest for that privilege, the contract ceases to be a deposit and takes on the character of a loan.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held that although the document speaks of a deposit, an examination of the entire writing shows that the contract was a loan and that such was the intention of the parties. The Court said it was unnecessary to recur to the canons of interpretation to reach this conclusion. The obligation of the depositary to pay interest at six per cent to the depositor sufficed to cause the obligation to be considered a loan, and made it evident that the parties intended the depositary to have the right to make use of the amount deposited, since it was stipulated that the amount could be collected after notice of two months in advance. The contract therefore lost the character of a deposit and acquired that of a loan.

On the second issue, the Court held that all personal actions, such as those arising from a contract of loan, cease to have legal effect after twenty years under the former law and after fifteen years under the Civil Code then in force. The document is dated the thirty-first of January 1859, and the action was brought in January 1900, well beyond either period.

On the third issue, the Court considered the proof of payment sufficient to establish the defense. The document of the eighth of January 1869 acknowledged receipt of 1,224 pesos, declared to be the balance due upon a debt of 2,000 pesos, which was slightly more or less the amount remaining due upon the original obligation after the admitted payments. In the absence of evidence of other claims in favor of Gavieres, it was reasonably to be supposed that the payment was made to satisfy the balance due upon the original obligation. The Court added that he who by laches in the exercise of his rights has caused a failure of proof has no right to complain if the court does not apply the strict rules of evidence applicable in ordinary cases, and admits to a certain extent the presumption to which the conduct of the interested party himself naturally gives rise.

Doctrine

A contract is characterized by its substance and by the intention of the parties, not by the name they give it. Where the recipient of money is bound to pay interest to the giver and may make use of the amount, the contract is a loan, not a deposit, and the deposit label will not control.

Personal actions arising from a contract of loan are extinguished by prescription, after twenty years under the former law and after fifteen years under the Civil Code.

A party whose own delay has made proof impossible cannot demand that the court apply the strict rules of evidence; the court may admit the presumptions that the conduct of the interested party naturally suggests.

Disposition

The Supreme Court affirmed the judgment of the Court of First Instance, with costs of appeal taxed against the appellant, so the defendant prevailed.

Remember This

The single line to memorize is that the name the parties give a contract does not make it so; interest and the right to use the money turn a deposit into a loan. Examiners use this case to test the deposit-versus-loan distinction and the effect of prescription and laches on the proof a court will accept.