JUANA MORENO FRANCISCO, PLAINTIFF AND APPELLEE, VS. JOSE MANUEL GRUET, DEFENDANT AND APPELLANT.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Francisco versus Gruet
The Case
This is Francisco versus Gruet, an early decision of the Philippine Supreme Court under the Code of Civil Procedure of 1901. Juana Moreno Francisco, the plaintiff and appellee, sought to dismiss the appeal taken by Jose Manuel Gruet, the defendant and appellant, from an order of the Court of First Instance removing him as guardian. The case is not about guardianship at all. It is about procedure — specifically, the two radically different methods the Code provides for bringing a case up to the Supreme Court: the bill of exceptions for ordinary suits, and the appeal for special proceedings. The Court uses this motion to dismiss to teach when each method applies, and how strictly, or how leniently, defects in perfecting an appeal will be treated.
Procedural History
The case began in the Court of First Instance, which entered an order removing the appellant as guardian. That order was issued in the exercise of the court's jurisdiction over special proceedings concerning the administration of guardians. From that order, the appellant sought to come up to the Supreme Court. He did so by way of a bill of exceptions, not by an appeal. The appellee moved to dismiss the appeal on the ground that the wrong mode was used. The Supreme Court, speaking through Justice Willard, denied the motion to dismiss but imposed conditions. Justice Cooper dissented.
Facts
The Court of First Instance removed Jose Manuel Gruet as guardian. Wishing to challenge that order, the appellant presented to the court a notice of appeal. The judge, however, told him that an appeal was not the proper remedy in that case, and gave him ten days within which to present a bill of exceptions. The appellant prepared a bill of exceptions, which the judge signed. In that bill it was stated that the appellant, upon being notified of the order, appealed. There also appears in the record an order admitting the appeal.
The appellant also gave a bond in the sum of three thousand dollars, which the judge approved. But the bond was conditioned on the performance of the judgment by the appellant in case it was affirmed. It should have been conditioned on his prosecuting the appeal and paying the damages and costs occasioned by it.
At the hearing, it was stated that the clerk had not sent to the Supreme Court a certified copy of the evidence introduced, as the rules required. It was also stated that the appellant had never served his assignment of errors and brief on the appellee as required by the rules; the appellant answered that these were included in the bill of exceptions, which had been served.
Issues
- Whether or not the order removing a guardian, entered in special proceedings, should have been brought to the Supreme Court by appeal rather than by bill of exceptions.
- Whether or not the appellant substantially complied with the requirements for perfecting an appeal in special proceedings, namely a notice of appeal and a bond.
- Whether or not the appeal should be dismissed because of the defective condition of the bond.
- Whether or not the appeal should be dismissed because the record was incomplete and the brief and assignment of errors were not separately served.
Applicable Provisions
Article 783 of the Code of Civil Procedure, which governs appeals from final orders in special proceedings, provides:
Article 783. Final orders in testate or intestate estates and the administration of guardians and trustees may be appealed from.
This is the provision under which the order removing the guardian should have been brought up, by appeal and not by bill of exceptions.
Article 780, on the bond required for such an appeal, provides:
Article 780. The appellant must give a satisfactory bond to the court conditioned that he will prosecute the appeal to effect and pay the intervening damages and costs occasioned by such appeal.
This is the condition the appellant's bond failed to follow.
Article 500, on defects of form, provides:
Article 500. No bill of exceptions shall be dismissed for defects of form which do not affect the rights of the parties, nor for any defect which can be cured.
The Court extends this rule by analogy to appeals, so that a curable defect in the bond does not warrant dismissal.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the order removing the guardian was entered in special proceedings, and so ought to have been brought up by appeal, not by bill of exceptions. The Code, the Court explained, points out two radically different methods: the bill of exceptions for ordinary suits, and the appeal for special proceedings. There is no general provision authorizing an appeal in all special proceedings; the appeal is confined to the specific cases enumerated, and this case falls under Article 783.
On the second issue, the Court found substantial compliance. As to the notice of appeal, what the appellant did amounted to a notice within the meaning of the law. As to the bond, one was in fact given and approved, though its condition was wrong.
On the third issue, the Court refused to dismiss. It applied Article 500 by analogy, reasoning that a bill of exceptions and an appeal are no more than different methods of accomplishing the same end, the removal of a suit from a lower to a higher court. If a bill of exceptions ought not to be dismissed for a curable defect of form, neither should an appeal.
On the fourth issue, the Court likewise refused to dismiss. Article 501 required it to suspend the hearing until the record was complete, not to dismiss. And the appellant's mistake of placing his brief and assignment of errors in the bill of exceptions, though improper, did not prejudice the appellee, who had been served.
Doctrine
A Bar candidate should retain these rules. First, under the Code of Civil Procedure, the bill of exceptions is the mode for ordinary suits, while the appeal is the mode for special proceedings; an order removing a guardian is a final order in special proceedings and must be brought up by appeal. Second, defects of form in perfecting an appeal that do not affect the rights of the parties, and that can be cured, do not warrant dismissal, by analogy to Article 500. Third, an incomplete record is not a ground for dismissal; the Court must suspend the hearing until the record is complete.
Disposition
The motion to dismiss the appeal was denied, but the appellant was required, within twenty days, to file a bond conditioned as Article 780 requires, failing which the appeal would be dismissed; the clerk was ordered to transmit the evidence, and the brief and assignment of errors in the bill of exceptions were treated as the appellant's brief.
Remember This
Memorize the line that the Code provides two radically different methods for bringing cases to the Supreme Court — the bill of exceptions for ordinary suits and the appeal for special proceedings. Examiners use this case to test the distinction between ordinary actions and special proceedings, and the rule that curable defects of form do not justify dismissal of an appeal.