🎧 Case Brief Lecture

THE UNITED STATES, COMPLAINANT AND APPELLANT, VS. ANASTASIO CARMONAN DEFENDANT AND APPELLEE.

G.R. No. 596. August 19, 1902 August 19, 1902

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

United States versus Carmona

The Case

This is a criminal case in which the Government of the United States prosecuted Anastasio Carmona, a captain in the so-called insurrectionary army, for the killing of a tailor named Marcelo Blas. The trial court acquitted him of the charge of asesinato, or murder, yet the case still reached the Supreme Court on appeal, and both the Solicitor-General and counsel for the defendant joined in asking the Court to declare the accused covered by the President's amnesty proclamation. The case matters because it is an early statement of how the Court reads the phrase "offenses political in their character" in an amnesty proclamation, and of when a killing committed in the course of an insurrection counts as a political offense rather than a private crime.

Procedural History

The defendant was tried for asesinato in the court below and was acquitted. The case was then brought to the Supreme Court on appeal. While it was pending there, the Solicitor-General and counsel for the defendant filed a joint petition asking that the defendant be declared embraced within the President's amnesty proclamation of July 4 of that year. The Supreme Court resolved that petition in this decision.

Facts

Anastasio Carmona was a captain in the so-called insurrectionary army. Acting in that capacity, he issued an order to four soldiers under his command to lie in wait for the deceased, a tailor named Marcelo Blas, at a place known as Maytubig, in the district of Malate, in the city of Manila, and to arrest him as a spy in the service of the Americans and the police.

In pursuance of that order, the soldiers lay in wait at the designated place. On the afternoon of the third of October, 1900, Blas passed by, accompanied by his wife and one Domingo Tansio. After a short conversation, in which the soldiers told him that their superior officer wanted his measure taken for a suit of clothes, and Blas refused to go because it was too late, two of the men threw themselves upon him and stabbed him to death, leaving his body in the middle of the road.

The record also showed uncontradicted evidence that an insurrectionary officer superior in command to the defendant had issued an order directing the arrest of all Filipino spies. The Court found the conclusion entirely warranted that the defendant, in commanding the arrest of the deceased, was acting in pursuance of that order.

Issues

  • Whether or not the defendant, having participated in the insurrection against the Government of the United States, comes within the classes of persons to whom the amnesty is extended by the President's proclamation.
  • Whether or not the killing of the deceased, committed in the course of the insurrection, pursuant to orders of insurrectionary military authorities, and for military purposes in the interest of the insurrection, falls within the designation of offenses political in their character as that expression is used in the proclamation.

Applicable Provisions

The President's amnesty proclamation of July 4, as the Court quotes it, extends the amnesty to offenses of a certain description:

Offenses political in their character.

This is the phrase the Court construes, and the whole question is whether a killing done in the course of the insurrection answers that description.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held that the defendant, having participated in the insurrection against the Government of the United States, comes within the description in the proclamation of the classes of persons to whom the amnesty is extended. The crime of which he is guilty, if he is guilty of any crime of which he can be convicted upon the complaint in this case, belongs also to one of the classes of offense covered by the proclamation.

On the second issue, the Court held that the offense was committed in the course of the insurrection against the Government of the United States; that it was committed pursuant to orders issued by insurrectionary military authorities; and that it was committed for military purposes in the interest of the insurrection, and without any motive of private revenge or hatred whatever, so far as the record discloses. It therefore falls within the designation of offenses political in their character, as that expression is used in the proclamation, even placing upon the words the narrowest interpretation of which they are in any possible view susceptible.

The Court accordingly declared the defendant entitled to the benefit of the proclamation upon filing in the Supreme Court the oath prescribed therein as a condition of the amnesty.

Doctrine

An offense is political in character, within the meaning of an amnesty proclamation, when it is committed in the course of an insurrection against the Government, pursuant to orders issued by insurrectionary military authorities, and for military purposes in the interest of the insurrection, without any motive of private revenge or hatred. Where those elements are present, the offense falls within the amnesty even on the narrowest reading of the words "offenses political in their character." A participant in the insurrection who commits such an offense belongs both to the class of persons and to the class of offenses covered by the proclamation. For the Bar candidate, the rule to write is that the political character of an offense is determined by its connection to the insurrection and its military purpose, not by the name of the crime charged.

Disposition

The Court declared the defendant entitled to the benefit of the amnesty proclamation upon filing the prescribed oath, and directed that upon such filing the cause be returned to the court below with directions that the defendant be discharged, with costs de oficio, meaning costs at the expense of the public.

Remember This

The line worth memorizing is that a killing committed in the course of an insurrection, under insurrectionary orders and for military purposes, without private revenge or hatred, is an offense political in character and is covered by the amnesty. Examiners use this case to test the definition of a political offense and the reach of an amnesty proclamation over acts done in furtherance of an insurrection.