THE UNITED STATES, COMPLAINANT AND APPELLEE, VS. ISIDRO GUZMAN ET AL., DEFENDANTS AND APPELLANTS.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
United States versus Guzman
The Case
This is a criminal case in which the Government of the United States, as complainant and appellee, prosecuted Isidro Guzman and Jose Guzman for the murder of Lieutenant Salvador Piera of the Spanish army, committed in the district of Isabela in the closing months of 1898. The accused were convicted of murder in the Court of First Instance of Isabela and sentenced to life imprisonment, damages, and costs, and the case came before the Supreme Court on their appeal. What makes the case matter is that the Supreme Court did not decide the appeal on the evidence of the killing at all. It decided a question of sovereign power: whether a general amnesty proclaimed by the President of the United States reaches a crime of murder that was committed out of political hatred during the revolution against Spain. The Court held that it does, and ordered the accused set at liberty. The case is therefore a foundational Philippine authority on the legal force of an amnesty and on how courts must treat a valid exercise of the pardoning power.
Procedural History
The two accused were tried in the Court of First Instance of Isabela on a charge of murder. On the sixth of January of that year, the trial court rendered judgment convicting them and condemning them to life imprisonment, to the payment of damages, and to the costs. The accused appealed to the Supreme Court. While the appeal was pending, their counsel, Mr. W. A. Kincaid, filed a motion asking that the two accused be given the benefits of a general amnesty proclaimed by the President of the United States on the fourth of July of that year, and that the case be dismissed with costs de oficio, meaning costs at the expense of the government. The Supreme Court resolved that motion in the decision now before us.
Facts
Around the end of September or the beginning of October of 1898, Major Simeon Villa of the revolutionary army, commanding officer of the forces occupying the district of Isabela, arrived at Ilagan. Lieutenant Salvador Piera of the Spanish army was at that time a prisoner of the revolutionary forces in Aparri. Villa telegraphed Colonel Tiron to send Piera to him in order to take Piera's deposition. According to the prosecution, Villa did this at the instigation of Dimas Guzman, who wanted revenge on Piera because Piera had been the judge in a military prosecution brought against Guzman in 1897 on political grounds.
When Lieutenant Piera arrived at the house where Major Villa resided, Villa and the accused, Isidro and Jose Guzman, beat and kicked him and clubbed him with their guns. They then tied his arms behind his back and hung him from the roof of the parochial residence, letting him fall to the ground from time to time until he died. They buried his body in a hole dug near the house for that purpose.
The record showed that the accused had taken part in the rebellion against the Spanish Government, that they were officers of the revolutionary army, and that they had rendered services to it. The record also showed that the murder was the result of political hatred and of dissensions between the accused, especially the Guzman family, and the deceased. Witnesses attributed to the accused, among others, words addressed to the dead body of Piera: when the Bastille fell, the day arrived for the settlement of accounts; now you will give me satisfaction; and now we are even. These words confirmed the enmity, hatred, and malice that existed between the accused and the deceased.
Issues
- Whether or not the crime of murder of which the accused were convicted is included within the general amnesty proclaimed by the President of the United States on the fourth of July of that year.
- Whether or not the courts are bound to give effect to the amnesty and dismiss the prosecution, notwithstanding the odious and repugnant character of the crime and the aggravated circumstances of its commission.
Applicable Provisions
The decision does not quote a statutory text; it applies the general amnesty proclaimed by the President of the United States on the fourth of July of that year, as described in the decision itself. The Court states the scope of that proclamation in these words:
A full and general amnesty for the benefit of all Filipinos who took part in the insurrection against the Government of Spain, and who had committed during such revolution acts in violation of law, as also in favor of persons guilty of crimes which were the result of internal political feuds or of dissensions between the Filipinos and Spaniards or the Spanish authorities during that insurrection.
This description of the amnesty is the provision that decides the case, because the Court measures the murder of Lieutenant Piera against its two classes of coverage: acts committed in the course of the insurrection, and crimes resulting from political feuds or dissensions between Filipinos and Spaniards.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the accused are properly included within the scope of the amnesty. It reasoned that the record shows the accused took part in the rebellion against the Spanish Government and were officers of the revolutionary army, and that the murder of Lieutenant Piera was the result of political hatred and of dissensions between the accused, especially the Guzman family, and the deceased. The Court acknowledged that murder pertains to the class of common crimes, but held that the murder in question was committed in violation of the laws of war and in consequence of hatred and dissensions between Filipinos and Spaniards or authorities and officers of the Government of Spain, which arose from acts and feuds of a political nature. The words spoken over the body of Piera confirmed the political enmity behind the killing.
On the second issue, the Court held that once the sovereign power has decreed a remission and forgetfulness of a certain class of offenses, obedience to the will of the sovereign is compulsory and must result in the final dismissal of the prosecutions. The Court put the rule this way:
No matter how odious and repugnant may be the crime of which the unfortunate Salvador Piera was the victim, and who, as a prisoner of war, was under the protection of the laws of war and of international law, for which reason the party or parties guilty of his horrible death have violated those laws and were subject to the heaviest penalties, from the moment in which the sovereign power of the territory in which the crime occurred saw fit to decree a remission and forgetfulness of a certain class of offenses, blotting out even the shadow of crime for reasons of state and motives of humanity, obedience to the will of the sovereign is compulsory and must result in the final dismissal of prosecutions instituted for the punishment of crimes expressly included within the amnesty proclaimed.
The Court characterized the amnesty as an act of policy, of wise prudence, and of well-timed generosity, freely exercised by the President for high political motives, following the dictates of common sense and a humane conscience, on the view that society would suffer more by executing the penalty than by allowing crimes committed under the impulse of partisan spirit to go unpunished. It held that no reason could be drawn from the text of the proclamation that would reasonably prevent the application of the amnesty, without misconstruing its meaning and high design, which under the circumstances then prevailing in the country was an act of justice political rather than judicial in its nature.
Doctrine
An amnesty is an act of the sovereign power that blots out the offense itself and remits its punishment for reasons of state and motives of humanity. When the sovereign has validly proclaimed an amnesty covering a class of offenses, the courts have no discretion to refuse it: obedience to the will of the sovereign is compulsory, and the prosecution must be dismissed as to every crime expressly included within the amnesty. The gravity of the crime, the cruelty of its execution, and the fact that it violates the laws of war and international law do not defeat the amnesty once the offense falls within its terms. Whether an offense falls within the amnesty is determined by its political character: a common crime such as murder is covered when it was committed in the course of the insurrection and was the result of political hatred or of dissensions between Filipinos and Spaniards or Spanish authorities. The amnesty is an act of justice political rather than judicial in its nature, and the court's role is to apply it, not to weigh its wisdom.
Disposition
The Supreme Court held that the accused, Isidro Guzman and Jose Guzman, are included within the amnesty of the fourth of July of that year and entitled to its benefits, and ordered the judge of First Instance of Isabela, after the taking of the oath prescribed as a condition in the decree of amnesty, to set the accused immediately at liberty and to transmit the record of his proceedings together with the original oaths.
Remember This
The line to memorize is that from the moment the sovereign power decrees a remission and forgetfulness of a class of offenses, obedience to the will of the sovereign is compulsory and the prosecution must be dismissed. Examiners use this case to test the nature and effect of amnesty, the duty of courts to give it effect despite the heinousness of the crime, and the political character that brings a common crime such as murder within its scope.