THE UNITED STATES, COMPLAINANT AND APPELLEE, VS. FELIPE ISLA, DEFENDANT AND APPELLANT.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
United States versus Isla
The Case
This is a criminal prosecution for bigamy, brought by the United States against Felipe Isla. The question is whether a man who contracted a second canonical marriage while his first canonical marriage still stood may be convicted under article 471 of the old Penal Code, or whether he must instead be prosecuted under article 440, which the defense invokes. The case matters for two reasons: it settles how a marriage record is proved when the accused denies that he is the person named in it, and it fixes the bigamy provision that governs where both marriages are canonical and indissoluble.
Procedural History
Felipe Isla was prosecuted for bigamy in the Court of First Instance. That court convicted him, and he appealed to the Supreme Court of the Philippine Islands. The Supreme Court, speaking through Justice Willard, confirmed the judgment of the court below, with the costs of the appeal charged to the appellant.
Facts
On the fifth of November, 1899, in the parish church of Santa Cruz in Manila, Felipe Isla was married to Maria Hilario, the complaining witness. On the fourteenth of November, 1901, in the parish church of Tondo, the same Felipe Isla was married to Aleja Pascual. The second marriage was contracted while the first still subsisted, and so the prosecution for bigamy followed.
The defense was identity. The defendant claimed that he was not the Felipe Isla who was a party to the marriage of 1899. Against him stood the testimony of Maria Hilario herself, who said that the defendant is the man she married, and of the two witnesses named in the marriage record, Maximo Briseno and Alexandra de los Angeles, who said the same. The defendant admitted that he knew Maria Hilario and that she had lived with him as his mistress in 1899. He is a native of Paranaque, and so was the Felipe Isla of that marriage.
The only other ground for his denial was the marriage record itself, which described the Felipe Isla there named as the son of Valentin Isla and Maria Madayag, both deceased, while the defendant testified that he is the son of Gabriel Isla and Petra de Leon. The Court held that this discrepancy showed only that the statement of parentage in the record was incorrect, not that the record was inadmissible. The record remained competent evidence of the marriage of a Felipe Isla, with the other evidence pointing out who that Felipe Isla is.
Issues
- Whether or not the defendant was sufficiently identified as the Felipe Isla who contracted the marriage of 1899, despite the incorrect statement of his parentage in the marriage record.
- Whether or not the defendant should have been convicted under article 440 of the Penal Code rather than under article 471.
Applicable Provisions
Article 471 of the Penal Code, the provision under which the defendant was convicted, is the bigamy provision applied by the Court. The decision states that the defendant falls exactly within its terms because both marriages were canonical and indissoluble. The text of the article is not set out in the decision, and so it is not quoted here.
Article 440 of the Penal Code is the provision the defense pressed for. The Court, through the history given by Viada, explained that this article was designed to restrain the public scandal arising from a person who, after the Civil Marriage Law, abandons his consort and contracts a new marriage under the other law without the first having been legitimately annulled. The decision quotes Viada as follows:
But from the time that article 1 of the royal decree of February 9, 1875, conceded all the civil effects recognized by the laws of Spain until the promulgation of the 18th of June, 1870, to canonical marriages, celebrated or to be celebrated, in accordance with the sacred canons, the existence of the crime mentioned, prescribed, and punished in this article 455 is not possible, since every new marriage, either civil or canonical, celebrated without being legitimately relieved of the previous obligation, will constitute an offense against the civil status of the persons, and therefore the crime of bigamy, prescribed and punished by article 486.
This history bears on the case because it shows that where both marriages are canonical, the offense falls under the bigamy article and not under the special provision for scandalous double marriages.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the defendant was sufficiently identified. The marriage certificate alone would not have been enough to show that the Felipe Isla named in it is the defendant, but other evidence proved that fact, and that evidence showed the statement of parentage in the record to be incorrect. The record was still competent evidence of the marriage of a Felipe Isla, with the other evidence identifying him. The Court also set aside as entitled to no weight the statements of the defendant's witnesses that they understood him to be a bachelor before his marriage in 1901, in the face of the direct evidence to the contrary.
On the second issue, the Court held that the conviction was properly under article 471. The law of 1870 on civil marriages was never promulgated and never in force in these Islands. The Civil Code provisions on civil marriage and a civil registry were in force here for only two weeks after the promulgation of the Civil Code, and were then suspended by royal order. Civil marriages were therefore never recognized here until the Military Government of the United States promulgated General Orders, Number 68, on the eleventh of December, 1899. The Court said it was not apparent why article 440 was retained in the Penal Code when it was placed in force here, but that it was enough to say that in this case both marriages were canonical and indissoluble and that the defendant falls exactly within the terms of article 471. The Court noted that it had already applied that article where the second marriage was celebrated under General Orders, Number 68, in the case of the United States versus Leoncio Cruz, decided on the thirteenth of December, 1901.
Doctrine
First, a marriage record is competent evidence of the marriage of the person named in it, even if the record contains an incorrect statement of parentage; the record proves the marriage, and other evidence may identify the accused as that person. Second, where both marriages are canonical and indissoluble, the accused is liable for bigamy under article 471 of the Penal Code, not under article 440, because the special provision for scandalous double marriages has no application once canonical marriages are given full civil effects. Third, the law of 1870 on civil marriages was never in force in these Islands, and civil marriages were not recognized here until General Orders, Number 68, on the eleventh of December, 1899.
Disposition
The Supreme Court confirmed the judgment of the court below convicting Felipe Isla of bigamy, with the costs of the appeal charged to the appellant.
Remember This
The line worth memorizing is that where both marriages are canonical and indissoluble, the crime is bigamy under article 471, and the marriage record stands as competent evidence of the marriage even if its statement of parentage is wrong. Examiners use this case to test the bigamy provision applicable to canonical marriages and the rule on the probative value of a marriage record against a denial of identity.