THE UNITED STATES, COMPLAINANT AND APPELLEE, VS. ISIDRO PADDIT ET AL., DEFENDANTS AND APPELLANTS.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
United States versus Paddit
The Case
This is a criminal appeal from a judgment of conviction for robbery en cuadrilla resulting in homicide — robbery committed by a band, attended by the killing of the victim. The United States prosecuted Isidro Paddit, Marcelino Lozano, and Julian Serios for the violent taking of a package of articles and jewelry belonging to Gregorio Mejia, which had been entrusted to Jacob de la Cruz for safekeeping, and for the killing of de la Cruz on the same occasion. The case matters because the Supreme Court, while affirming that a killing occurred, refused to sustain the robbery for want of proof beyond reasonable doubt, and instead convicted the accused of the lesser offense of homicide — which is necessarily included in the charge — under the rule allowing conviction of an included offense. It is an early and clean illustration of the reasonable-doubt standard applied to the taking element of robbery, and of the doctrine of included offenses.
Procedural History
The three defendants were tried in the Court of First Instance, which found them guilty under the provisions of article 503 of the Penal Code and imposed upon them the penalty of death. From that judgment they appealed to the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court reviewed the evidence, reversed the judgment of the Court of First Instance, and rendered its own judgment convicting the defendants of homicide instead.
Facts
On a night in November 1900, in the town of San Nicolas, on the occasion of the entry of the American Army into the pueblo, four persons armed with guns and bolos went to the house of Jacob de la Cruz. They bound his hands and carried him off. His widow, Nicolasa Valdez, lit a candle and recognized three of them — the defendants — whom she knew because they lived in the same pueblo and barrio, and one of whom, Marcelino Lozano, had been her neighbor since childhood. About two weeks earlier, Gregorio Mejia, trusting de la Cruz, had confided to his keeping a package containing various articles and jewelry, and the defendants had seen the property when it was brought to the house.
The widow testified that she knew her husband was being killed after they took him away, because he called to her aloud just before they succeeded in killing him, using a phrase the natives say in bidding goodbye before death. About an hour and a half later, upon the return of her father, she told him what had happened, and they went out and found the body of de la Cruz, with five wounds on the breast and one on the back near the spinal column, east of the house, near the place where the package was buried. The next day she looked for the package and found it gone. Her account was corroborated by Gregorio Mejia, Vicenta Valdez, and Lorenza Javellana as to the carrying off of her husband, the finding of the body, the character of the wounds, and the disappearance of the articles.
The defense offered alibi witnesses — Joaquin Martinez; Eugenia Vicente, wife of Isidro Paddit; and Juana Bibat and Oiriaca Serios, wife and daughter of Julian Serios — who testified that during the whole month of November the defendants were in their respective houses. The Court gave no credence to this proof of alibi.
Issues
- Whether or not the evidence proves beyond reasonable doubt the crime of robbery, so as to sustain a conviction for robbery resulting in homicide.
- Whether or not the defendants may be convicted of homicide, as an offense necessarily included in the charge of robbery resulting in homicide.
Applicable Provisions
Section 29 of General Orders, Number 58 provides:
By the provisions of section 29, General Orders, No. 58, a defendant may be found guilty of any offense the crime of which is necessarily included in the charge under the complaint and information.
This is the procedural authority that allowed the Court, after rejecting the robbery, to convict of the included offense of homicide.
Article 404 of the Penal Code is the provision under which the Court sentenced the defendants, as stated in its judgment:
The offense of homicide is included in the offense of robbery resulting in homicide, and we find the defendants guilty of homicide with the aggravating circumstance of nocturnity, which is punishable under article 404, with seventeen years and four months reclusion temporal in its medium degree.
This provision fixes the penalty the Court ultimately imposed for the homicide attended by nocturnity.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the robbery had not been proven beyond reasonable doubt. No witness saw the taking of the package by the defendants, and none of the property was found in their possession. The property had been hidden two weeks before the occurrence, and there was no evidence as to the manner in which it was hidden, nor whether it remained at the place or was seen there at any time from the time it was placed there two weeks before its disappearance. The Court was careful to note that had the charge been murder, the evidence would have been entirely sufficient to sustain it as qualified by alevosia, with the aggravating circumstance of nocturnity, and the death penalty might have been sustained — but the charge was robbery resulting in homicide.
On the second issue, the Court applied the rule on included offenses and convicted the defendants of homicide with the aggravating circumstance of nocturnity, punishable under article 404 with seventeen years and four months of reclusion temporal in its medium degree.
Doctrine
First, the taking element of robbery must be proved beyond reasonable doubt; the mere disappearance of property, without proof that the accused took it, does not establish the robbery, even where the killing of the victim is fully established. Second, under the rule on included offenses, a defendant may be found guilty of any offense necessarily included in the charge, so that an accused charged with robbery resulting in homicide may be convicted of homicide alone when the robbery is not proved. Third, nocturnity may be appreciated as an aggravating circumstance where the offense was committed at night.
Disposition
The judgment of the Court of First Instance was reversed, and the defendants were each sentenced to seventeen years, four months, and one day of reclusion temporal in its medium degree, with indemnification of 1,000 pesos, Mexican, to the family of the deceased, and costs of suit.
Remember This
Memorize this line: when the robbery is not proved beyond reasonable doubt, the accused may still be convicted of homicide as an offense necessarily included in the charge. Examiners use this case to test the reasonable-doubt standard on the taking in robbery and the rule on included offenses under the early General Orders.