🎧 Case Brief Lecture

THE UNITED STATES, COMPLAINANT AND APPELLEE, VS. BONIFACIO MODAMA, DEFENDANT AND APPELLANT.

G.R. No. 574. December 17, 1902 December 17, 1902

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

United States versus Modama

The Case

This is a criminal appeal from a conviction for theft. The United States prosecuted Bonifacio Modama, a hotel servant, for stealing one thousand dollars in United States currency from an American captain who was a guest at the Giralda Hotel in Manila. The case matters to the Bar candidate because it is an early, clean illustration of how the old Penal Code graded the crime of theft by the value of the thing taken, and of how the aggravating circumstance of abuse of confidence may be appreciated even when it is not alleged in the complaint, while a qualifying circumstance that raises the offense to a higher article must be alleged. It also shows the Court correcting the arithmetic of a penalty while affirming the substance of the judgment below.

Procedural History

The defendant was charged with theft in the Court of First Instance, tried, and convicted. The trial court condemned him to three years, six months, and twenty days of presidio correccional, to restitution of the amount stolen, to subsidiary imprisonment in case of insolvency, and to pay the costs. From that judgment the defendant appealed to the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court reviewed the evidence and the penalty, affirmed the judgment, and adjusted the period of imprisonment to the correct minimum of the medium degree.

Facts

On the twelfth of November, 1901, Captain White, a guest at the Giralda Hotel in the city of Manila, kept one thousand dollars in twenty dollar gold certificates, nearly all new, in the inside pocket of his hand satchel. He took the satchel into his room and placed it under the head of the bed. At about five o'clock in the afternoon he and his family left the room for a couple of hours. The door was left unlocked, indeed open, so that the muchacho, the defendant, could enter to arrange the room.

At about ten o'clock that night the captain opened his satchel and found the money gone. The defendant did not appear at the hotel the next day, and the complainant reported the loss and the circumstances to the Chief of the Secret Service. Detectives were given the description of the defendant. He was arrested at a saloon in Manila, and on his person were found two hundred eighty dollars in twenty dollar gold bills.

At the police station, questioned by the Chief of Police, he said that he was a servant of an American captain, that he had entered the room to make up the bed with another muchacho named Juan Mendoza, and that they took the money and divided it between them. The Chief of Police and a detective accompanied him to his house. There they found various articles belonging to the Giralda Hotel. Noticing the strange deportment of the defendant's wife, who had her hand upon her breast and seemed much disturbed, an officer drew her hand away and found five twenty dollar gold bills and two five dollar gold bills. She said the defendant had given her the money and that she had already used a twenty dollar bill to buy jewelry. Asked whether this money came from the same place as the other money, the defendant answered yes, and said that Juan Mendoza had the remainder. The owner identified the bills as having a similar appearance to those he had lost.

Issues

  • Whether or not the evidence established the theft of the money by the defendant as alleged in the complaint.
  • Whether or not the penalty should be governed by the entire amount taken, one thousand dollars, rather than by the smaller sum found on the defendant and on his wife.
  • Whether or not the fact that the defendant was a domestic of the hotel could qualify the offense and raise it to the higher penalty under the article on theft by a domestic, when that fact was not alleged in the complaint.
  • Whether or not abuse of confidence may be taken as an aggravating circumstance although it was not alleged in the complaint.

Applicable Provisions

Article 518, Number 1, of the Penal Code, as discussed in the decision, provides:

Under article 518, No. 1, of the Penal Code the theft of an amount exceeding 6,250 pesetas is punished by presidio correccional in its minimum and medium degrees.

This fixes the penalty bracket by the value of the property stolen, and the whole case turns on whether the amount taken exceeded six thousand two hundred fifty pesetas.

Article 520 of the Penal Code, as the Court describes it, provides:

He might have been charged with the offense defined in article 520 of the Penal Code, under which he would have been punishable with the penalty next higher in degree, it being shown that he was a domestic of the Giralda Hotel at which the complaining witness lived at the time, but the fact that he was such domestic has not been alleged in the complaint, which should have been done in order to sustain a conviction under article 520.

This is the qualifying circumstance that would have raised the offense, and the Court holds it cannot be considered because it was not alleged.

Paragraph 10 of Article 10 of the Penal Code, as the Court states it, provides:

However, under paragraph 10 of article 10 the law defines and enumerates circumstances which aggravate criminal liability and when the act is committed with the abuse of confidence those circumstances may be considered without the necessity of alleging the aggravating circumstances.

This allows abuse of confidence to aggravate the liability even though the complaint is silent on it.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held that the evidence clearly showed the theft of the property by the defendant as alleged in the complaint. The money was traced to his person and to his wife, and his own statements connected him to the taking.

On the second issue, the Court rejected the argument of counsel that because the money found on the defendant and on his wife was less than six thousand two hundred fifty pesetas, the penalty should be that of arresto mayor. The Court reasoned that all of the money, amounting to one thousand dollars, was taken from the satchel, and that even if the defendant did not appropriate the entire amount to himself, it was evident that the one thousand dollars in gold was taken by him. It was immaterial whether the division claimed had been made.

On the third issue, the Court held that the defendant might have been charged under the article punishing theft by a domestic, with the next higher penalty, since he was a domestic of the hotel where the complaining witness lived. But because that fact was not alleged in the complaint, and should have been alleged to sustain a conviction under that article, the circumstance could not qualify the offense and raise it to a higher degree.

On the fourth issue, the Court held that abuse of confidence may be considered as an aggravating circumstance under paragraph 10 of Article 10 without the necessity of alleging it. Taking that aggravating circumstance into account, and giving the defendant the benefit of Article 11 as reducing the penalty, the Court fixed the penalty at presidio correccional in its medium degree, the minimum of which is three years, six months, and twenty-one days, which it found substantially the penalty fixed by the lower court.

Doctrine

First, in theft, the penalty is graded by the value of the property taken, and the value is that of the whole amount stolen, not merely the portion recovered from the accused or found in his possession. Second, a qualifying circumstance that raises the offense to a higher article and a higher penalty must be alleged in the complaint; if it is not alleged, it cannot be considered to qualify the offense. Third, an ordinary aggravating circumstance, such as abuse of confidence, may be appreciated even if not alleged, because the law enumerates the circumstances that aggravate criminal liability and they need not be pleaded. These rules are tied to the quoted Article 518, Article 520, and paragraph 10 of Article 10 of the Penal Code.

Disposition

The judgment of the lower court was affirmed, and the defendant was condemned to three years, six months, and twenty-one days of presidio correccional, to restitution of one thousand dollars in gold less the four hundred eighty-five dollars in gold taken from his possession, to subsidiary imprisonment in case of insolvency at one day for each twelve and one-half pesetas not exceeding one year, and to pay the costs.

Remember This

The line worth memorizing is that the theft is measured by the whole amount taken, while a qualifying circumstance that raises the offense must be alleged in the complaint, though an aggravating circumstance like abuse of confidence need not be. Examiners use this case to test the distinction between qualifying and aggravating circumstances and the grading of theft by value.