🎧 Case Brief Lecture

ROBERTO ROA Y ALBURO, PLAINTIFF AND APPELLEE, VS. NICASIO VELOSO, DEFENDANT AND APPELLANT.

G.R. No. 570. January 23, 1903 January 23, 1903

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

Roa versus Veloso

The Case

This is an early Philippine Supreme Court decision, from January 1903, about the reach of an administrator's power of sale. Roberto Roa, a grandson and heir of the late Don Antonio Roa, sued Nicasio Veloso to recover a parcel of land that the Roa family's former administrator, Don Antonio Samson, had conveyed to Veloso in 1886. The heir insisted that the conveyance was insufficient to pass title. The case matters because the Court reads a single contractual clause — clause six of a creditors' agreement approved by the Court of First Instance of Cebu — as creating two separate powers: a power to buy the estate for himself at two-thirds of its appraised value, and a distinct power to sell it as owner for the benefit of the creditors. It is a lasting lesson in how a court gives effect to every word of a contract rather than to a reading that would render part of it useless.

Procedural History

In 1896, Roberto Roa, as grandson and heir of Don Antonio Roa, commenced this action against Nicasio Veloso in the Court of First Instance, claiming that the conveyance of 1886 was insufficient to pass title to the defendant and asking that the estate be delivered to him for himself and his coheirs. The trial court rendered judgment annulling that conveyance, canceling the inscription, and directing the estate to be delivered not to the plaintiff but to the creditors. From that judgment the defendant appealed to the Supreme Court, which decided the appeal on the construction of clause six of the creditors' proposition.

Facts

In March 1876, Don Antonio Roa presented to the Court of First Instance in Cebu a petition asking an extension of the time for the payment of his debts. A meeting of his creditors was called; the written proposition he submitted was accepted by them and approved by the court. The proceedings were taken in strict conformity with articles 506 to 518 of the Ley de Enjuiciamiento Civil of 1855, which the court treated as legal doctrine although that law was not in force in these Islands. The proposition accepted by the required majority of creditors provided for an extension of five years; that Don Antonio Samson should guarantee the debts of Don Antonio Roa and should have the administration of the latter's property during the five years, or such time as might be necessary for the payment of the debts. All the property of both Roa and Samson was mortgaged to secure the performance of the obligations.

The sixth clause of the proposition provided that Don Antonio Samson may acquire for himself, for two-thirds of the estimated value, the realty and all other property he may select, and as owner thereof he may convey or mortgage, but shall be a guarantor for the amount thereof and shall be liable to the creditors; whatever may be left over after the payment of all the credits which Samson may guarantee shall belong to Don Antonio Roa and shall be devoted to the payment of his indebtedness to Dona Francisca Casa de Roa. The order of the court approving the action of the creditors directed the property to be delivered to Antonio Samson.

Don Antonio Roa died in February 1886. On May 19 of the same year, Don Antonio Samson, by a public writing, conveyed the estate in question to the defendant. The purchase price was a debt of the defendant against Roa for 1,800 dollars, which amounted at the date of the conveyance, with interest, to 4,800 dollars. The estate belonged to Antonio Roa, was included in the inventory of his property filed with his petition for an extension, and was appraised therein at 24,809.64 dollars.

Issues

  • Whether or not clause six of the creditors' proposition gave Don Antonio Samson the right, as administrator, to sell the estate to the defendant as owner, independently of his right to acquire it for himself at two-thirds of its appraised value.
  • Whether or not the conveyance of 1886 was sufficient to transfer title to the defendant, so that the action to recover the estate must fail.

Applicable Provisions

The decision refers to the prohibition against an administrator buying for himself the property he administers, now contained in article 1459 of the Civil Code:

Article 1459 of the Civil Code prohibits an administrator from buying for himself the property which he administers.

The Court cites this prohibition to explain why clause six had to grant Samson, expressly, a right he would not otherwise have — the right to buy the estate for himself at two-thirds of its appraised value.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held that clause six consists of two distinct parts. By the first part, Samson was given the right to buy for himself this or any other property of Roa for two-thirds of the value placed upon it in the inventory; that provision is complete in itself and was intended to give Samson a right which otherwise he would not have, since no administrator may buy for himself the property he administers. The remainder of the clause is also complete in itself: it gives Samson the right to sell, as owner, any of the property, accounting to the creditors for the price received. The Court rejected the heir's construction that the second part merely continues the first, so that Samson could sell as owner only the goods he had elected to take for himself at two-thirds of their appraised value. Three reasons were given. First, such a construction would render useless the second part of the clause, because if Samson had acquired the estate at two-thirds of its value and paid for it, he would already have had the right to dispose of it as owner, and no declaration to that effect was needed. Second, the words "su importe" are inconsistent with that construction: if they mean the two-thirds of the appraised value they are unnecessary, and if they refer to the price received in a sale to a third person they would render the right of purchase of no value, for Samson would have to account to the creditors for the whole selling price while still answering for two-thirds of the appraised value — a reading that eliminates the words "para si" from the contract. Third, the clause requiring what remains to be returned to Roa indicates that the property was not to be kept intact, but that Samson was to have the right to sell it to pay the debts. The language of the conveyance of 1886, describing Samson as administrator, liquidator, and surety of Roa and availing himself of the authority conferred by the sixth clause, was entirely consistent with this view.

On the second issue, the Court held that under its construction of clause six, Samson as administrator had the right to dispose of the estate, and the conveyance of 1886 was sufficient at that time to transfer title to the defendant, who is therefore the owner. The Court noted that nothing in the record shows the state of accounts between Samson and Roa or how many creditors have been paid; the plaintiff or the creditors may have the right to demand of Samson's heirs a statement as to his administration, but whatever rights of that kind they may have, they can exercise none against the defendant.

Doctrine

A contractual clause granting an administrator the power to acquire the administered property for himself at a fixed proportion of its appraised value, and separately granting him the power to convey or mortgage it as owner while remaining liable to the creditors, creates two distinct and complete powers. The second is not restricted to property the administrator has elected to buy for himself. A construction that would render part of a contract useless, or eliminate words from it, must be rejected; every stipulation is to be given effect. Because an administrator cannot buy for himself the property he administers, such a power must be expressly conferred, and when conferred it is complete in itself. A conveyance made in the exercise of that power transfers title to the purchaser, and an heir or creditor may not recover the property from him, whatever accounting claim may lie against the administrator or his heirs.

Disposition

The Supreme Court reversed the judgment of the trial court and dismissed the action, without costs; the defendant Veloso was declared the owner of the property.

Remember This

Memorize this line: clause six gave Samson two complete powers — to buy for himself at two-thirds of the appraised value, and to sell as owner for the creditors — and the second is not limited to what he bought. Examiners use this case to test contract construction, the rule that every stipulation must be given effect, and the administrator's disability under article 1459 of the Civil Code.