THE UNITED STATES, COMPLAINANT AND APPELLEE, VS. PANTALEON GIMENO, DEFENDANT AND APPELLANT.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
United States versus Gimeno
The Case
This is a criminal case from the early years of the American regime in the Philippines. The United States prosecuted Pantaleon Gimeno for the crime of robbery, and he was convicted and sentenced by the Court of First Instance. The question that brings the case to the Supreme Court is not whether the evidence proved the robbery, but whether the accused was denied his right to be defended by counsel at his trial. The case matters because it is one of the earliest statements of the constitutional and statutory guarantee that an accused who cannot afford a lawyer must have one assigned to him, and that the court must see to it that the assigned lawyer actually performs his duty.
Procedural History
Pantaleon Gimeno was tried in the Court of First Instance of the Fifth Judicial District. On November 21, 1901, that court convicted him of robbery and sentenced him to six years and one day of presidio mayor, and to pay damages and costs. From that judgment he appealed to the Supreme Court. The appeal was resolved by the Court en banc, with a majority opinion written by Justice Cooper and a dissenting opinion by Justice Willard. Justice Torres did not sit in the case.
Facts
Before his trial, Pantaleon Gimeno applied to the Court of First Instance for the assignment of counsel to defend him. The court granted the application and assigned an attorney for his defense.
When the trial came, however, the assigned attorney failed to appear. The accused was left to make his own defense, and the record shows that he cross-examined some of the witnesses himself.
Nothing in the record explains why the lawyer was absent, and the accused made no objection to proceeding without him. He was convicted and sentenced, and he appealed.
Issues
- Whether or not the accused was deprived of his right to have counsel assigned to defend him when the attorney appointed by the court failed to appear at the trial and the accused was compelled to conduct his own defense.
- Whether or not the failure of the court, after assigning counsel, to require that counsel to appear and defend the accused is a ground for reversing the conviction and remanding the case for a new trial.
Applicable Provisions
Section 17 of General Orders, Number 58, provides:
If the defendant appears without counsel he must be informed by the court that he has a right to have counsel before being arraigned, and must be asked if he desires the aid of counsel. If he desires and is unable to employ counsel the court must assign counsel to defend him.
This is the provision the Court construes, and it is the basis for holding that the right to counsel is not satisfied by a mere appointment on paper.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the accused was effectively deprived of his right to counsel. The Court acknowledged that an attorney had been assigned upon his application, but it stressed that the attorney failed to appear at the trial, so that the burden of defending himself fell upon the accused. The right to counsel, the Court said, is a right of which the defendant should not be deprived.
On the second issue, the Court held that the failure of the court to assign counsel, or, after counsel has been assigned, to require him to perform this duty by appearing and defending the accused, is sufficient cause for the reversal of the case. The Court put the rule in these words:
This is a right which the defendant should not be deprived of, and the failure of the court to assign counsel or, after counsel has been assigned, to require him to perform this duty by appearing and defending the accused would be sufficient cause for the reversal of the case.
Justice Willard dissented. In his view, the court had complied with Section 17 by nominating a lawyer, the accused made no objection to proceeding without him, and in the absence of any showing to the contrary the Court should presume that the trial judge had good reason to proceed and that the accused consented. He would have affirmed the judgment.
Doctrine
The right to counsel under Section 17 of General Orders, Number 58 is not discharged by the mere designation of an attorney. The court must not only assign counsel to an indigent accused; it must also require that counsel to appear and actually defend him. The failure to assign counsel, or the failure to require an assigned counsel to perform his duty, is sufficient cause for reversing the conviction and remanding the case for a new trial, at which the accused must be assigned counsel for his defense. The guarantee protects the accused at the trial itself, and it is the duty of the court to see that the protection is real and not nominal.
Disposition
The Supreme Court reversed the judgment of conviction and remanded the case for a new trial, at which the defendant must be assigned counsel for his defense, with the costs of the appeal adjudged de oficio.
Remember This
The line worth memorizing is that the right to counsel is not satisfied by appointment alone; the court must require the assigned lawyer to appear and defend. Examiners use this case to test the duty of the court to secure effective counsel for an indigent accused, and to distinguish a nominal appointment from actual representation at trial.