🎧 Case Brief Lecture

MARIANO DEVEZA, PLAINTIFF AND APPELLANT, VS. SIMEON GUINOO, DEFENDANT AND APPELLEE.

G.R. No. 551. December 24, 1902 December 24, 1902

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

Deveza versus Guinoo

The Case

This is Deveza versus Guinoo, a decision of the Supreme Court rendered in December 1902, at the dawn of the American procedural regime in the Philippines. Mariano Deveza brought an action of unlawful detainer against Simeon Guinoo, seeking to evict him from a parcel of land in Occidental Negros which Guinoo had sold to him with a right of redemption, and which Guinoo continued to occupy after the redemption period lapsed without the price being returned. The case matters far less for the land than for procedure: it is an early and emphatic ruling that a change of procedural law does not apply to a case already pending under the old law, that jurisdiction over unlawful detainer belongs to the justice of the peace of the place where the property lies, and that the formal requirements of procedural law are matters of public policy whose exact observance the courts must demand.

Procedural History

The action of unlawful detainer was commenced in June 1898, under the old Law of Civil Procedure then in force, before the Court of First Instance of Negros. The defendant, Guinoo, interposed a dilatory plea of lis pendens and refused to answer, protesting that the trial should be suspended until his plea was resolved. The court refused to act on the incidental question and denied the motion to vacate its order setting the case for hearing. The oral trial began in July 1898, the defendant protesting the proceedings as null and void, and there the case stalled. No further proceedings were had for years.

In January 1901 new counsel appeared for the plaintiff and moved for a ruling on the plea of lis pendens and for judgment directing eviction. The court set the case for hearing again in November 1901, and on the fifteenth of that month it entered the judgment now on appeal. The case reached the Supreme Court by appeal, and the Court reviewed the record and set the judgment aside.

Facts

On the fourteenth of August 1896, Simeon Guinoo executed a public instrument before a notary public of Iloilo, selling to Mariano Deveza a parcel of land situated at Lanotan and Simulan in the town of Minuluan, Occidental Negros, for the sum of 3,540 pesos. The sale was made subject to a right of redemption: should the vendor return the consideration within a period expiring on the tenth of April 1897, the sale would be undone; should he fail to return it, the sale would become absolute and irrevocable. In the meantime Guinoo was to continue holding the land and enjoying its usufruct without paying anything to the purchaser. The instrument was provisionally entered in the register, and the provisional entry was later converted into a final inscription.

The redemption period expired without Guinoo returning the price. Deveza caused demand to be made upon Guinoo by the justice of the peace of Minuluan in May 1898 to vacate the land, but Guinoo refused. Deveza then filed his complaint for unlawful detainer in June 1898, alleging that the sale had become final and that Guinoo held the property as a precarious tenant without payment of rent and unlawfully detained it.

Guinoo resisted, not by denying the tenancy in a formal answer but by interposing a dilatory plea of lis pendens and protesting the proceedings. When the case was finally heard again in November 1901, the trial judge appears to have applied the new Code of Civil Procedure, which had taken effect on the first of October 1901, receiving evidence whose result does not appear in the record, and entering judgment without complying with the requirements of that Code on the form of decisions and the transmission of records.

Issues

  • Whether or not the trial judge had authority to apply the new Code of Civil Procedure to an action of unlawful detainer commenced under the old Law of Civil Procedure and still pending when the new Code became operative.
  • Whether or not the Court of First Instance had jurisdiction to try the action of unlawful detainer, given that cognizance of such actions is vested in the justice of the peace of the place where the property is situated.
  • Whether or not the proceedings below and the judgment appealed from may be sustained, given that the record does not contain the evidence taken and the formal requirements of procedural law were not observed.

Applicable Provisions

Article 80 of the Code of Civil Procedure provides:

Cognizance of actions of unlawful detainer and of all actions arising from an ouster from or illegal detention of real property, corresponds to the justice of the peace of the place where the property is situated.

This fixes jurisdiction over the action in the justice of the peace, not in the Court of First Instance, and therefore bears directly on the second issue.

Paragraph 3 of article 795 of the same Code provides:

The provisions of paragraph 3 of article 795 above cited should therefore be applied, and consequently the proceedings in this action of unlawful detainer should be continued in the Court of First Instance of Negros, in accordance with the provisions of the former law of Civil Procedure.

This is the transitional rule the Court applies: a case pending under the old law continues under the old law, in the court where it was pending.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held that the judge had no authority to apply the new procedural law to the action. The action had been commenced under the old Law of Civil Procedure and was still pending when the new Code became operative, and the transitional provision of the new Code directs that it be continued in the Court of First Instance of Negros in accordance with the former law. The Court noted that the judge, in setting the case for trial, appears to have intended to apply the new Code, and that if he had done so he should have directed the presentation of a bill of exceptions for allowance under the new Code, and could not under any circumstances have directed that the original papers be sent up.

On the second issue, the Court held that even had it been possible to apply the new procedural law, the special judge of Negros was without jurisdiction to try the case. Cognizance of actions of unlawful detainer and of all actions arising from an ouster from or illegal detention of real property corresponds to the justice of the peace of the place where the property is situated, as expressly provided by article 80 of the Code of Civil Procedure and by the Organic Act. The Court quoted the rule:

Cognizance of actions of unlawful detainer and of all actions arising from an ouster from or illegal detention of real property, corresponds to the justice of the peace of the place where the property is situated.

On the third issue, the Court held that the proceedings below and the judgment appealed from cannot be sustained. The record does not contain the evidence taken, so the Court is unable to pass upon it as the law requires. The Court stressed that in order that a proper judgment may be entered in an action for unlawful detainer, compliance must have been had with all the formal provisions established by the procedural law, the exact observance of which is a matter of public policy.

Doctrine

Three rules are worth carrying into the examination room. First, a change of procedural law does not apply to a case already pending under the old law; the case continues under the procedure in force when it was commenced, in the court where it was then pending, pursuant to the transitional provision of the new Code. Second, jurisdiction over unlawful detainer and over all actions arising from an ouster from or illegal detention of real property is vested in the justice of the peace of the place where the property is situated, and a court not so vested is without jurisdiction even if the new procedural law were otherwise applicable. Third, the formal requirements of procedural law are matters of public policy, and their exact observance is required before a proper judgment in an action of unlawful detainer may be entered; a judgment entered without the evidence in the record cannot be reviewed and must be set aside.

Disposition

The Court set aside the proceedings from page 112 of the record forward, together with the judgment appealed from, which it declared void, and directed the judge to continue the trial of the case in accordance with the old Law of Civil Procedure, with no special ruling as to costs.

Remember This

The line to memorize is that procedural statutes are not retroactive as to pending cases, and that the formal requirements of procedure are matters of public policy demanding exact observance. Examiners use this case to test the application of transitional provisions to pending actions, the special jurisdiction of the justice of the peace over unlawful detainer, and the consequences of an incomplete record on appeal.