THE UNITED STATES, COMPLAINANT AND APPELLEE, VS. MARIANO RICAFOR, DEFENDANT AND APPELLANT.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
United States versus Ricafor
The Case
This is a criminal case from the early years of the American regime in the Philippines. The United States, as complainant and appellee, prosecuted Mariano Ricafor for the killing of Pedro Lorioda, and Ricafor, as defendant and appellant, brought the matter to the Supreme Court for review. The trial court convicted him of assassination and imposed life imprisonment. The question on appeal is whether that penalty was correct, or whether the qualifying circumstances of the killing required the graver penalty of death. The case matters because it is a compact lesson on how treachery and premeditation are established from external acts, and on how the Supreme Court treats the testimony of accomplices who were present at the killing.
Procedural History
Mariano Ricafor was tried before the Court of First Instance of Pangasinan, which declared him guilty of the crime of assassination, committed without any generic circumstance qualifying the criminal responsibility, and sentenced him to life imprisonment, cadena perpetua. The cause was then brought up to the Supreme Court for review. The Solicitor-General concurred with the judgment of the trial court and asked that it be affirmed. The Supreme Court did not affirm. It annulled the sentence of the court below and imposed the death penalty, with an indemnity and accessory penalties, and remanded the cause to the Court of First Instance of Pangasinan for execution of the sentence.
Facts
On the night of a certain Friday in March 1900, the defendant Mariano Ricafor and Gabino Marquez, accompanied by Clemente Oli, Marcos Nares, and Cornelio Tabajonda, went to the house of Pedro Lorioda within the limits of Pozorrubio, Pangasinan. Oli, Nares, and Tabajonda, who appear to have been asked or compelled to accompany the two for that purpose, called Pedro Lorioda and his brother Juan Lorioda out of the house, or in some manner induced them to permit Ricafor and Marquez to enter.
Ricafor and Marquez took possession of the two Loriodas and, still accompanied by the three others, conducted them to the fields of the barrio of Alipangpang, to a place where there was a well. Upon arriving at that spot, Ricafor and Marquez bound their victims and killed them by inflicting wounds upon the neck with bolos, the defendant killing Pedro and Marquez killing Juan. They then threw the bodies into the well.
The abduction of the two Loriodas by removing them from the house was proved by five eyewitnesses: Oli, Nares, Tabajonda, and the wife and daughter of Pedro Lorioda. The remaining facts were proved by the statements of Oli, Nares, and Tabajonda, who went from the house to the fields with the accused and were present while the victims were bound and killed. These three were themselves accomplices in the crime, but because their statements were corroborated in large part by other unimpeached witnesses, the Court gave them absolute credence, as the trial court had done.
Issues
- Whether or not the testimony of the three accomplices may be given absolute credence despite their participation in the crime.
- Whether or not the failure to disclose the motive for the killing prevents conviction.
- Whether or not the fact of having bound the victims constitutes the qualifying circumstance of treachery, converting the homicide into assassination.
- Whether or not the aggravating circumstance of premeditation should be taken into account.
- Whether or not the circumstance of race should be considered an extenuating circumstance in favor of the accused.
Applicable Provisions
General Orders, Number 58, article 55, governs the credibility of witnesses and provides:
The statements made by witnesses shall be presumed to be true, unless there is something in the manner of giving them or in the character of the witnesses which would affect their probability.
This provision is the basis for the Court's acceptance of the accomplices' testimony, since nothing in the manner of their statements affected their probability.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the statements of Oli, Nares, and Tabajonda should be given absolute credence. Although they were accomplices, their testimony was corroborated in large part by other witnesses who were not impeached in any sense, and nothing in the manner of giving their statements at the trial affected their probability under article 55 of General Orders, Number 58.
On the second issue, the Court attributed little importance to the fact that the motives for the crime were not disclosed. In crimes apparently without motive, the motives which might exist are innumerable, perhaps unknown even to the relatives of the deceased who testified, and not even disclosed to the three who cooperated in a certain measure in the crime.
On the third issue, the Court held that the fact of having bound the murdered persons constituted the qualifying circumstance of treachery, thus converting the homicide into assassination. The binding hindered their resistance or rendered it impossible, and had for its direct and special object the assurance of the execution of the crime without personal risk to the defendant and Marquez.
On the fourth issue, a majority of the Court held that premeditation should also be taken into account. The facts sufficed to demonstrate a determined plan conceived by the defendant and Marquez at the latest at the time of taking hold of the Loriodas and starting with them for the place where the crime was committed. The time between the abduction and the arrival at the well was sufficient, in the language of the supreme court of Spain, for the conscience to conquer the determination of the will. The binding of the deceased afforded a new opportunity for reflection. The Court stressed that premeditation must be evident, based upon external acts and not presumed from the mere lapse of time, and found such external acts in the deceit practiced to obtain possession of the victims, the abduction, the conveyance to a place that lent itself to concealment of the bodies, and the binding of the victims, all forming part of a single design directed to the same final result.
On the fifth issue, the Court held that the circumstance of race should not be considered an extenuating circumstance in favor of the culprit, in view of the nature of the crime and the conditions of the defendant.
Doctrine
First, the testimony of accomplices may be given absolute credence where it is corroborated in large part by other unimpeached witnesses and nothing in the manner of giving it affects its probability, consistent with article 55 of General Orders, Number 58. Second, the absence of a disclosed motive does not prevent conviction, since motives in apparently motiveless crimes are innumerable and often unknown. Third, treachery is present where the accused binds the victim, hindering resistance or rendering it impossible, to assure execution of the crime without personal risk; this converts homicide into assassination. Fourth, premeditation must be evident, based on external acts and not presumed from mere lapse of time, but a continuous series of acts forming a single design, from deceit and abduction to conveyance to a place of concealment and the binding of the victims, sufficiently manifests reflective meditation. Fifth, the circumstance of race is not an extenuating circumstance where the nature of the crime and the conditions of the defendant do not warrant it.
Disposition
The Court annulled the sentence of the court below and condemned the defendant to death, to pay an indemnity of 1,000 pesos, Mexican currency, to the widow and heir of Pedro Lorioda, and, should the sentence not be carried out by reason of pardon, to the accessory penalties of perpetual absolute disqualification and subjection to the vigilance of the authorities during his life, unless expressly included in the pardon; the cause was remanded to the Court of First Instance of Pangasinan for execution of the sentence.
Remember This
The single line worth memorizing is that premeditation must be evident from external acts, not presumed from the mere lapse of time, and that binding a victim to assure the crime without risk is treachery. Examiners use this case to test the elements of treachery and premeditation, and the credence given to corroborated accomplice testimony.