FLORENCIO POZADAS, PLAINTIFF AND APPELLANT, VS. DOMINGO MARTINEZ ET AL.,DEFENDANTS AND APPELLEES.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Pozadas versus Martinez
The Case
This is an early Philippine case, decided in September 1902, on the boundary between voluntary jurisdiction and contentious jurisdiction in the summary proceedings for judicial possession of real property. Florencio Pozadas, claiming ownership under a recorded public instrument, asked the Court of First Instance to put him in possession of land in Pata, in the town of San Carlos, under the old Law of Civil Procedure. Domingo Martinez and Magdalena Martinez, husband and wife, opposed the proceeding, claiming that a portion of the land was in the wife's possession as owner. The case matters because it fixes a simple but durable rule: the moment a third person in possession opposes the petition before possession is delivered, the voluntary proceeding must stop and the parties must litigate in a contentious action.
Procedural History
Pozadas filed his petition for possession with the Court of First Instance on the thirteenth of May, 1901. The court granted it the same day, without prejudice to third persons with better right. After publication of the edicts citing the owners of the adjacent lands, Pozadas was placed in possession on the twenty-second of May, without opposition. But on the twenty-fifth of May the judge, finding defects in the citation of the adjacent owners and an insufficient description of the boundaries, declared that act void and ordered the proceedings repeated.
The proceeding was had anew, and the area and boundaries were recorded in the minutes of the thirty-first of May. Before possession could be delivered, the Martinez spouses appeared and opposed. They first asked the municipal president, acting as commissioner, to suspend the possession about to be conferred; he did not grant the petition but told Martinez to prosecute his claim before the Court of First Instance. Martinez did so by petition dated the first of June, asking that the possession conferred on Pozadas be set aside and that Pozadas be ordered to assert his rights in a civil action. After an ocular inspection and a report by the clerk, the court issued the order of the twenty-fourth of June, 1901, reversing the order of possession, declaring the matter contentious, preserving the parties' respective possession, allocating costs, and enjoining Pozadas from molesting Martinez. Pozadas appealed, and the appeal was allowed in both effects and reached the Supreme Court.
Facts
Pozadas alleged that he owned a parcel of land at Pata, in San Carlos, the extent and boundaries of which appeared in the public instrument by which he acquired it, recorded in the Register of Property. He exhibited that instrument as evidence of his ownership and asked to be judicially put in possession under the Law of Civil Procedure then in force.
Possession was first given on the twenty-second of May, 1901, without opposition. The judge then voided that proceeding for defects in the citation of the adjacent owners and in the description of the boundaries, and ordered the proceeding repeated. In the new proceeding, before possession was delivered, Domingo Martinez and Magdalena Martinez appeared and opposed, claiming that a piece of land included in Pozadas's claim was in the wife's possession as owner.
The municipal president declined to act on their request for suspension but directed Martinez to the Court of First Instance, which he did. The trial court then reversed the order of possession, holding that the possession given Pozadas would oust the Martinez spouses from a possession they held under a claim of ownership, and that such a claim cannot be defeated without a day in court.
Issues
- Whether or not the opposition of a third person in possession, made before judicial possession is delivered under a voluntary proceeding, converts the proceeding into a contentious action and requires its dismissal.
- Whether or not the order of the twenty-fifth of May, 1901, declaring the first proceeding void, may still be reviewed on appeal.
- Whether or not the trial court erred in its award of costs against the municipal president and the parties.
Applicable Provisions
Article 2015 of the Law of Civil Procedure then in force, invoked by the petitioner, provides:
The petitioner prayed that the municipal president of San Carlos, acting as justice of the peace, be authorized to execute the order, and that the petitioner be given a transcript of the order directing that he be given possession of the lands.
This is the voluntary remedy Pozadas used to obtain judicial possession of land he claimed as owner.
Article 2016 of the same Law provides:
The judge, in accordance with the provisions of article 2016 of the same Law, ordered that the possession solicited be given without prejudice to the rights of third persons.
This shows that the remedy is summary and provisional, and cannot prejudice third persons with better right.
Article 1817 of the same Law provides:
The moment that opposition was made to the proceedings, as was that of Martinez and his wife, before possession was given, the execution of the order of possession should have been suspended, and the proceedings of voluntary jurisdiction dismissed, with the result of converting the action into one of contentious jurisdiction, in accordance with the provisions of article 1817 of the Law of Civil Procedure.
This is the decisive rule: timely opposition before delivery of possession suspends execution, dismisses the voluntary proceeding, and converts the matter into a contentious action.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the opposition was timely and effective. The judicial order of possession can be executed only if no third person interested in the matter opposes. Martinez and his wife alleged possession under a claim of ownership of a piece of land included in Pozadas's claim. The moment they opposed, before possession was given, the execution of the order should have been suspended and the voluntary proceeding dismissed, converting the action into one of contentious jurisdiction under Article 1817. The possession given Pozadas on the thirty-first of May was therefore in violation of that article.
On the second issue, the Court refused to review the order of the twenty-fifth of May. That order had become final and unappealable because the appellant took no exception to it. Hence the new proceeding of the thirty-first of May would have been perfectly legal had it not been for the opposition.
On the third issue, the Court held that no special order on costs in the first instance should have been made. The municipal president was a layman who acted in good faith, as shown by the text of the order of the twentieth of May, and so was exempt from responsibility or disciplinary correction.
Doctrine
A petition for judicial possession under the Law of Civil Procedure is a proceeding of voluntary jurisdiction. It is granted without prejudice to third persons with better right, and it may be executed only if no third person interested in the matter opposes. Once a third person in possession under a claim of ownership opposes before possession is delivered, the execution of the order must be suspended, the voluntary proceeding dismissed, and the matter converted into a contentious action, in which no one may be ousted from possession without his day in court. A final and unappealed order cannot be reopened on appeal. And a lay official who acts in good faith in executing such an order is not liable for costs.
Disposition
The order of the twenty-fourth of June, 1901, was affirmed, with costs of the second instance against the appellant, but reversed as to the costs of the first instance, which were left without special declaration; Pozadas lost the appeal.
Remember This
Memorize the line: the moment a third person in possession opposes before possession is delivered, the voluntary proceeding stops and becomes contentious. Examiners use this case to test the distinction between voluntary and contentious jurisdiction and the rule that no one is ousted from possession without his day in court.