EDWIN H. WARNER, PLAINTIFF AND APPELLANT, VS. THE MUNICIPALITY OF PASAY, DEFENDANT AND APPELLEE.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Warner versus Municipality of Pasay
The Case
This is the case of Warner versus the Municipality of Pasay, decided in April 1902. Edwin H. Warner filed a petition for the survey and fixing of the boundaries of a large tract of land known as the Pasay estate, a single property of some 480 hectares, within which the town of Pasay itself stood, with its streets, public squares, and buildings. The Municipality of Pasay appeared and opposed the petition. The question that makes this case matter is a fundamental one about the nature of boundary-survey proceedings: are they an act of mere voluntary jurisdiction, resting on the consent of all parties in interest, or can they be used to settle a real dispute over ownership and possession? The Court held that once any party in interest opposes, the proceeding must stop, because a voluntary proceeding cannot decide a contentious question.
Procedural History
Warner commenced the proceeding in the Court of First Instance as an act of voluntary jurisdiction under the Law of Civil Procedure, seeking the survey and designation of the boundaries of the Pasay estate. The original complaint did not cite any person interested, and the amended complaint named only the adjacent property owners outside the perimeter of the estate. The Municipality of Pasay was not cited, but it entered an appearance as the owner of streets, squares, and other lands within the estate, and it made opposition to the petition. On that opposition, the judge dismissed the proceedings. Warner appealed to the Supreme Court, which affirmed the dismissal, with costs against the appellant. Justice Cooper, joined in part by Chief Justice Arellano, dissented.
Facts
Warner alleged that he was the owner of the entire Pasay estate, a tract of some 480 hectares, subject to certain exceptions that he described. The town of Pasay, with its streets, public squares, and buildings, lay within this estate. The petition sought a judicial survey and the fixing of the estate's boundary lines.
The requirements for the original complaint were not strictly complied with, because no person interested was cited in it. The amended complaint mentioned only the names of the adjacent property owners outside the perimeter of the estate. The Municipality of Pasay was not cited at all.
Despite not being cited, the Municipality entered an appearance in the action as the owner of the streets, squares, and other lands within the estate. It opposed the petition, both as owner of those lands and as representative of the private interests of the inhabitants. The trial judge, faced with this opposition, dismissed the proceedings, and Warner appealed.
Issues
- Whether or not a person who is not the owner of the property, or who holds no real right over it, is entitled to ask for the survey and designation of its boundaries under the Law of Civil Procedure.
- Whether or not the Municipality of Pasay, as owner of the streets and public squares within the estate, was a party in interest entitled to oppose the petition, even though it was not an adjacent owner.
- Whether or not the opposition of a party in interest converts the proceeding from voluntary to contentious jurisdiction, so that the judge must dismiss it and remit the parties to an ordinary action.
Applicable Provisions
Article 384 of the Civil Code grants the right to survey property. It provides:
Article 384. Every owner of property has the right to survey and mark the boundaries of his property, and to have the same surveyed and marked at his own expense, and to compel the owners of adjoining property to contribute to the expense of the survey and marking of the boundaries which separate them.
The Court used this article to show that the right to survey belongs to the owner, and that the Law of Civil Procedure is consistent with the Civil Code on this point.
Article 2020 of the Law of Civil Procedure grants the right to the owner and to him who has a real right in the land. It provides:
Article 2020. The owner of real property, or any person having a real right in the land for his use and benefit, may apply to the Court of First Instance for an order that the boundaries of the property be surveyed and marked.
The Court relied on this to hold that only the owner or one with a real right may invoke the remedy.
Article 2021 of the Law of Civil Procedure requires that all parties in interest be cited. It provides:
Article 2021. The designation of the day and hour shall be made in such a manner that all the parties in interest may be present, they to be previously cited in legal form.
The Court used this to show that the law itself contemplates the citation of all parties in interest, not only adjacent owners.
Article 1800 of the Law of Civil Procedure governs opposition. It provides:
Article 1800. If opposition to the request be made by any person interested the matter shall become litigious without altering the situation of the parties in interest or the subject-matter of the proceedings, and the procedure prescribed for ordinary actions shall be followed according to the import thereof.
This is the core provision: any person interested may oppose, and once opposition is made, the matter becomes contentious.
Article 2029 of the Law of Civil Procedure limits the effect of an adjacent owner's opposition. It provides:
Article 2029. If before commencing the survey opposition be made thereto by any owner of adjoining property, the survey of that part of the land which adjoins that of the opposing party shall be discontinued, the parties reserving the right to institute such declarative action therefor as may be proper. A similar discontinuance shall be ordered if any opposition is presented during the proceedings, provided the parties in interest do not agree upon the matter in dispute. In both cases the survey of the balance of the land may be performed at the request of the petitioner, provided the other adjoining owners do not make opposition thereto.
The Court held that this article is specific and does not take away the general right of any person interested, such as the owner or possessor, to oppose under Article 1800.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the right to survey and designate boundaries belongs to the owner, and to those in whose favor real rights exist. A person who is not the owner is not entitled to the remedy. The Court said that no one is entitled to the survey and designation of boundaries of an estate which is in the possession and is the property of another, because such a survey would imply an unlawful interference with possession and ownership, and could not be done without a material trespass upon the land.
On the second issue, the Court held that the Municipality of Pasay was a party in interest. As owner of the streets and public squares within the estate, it was entitled to oppose the petition. The Court explained that Article 2029 is specific and Article 1800 is general, and that Article 2029 was never intended to withhold from a third person who has an interest in the matter, such as the owner or possessor, the right to oppose the proceedings. The Court also held that a naked possessor is a person in interest who must be cited and who may oppose.
On the third issue, the Court held that once opposition is made by a party in interest, the judge can follow only one course. He is without authority in an action of voluntary jurisdiction to take cognizance of a contentious suit. He cannot decide that the petitioner is the owner and that the opposing party is not, nor can he decide that the opposing party is the owner. He can only remit the parties to a contentious suit in which alone such questions can be decided. To direct a continuation of the voluntary proceeding, in view of the denial of ownership, would be practically equivalent to deciding the question in issue.
The Court quoted Manresa's Commentaries to explain the basis of the rule:
Upon the ground that there can be no suit if there is no contest or question between the parties, the law has placed the survey of property among the acts of voluntary jurisdiction, provided that it is effected with the consent or acquiescence, at least, of all the parties in interest. But from the moment in which one of them makes opposition, whether before the operation or at the time of its performance, it is carried into the domain of contentious jurisdiction.
The Court concluded that whenever a dispute arises between parties interested in real property, either with respect to ownership or possession, they should not resort to this act of voluntary jurisdiction, nor insist upon it, no matter what may be the merits of the dispute.
Doctrine
The survey and designation of boundaries under the Law of Civil Procedure is an act of voluntary jurisdiction. It rests on the consent of all parties in interest. The right to invoke it belongs only to the owner or to one who has a real right in the land for his use and benefit. A stranger who is not the owner cannot use it to survey the property of another, because that would be an unlawful interference with possession and ownership.
Any person interested may oppose the petition under Article 1800. This includes the owner, the possessor, and one who holds a real right, and not only the adjacent owners. Once opposition is made, the proceeding is converted into a contentious matter. The judge must dismiss it and remit the parties to an ordinary action, because a voluntary proceeding cannot decide questions of ownership or possession.
Article 2029, which limits the effect of an adjacent owner's opposition to the part of the land adjoining his, does not deprive other persons in interest of their right to oppose under Article 1800. The specific provision does not repeal the general one.
Disposition
The Supreme Court affirmed the judgment of the trial court dismissing the proceedings, with costs of the instance against the appellant, Warner.
Remember This
The single line worth memorizing is this: a boundary-survey proceeding is an act of voluntary jurisdiction that rests on consent, and the moment a party in interest opposes, it becomes contentious and the judge must dismiss it. Examiners use this case to test the distinction between voluntary and contentious jurisdiction, and to ask who may oppose a petition for the survey and designation of boundaries.