🎧 Case Brief Lecture

THE UNITED STATES, COMPLAINANT AND APPELLEE, VS. HIPOLITO HILARIO ET AL., DEFENDANTS AND APPELLANTS.

G.R. No. 537. April 09, 1902 April 9, 1902

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

United States versus Hilario

The Case

This is a criminal appeal from a conviction for robbery. The United States prosecuted Hipolito Hilario and several others for entering a house by night, posing as policemen, and carrying off property after beating and binding the occupants. The case matters to a reviewee because it shows the Supreme Court correcting the trial court's choice of the governing penal provision: where personal violence is used in committing robbery, the conviction must rest on the article on robbery with violence against persons, not on the article penalizing robbery by a band. It is also an early illustration of how the Court applies aggravating circumstances and fixes the penalty accordingly.

Procedural History

Hipolito Hilario, together with Alejandro Bello, Bernabe Santos, Andres Estrella, and Anacleto Abena, was tried upon a complaint for robbery in the Court of First Instance of Manila. Bello was tried separately, while Hilario, Santos, Estrella, and Abena were tried together. Estrella and Abena were acquitted. Hilario, Bello, and Santos were convicted and appealed to the Supreme Court. Pending the appeal, the Court was officially informed that Bello and Santos had escaped from prison, and the cause was suspended as to them. The appeal was heard and submitted only as to the remaining defendant, Hilario.

Facts

Early in the morning of the eleventh of July, 1901, a band of six robbers gained entrance to the house of Telesforo Obispo in Tondo. They did so under the pretext that they were policemen.

Once inside, they beat Obispo, threw him to the floor, and tied his wife and some of the other inmates of the house. They then took a sewing machine, some clothing, various other articles found in the house, and a small sum of money, all of which they carried away.

The evidence showed that Hilario was one of the band and that he carried a light during the robbery. Two of the other robbers were armed, one with a gun and the other with a revolver and a bolo. Hilario and Santos were convicted in the court below under the last clause of Article 508 of the Penal Code.

Issues

  • Whether or not the conviction should rest on the last clause of Article 508 of the Penal Code, as held by the trial court, or on Article 503, Number 5, of the same Code, given that personal violence was employed in effecting the robbery.
  • Whether or not the aggravating circumstances of Article 10, Numbers 8 and 15, are present in the commission of the offense.
  • Whether or not the penalty imposed upon Hilario is the correct one under the applicable provision.

Applicable Provisions

Article 503, Number 5, of the Penal Code, which the Court holds to be the governing provision, provides:

Article 503. The penalty of presidio mayor shall be imposed upon any person who, with intent to derive profit, shall take possession of personal property belonging to another by means of violence or intimidation against persons, provided the value of the property taken exceeds one thousand two hundred and fifty pesetas.

This is the article on robbery with violence against persons, and the Court holds that it, and not Article 508, is the provision under which Hilario should have been convicted, because a certain amount of personal violence was employed in effecting the robbery.

Article 10, Numbers 8 and 15, of the Penal Code, which the Court finds present, provides:

Article 10. The following are aggravating circumstances: Number 8. That the offense was committed by means of a disguise or by the use of a mask or by the assumption of a fictitious name or by the simulation of authority. Number 15. That the offense was committed in the nighttime or in a deserted place or by a band.

These circumstances bear on the penalty because the Court expressly finds both present in the commission of the robbery.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court holds that the conviction should have been under Article 503, Number 5, of the Penal Code, and not under the last clause of Article 508, there having been a certain amount of personal violence employed in effecting the robbery. The Court confines itself to the case of Hilario, since the appeal was suspended as to Bello and Santos after their escape.

On the second issue, the Court finds that the two aggravating circumstances of Article 10, Numbers 8 and 15, are present. The robbers gained entrance by pretending to be policemen, which is the simulation of authority, and the offense was committed in the nighttime and by a band.

On the third issue, the Court fixes the penalty accordingly. Hilario is sentenced to ten years of presidio mayor, with restitution of the property stolen and payment of costs.

Doctrine

First, the classification of robbery turns on the means used. Where personal violence is employed in taking the property, the offense falls under Article 503, Number 5, of the Penal Code, on robbery with violence against persons, and not under Article 508, on robbery by a band. The presence of a band does not displace the article on violence against persons; it operates instead as an aggravating circumstance.

Second, aggravating circumstances must be alleged and proved, and the Court here finds two: the simulation of authority under Article 10, Number 8, arising from the robbers posing as policemen, and the nighttime and band under Article 10, Number 15.

Third, the penalty must be fixed under the correct article. Once the governing provision is identified as Article 503, Number 5, the penalty of presidio mayor is imposed, and the aggravating circumstances are taken into account in fixing its duration.

Disposition

The Court set aside the conviction under Article 508 and convicted Hilario instead under Article 503, Number 5, sentencing him to ten years of presidio mayor, with restitution of the stolen property and costs, and remanded the cause for execution of the judgment.

Remember This

The one line to memorize: where personal violence is used in taking property, the crime is robbery with violence against persons under Article 503, Number 5, and the band is only an aggravating circumstance, not a separate article. Examiners use this case to test the correct classification of robbery and the proper appreciation of the aggravating circumstances of simulation of authority and of nighttime and band.