ENGINEERING & MACHINERY CORPORATION, PETITIONER, VS. COURT OF APPEALS AND PONCIANO L. ALMEDA, RESPONDENTS.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Engineering and Machinery Corporation versus Court of Appeals and Ponciano Almeda
The Case
This is a petition for review on certiorari brought by Engineering and Machinery Corporation against the Court of Appeals and Ponciano Almeda, arising from a complaint for damages over a defective central air-conditioning system. The petitioner fabricated and installed the system in the private respondent's building, and the private respondent sued when the system failed to perform as agreed. The case matters because it settles two questions every civil law practitioner must be able to answer: whether such a contract is one of sale or one for a piece of work, and which prescriptive period governs an action for breach of its terms.
Procedural History
The private respondent filed a complaint for damages with the then Court of First Instance of Rizal. The petitioner moved to dismiss on the ground of prescription, invoking the six-month period for hidden defects, but the trial court denied the motion. After trial, the trial court ruled in favor of the private respondent, ordering the petitioner to pay the amount needed to rectify the faults and deficiencies of the system, plus damages, attorney's fees and costs. On the question of prescription, the trial court held that the complaint was filed within the ten-year period because the contract was one for a piece of work involving the installation of a system the petitioner itself manufactured, fabricated, designed and installed. The petitioner appealed to the Court of Appeals, which affirmed the trial court in full. The petitioner then came to the Supreme Court through a petition for review on certiorari under Rule 45.
Facts
By a contract dated September 10, 1962, the petitioner undertook to fabricate, furnish and install the air-conditioning system in the private respondent's building along Buendia Avenue, Makati, for 210,000 pesos. The petitioner was to furnish the materials, labor, tools and all services required. The system was completed in 1963 and accepted by the private respondent, who paid the contract price in full.
In September 1965, the private respondent sold the building to the National Investment and Development Corporation. Because the buyer failed to comply with the terms of the deed of sale, the private respondent obtained a judicial rescission, and ownership and possession returned to him sometime in 1971. It was then that he learned from the buyer's employees of the defects in the air-conditioning system. He commissioned an engineer to evaluate the system, and the report enumerated the defects and concluded that the system could not maintain the desired room temperature.
On the strength of that report, the private respondent filed the action for damages in May 1971, alleging that the system did not comply with the agreed plans and specifications. The petitioner raised prescription as its defense, arguing that the six-month period for hidden defects had long set in.
Issues
- Whether or not the contract for the fabrication and installation of the air-conditioning system is a contract of sale or a contract for a piece of work.
- Whether or not the action for breach of the contract is barred by prescription.
- Whether or not the private respondent's acceptance of the work and payment of the price relieved the petitioner of liability for the defects.
Applicable Provisions
Article 1713 of the Civil Code defines a contract for a piece of work:
By the contract for a piece of work the contractor binds himself to execute a piece of work for the employer, in consideration of a certain price or compensation. The contractor may either employ only his labor or skill, or also furnish the material.
This is the characterization the Court adopts for the contract in this case.
Article 1714 of the Civil Code states the contractor's obligations where he furnishes the materials:
If the contractor agrees to produce the work from material furnished by him, he shall deliver the thing produced to the employer and transfer dominion over the thing. This contract shall be governed by the following articles as well as by the pertinent provisions on warranty of title and against hidden defects and the payment of price in a contract of sale.
This provision is the bridge the petitioner used to argue that the six-month period for hidden defects applies.
Article 1715 of the Civil Code states the contractor's duty as to the quality of the work:
The contractor shall execute the work in such a manner that it has the qualities agreed upon and has no defects which destroy or lessen its value or fitness for its ordinary or stipulated use. Should the work be not of such quality, the employer may require that the contractor remove the defect or execute another work. If the contractor fails or refuses to comply with this obligation, the employer may have the defect removed or another work executed, at the contractor's cost.
This is the provision the Court holds governs the action, and it contains no special prescriptive period.
Article 1144 of the Civil Code supplies the period:
Actions upon a written contract prescribe in ten years.
Because the governing provision has no special period, this general rule applies and saves the complaint from prescription.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the contract is one for a piece of work, not a sale. The test is whether the thing transferred is one not in existence and which would never have existed but for the order of the person desiring it. If so, the contract is for a piece of work; if the thing would have existed and been the subject of a sale to some other person even without the order, the contract is one of sale. The Court found that manufacturing air-conditioning systems for sale off the shelf is not the petitioner's line of business; its field of expertise is the fabrication and installation of such systems as ordered by customers, in accordance with the particular plans and specifications they provide, with the price depending greatly on those plans and specifications.
On the second issue, the Court held that the action has not prescribed. It first noted that under the warranty rules, where there is an express warranty the prescriptive period is the one specified in that warranty, and in the absence of such a period the four-year period for rescission applies. That would have barred the suit. But a close scrutiny of the complaint showed that the action is not for enforcement of the warranties against hidden defects but one for breach of the contract itself, for failure to comply with the specifications. The governing law is therefore Article 1715, and since that provision contains no specific prescriptive period, the general law on prescription applies, which is the ten-year period for actions upon a written contract. The contract was executed in September 1962 and the complaint was filed in May 1971, so the action was timely.
On the third issue, the Court held that mere acceptance of the work does not, by that fact alone, relieve the contractor of liability for deviations from and violations of the written contract, because the law gives the employer ten years within which to file an action based on breach. The Court also upheld the finding that the defect was not apparent at the time of delivery and acceptance, since the private respondent is not an expert, and it is impossible to determine by simple inspection whether an air-conditioning system installed in an eight-floor building conforms to the agreed specifications.
Doctrine
A contract for the delivery of an article which the vendor in the ordinary course of business manufactures for the general market is a contract of sale; but where the goods are manufactured specially for the customer upon his special order and not for the general market, the contract is one for a piece of work under Article 1713. A contract for a piece of work is governed by Article 1715 as to the quality of the work, and because that article fixes no special prescriptive period, an action for breach of the written contract prescribes in ten years under Article 1144. The six-month period for redhibitory actions does not apply where the suit is not for enforcement of the warranty against hidden defects but for breach of the contract itself. Acceptance of the work does not ipso facto relieve the contractor of liability for deviations from the contract.
Disposition
The petition was denied and the decision of the Court of Appeals was affirmed, without costs.
Remember This
Memorize the rule that a thing made specially upon the customer's order, and which would never have existed but for that order, makes the contract one for a piece of work, so that breach of the written contract prescribes in ten years. Examiners use this case to test the sale-versus-piece-of-work distinction and the prescriptive period for a contractor's liability.