BENITO LEGARDA Y TUASON, COMPLAINANT AND APPELLANT, VS. VICENTE GARCIA VALDEZ, DEFENDANT AND APPELLEE.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Legarda versus Valdez
The Case
This is a criminal prosecution for libel, in the older Spanish sense of injurias graves — grave insults in writing — brought by Benito Legarda y Tuason against Vicente Garcia Valdez, the editor of a weekly paper called Miau. Legarda complains that an article published under his own name in that paper defamed him, charging him with vice and immorality and tending to bring him into contempt and to prejudice his good name, credit, and honesty. The case matters to a reviewee for two reasons. First, it fixes the correct penalty under the old Penal Code for written and public grave insults, and corrects a trial court that imposed a period of banishment the Code does not even recognize. Second, and more importantly for examinations, it holds that the bar against proving the truth of a libelous charge is no obstacle to considering the dignity of the offended party — either as a qualifying element of the offense or as a generic aggravating circumstance.
Procedural History
Legarda filed a criminal complaint against Valdez in the court below for the crime of grave insults defined and punished by Article 458 of the Penal Code. After trial, the judge of the court below, on the sixth of May 1902, rendered judgment declaring Valdez guilty and sentencing him to six months of banishment, a fine of 625 pesetas, and the costs of the action. The private prosecutor, Legarda, appealed from that judgment. The defendant did not appeal. The case thus reached the Supreme Court by ordinary appeal from the judgment of conviction, and the Court reviewed both the finding of guilt and the penalty imposed.
Facts
In issue number 16, dated the fifteenth of September 1901, of the weekly paper Miau, published in the city, an article appeared under the heading naming Benito Legarda y Tuason. Valdez was the editor of the paper at the time of publication. The article was not reproduced verbatim in the complaint because of its great length, but the complaint set out that it contained defamatory statements charging the complainant with vice and immorality.
At the trial the evidence fully showed that Valdez was the editor of Miau when the article was published. The Court found that the text of the article itself left no room for doubt as to its defamatory character and the gravity of the statements made against the complainant. Valdez made no attempt to deny the defamatory character of the article. Instead, he offered to prove the truth of the charges, and the trial judge properly rejected that offer under Article 460 of the Penal Code. The Court regarded the offer itself as, to a certain extent, an implied acknowledgment that the accused was the author of the article.
It also appeared from the record that the complainant was a member of the United States Civil Commission in these Islands at the date of the publication. The trial judge declined to apply the aggravating circumstance of disregard for the respect due the complainant by reason of his office, reasoning that since the accused could not prove the truth of the charges, it was impossible to determine whether the charges were made in disregard of that respect. The Supreme Court rejected this reasoning.
Issues
- Whether or not the penalty imposed by the trial court, six months of banishment and a fine of 625 pesetas, is the penalty prescribed by the Penal Code for the crime of written and public grave insults under Article 458.
- Whether or not the aggravating circumstance of committing the offense in disregard of the respect due the complainant by reason of the dignity of his office may be considered, notwithstanding the prohibition against evidence of the truth of the libelous charges.
- Whether or not that circumstance of dignity should be treated as a qualifying element of the offense or as a generic aggravating circumstance in this case.
- Whether or not the circumstance of recidivation may be considered against the accused.
Applicable Provisions
Article 458 of the Penal Code, as quoted in the decision, provides:
Article 458 of the Penal Code provides that written injurias graves made public shall be punished by banishment from the medium to the maximum degree and a fine of 625 to 6,250 pesetas.
This is the provision that fixes the crime and its penalty, and the Court holds that the trial court failed to impose it.
Article 460 of the Penal Code, as quoted in the decision, provides:
the defendant in a prosecution for libel (injuria) shall not be allowed to introduce evidence as to the truth of the charges
This is the prohibition the trial judge treated as a bar to considering the complainant's dignity, and which the Court holds is no such bar.
Article 28 of the Penal Code, as stated in the decision, provides that the duration of banishment is:
from six months and a day to six years
This shows that the penalty of six months of banishment imposed below is not a penalty the Code recognizes at all.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the penalty imposed below was not the penalty the Code prescribes. Article 458 punishes written and public grave insults with banishment from the medium to the maximum degree and a fine of 625 to 6,250 pesetas. Under Article 462, an insult is considered made in writing and publicly when it is effected by means of printed papers, which is precisely what occurred. The minimum duration of banishment in its medium degree is two years, four months, and one day under the demonstrative table of Article 96. Hence, even if the penalty under Article 458 were imposed in its minimum degree, it could never be six months only, especially since the Code does not recognize banishment for so short a time.
On the second issue, the Court held that the prohibition against evidence of the truth of the libelous publication is not and cannot be an obstacle to considering the dignity of the complainant in the commission of the offense. The Court reasoned that this very circumstance constitutes one of the reasons for regarding the insult as grave, since what is in itself merely a slight insult may be regarded as grave by reason of the status, dignity, and circumstances of the complainant or of the defendant. Dignity can and should therefore be considered, notwithstanding the prohibition, for the purpose of giving the proper legal classification to the offense and determining the penalty.
On the third issue, the Court drew the decisive distinction. When the status and dignity of the complainant must be taken into account as an element constituting the gravity of the defamation, that circumstance is a qualification of the offense and cannot augment the penalty, because the law has already considered it in defining and punishing the crime. But when the defamation is per se of a grave character, or is so classified independently of the dignity of the person defamed, then the circumstance is to be regarded as a generic aggravating circumstance. The present case falls under the second situation, so the trial court violated the provision on generic aggravating circumstances by failing to regard it as such.
On the fourth issue, the Court held that in addition to the aggravating circumstance of disregard for the dignity of the complainant, the circumstance of recidivation must be considered against the defendant, because he had already been convicted of the same offense of grave insult by a prior judgment of the Court.
Doctrine
Written and public grave insults are punished under Article 458 with banishment from the medium to the maximum degree and a fine of 625 to 6,250 pesetas, and the minimum of banishment in its medium degree is two years, four months, and one day. A penalty of six months of banishment is void of legal basis, since banishment under Article 28 runs from six months and a day to six years.
The prohibition in Article 460 against evidence of the truth of a libelous charge does not prevent the court from considering the dignity of the offended party. Where that dignity is an element that makes the defamation grave, it is a qualifying circumstance and cannot aggravate the penalty, for the law has already considered it. Where the defamation is per se grave, the dignity of the complainant is a generic aggravating circumstance that the court must appreciate. Recidivation likewise aggravates where the accused has previously been convicted of an offense under the same title of the Code.
Disposition
The Court modified the judgment appealed, condemning Valdez to six years of banishment from the city of Manila and the territory surrounding it within a radius of 250 kilometers, and to a fine of 6,250 pesetas, with subsidiary banishment in case of nonpayment and the costs of the instance, and affirmed the judgment as thus modified.
Remember This
The one line to memorize: the ban on proving the truth of a libel does not shield the offender from the aggravating circumstance of the complainant's dignity. Examiners use this case to test the distinction between a qualifying circumstance already absorbed by the law and a generic aggravating circumstance that must still be appreciated, and to test whether you can compute the correct penalty under the old Penal Code.