🎧 Case Brief Lecture

THE UNITED STATES, COMPLAINANT AND APPELLANT, VS. THE MUNICIPAL COUNCIL OF SANTA CRUZ DE MALABON, DEFENDANT AND APPELLEE.

G.R. No. 506. February 16, 1903 February 16, 1903

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

United States versus Municipal Council of Santa Cruz de Malabon

The Case

This is a criminal procedure case from the early American period in the Philippines. The United States, as complainant and appellant, sought to prosecute the municipal council of Santa Cruz de Malabon for adopting a resolution that imposed a tax of three pesos on each cavan of seed produced by landholders on a hacienda, allegedly to pay the expenses of a suit. The case matters because it fixes the rule that under the American system of criminal procedure, the prosecution of public offenses belongs to the Government, not to any private citizen, and that only the person injured by the offense may take part in the prosecution. It is the anchor case for the doctrine that the popular penal action of the old Spanish system was not carried over into General Orders, Number 58.

Procedural History

The Philippine Sugar Estates Development Company, Limited, a corporation domiciled in Manila, filed a supplementary prayer in a voluntary jurisdiction proceeding for judicial possession. It asked that the transcript of certain minutes be sent to the provincial fiscal so that he might file the corresponding information. The provincial fiscal declined to file an information, because he did not regard the facts as constituting the offense covered by the articles of the Penal Code cited by the corporation's representative. The judge dismissed the complaint in the preliminary investigation. On the twenty-third of September, nineteen hundred and one, when the corporation's representative appeared to file the formal complaint, notice of the order of dismissal was served upon him. On the same day he appealed against that order, relying on articles forty-three and forty-four of General Orders, Number 58. The case reached the Supreme Court by that appeal.

Facts

The Philippine Sugar Estates Development Company, Limited, a corporation domiciled in Manila, was involved in a voluntary jurisdiction proceeding for judicial possession. In a supplementary prayer, it asked that the transcript of certain minutes be sent to the provincial fiscal so that he could file the corresponding information.

The attached copy of the minutes of a meeting of the municipal council of Santa Cruz, Cavite, showed a resolution adopted by that council to impose upon landholders on the hacienda a tax of three pesos on each cavan of seed produced by the lands cultivated by them, for the purpose of paying the expenses of the suit, and the appointment of a collector and treasurer of this tax. This supplementary petition and the attached copy of the minutes became the basis of a separate proceeding in the nature of a preliminary investigation.

The provincial fiscal did not think it proper to file an information, as he did not regard the facts as constituting the offense covered by the articles of the Penal Code cited by the corporation's representative. The judge dismissed the complaint in the preliminary investigation. When the corporation's representative appeared on the twenty-third of September, nineteen hundred and one, to file the formal complaint, notice was served upon him of the order of dismissal, and he appealed on the same day.

Issues

  • Whether or not a private corporation may bring a criminal prosecution for an act it believes to be a public offense, under the system of criminal procedure established by General Orders, Number 58.
  • Whether or not the complainant corporation, domiciled in Manila, has shown itself to be a person injured by the act denounced, such that it may take part in the prosecution or appeal from the denial of that right.

Applicable Provisions

Article 107 of General Orders, Number 58, under the heading rights of the person injured by the offense, provides:

The privilege now secured by law to the person claiming to be injured by the commission of an offense to take part in the prosecution of the offense and recover damages for the injury sustained by reason of the same shall not be abridged by the provisions of this order.

This provision is the Court's textual anchor: it preserves only the right of the injured person, and by its express and special inclusion the Court reads the most express exclusion of any other right, such as the popular penal action.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held that under the American system the prosecution of public offenses is reserved to the representative of the Government to such an extent that the individual citizen cannot bring an action for that purpose. The citizen is protected by his right to bring a personal action for the damage which the commission of a crime may occasion him; as to him, the crime is but the source of a civil obligation. General Orders, Number 58, as a concession to the period of transition, compromised only with the private penal action of the injured party, and with that alone, not with the action which under the former law might be brought by any citizen who desired to aid the action of the Government. The Court explained that the private penal action of the injured party was maintained for two reasons: first, because on principle the declaration of criminal liability carries with it the declaration of the resulting civil obligation; and second, because there are crimes which cannot be prosecuted other than at the formal instance of the person injured.

On the second issue, the Court held that until it is made to appear that the complainant corporation, domiciled in Manila, forms part of the inhabitants of Santa Cruz, Cavite, upon whom might fall the burden of this so-called illegal exaction, it has not been shown that the corporation has been or might be injured by the commission of the act denounced as a crime. Consequently it has no right to bring a prosecution for such an act, nor to appeal against the denial of such a right, or the refusal to regard as a crime an act which in its opinion constitutes such an offense.

Doctrine

Under the American system of criminal procedure adopted in General Orders, Number 58, the prosecution of public offenses is reserved to the representative of the Government. A private citizen cannot bring a criminal action for a public offense; his remedy is a personal civil action for the damage the crime may have occasioned him, because as to him the crime is but the source of a civil obligation.

The only private participation preserved is the private penal action of the injured party, as secured by article 107 of General Orders, Number 58. That express and special inclusion of the injured person's right is the most express exclusion of the popular penal action of the old Spanish system, which allowed any citizen to aid the Government's action.

To take part in the prosecution, the private complainant must show that he is himself injured by the offense. A corporation domiciled elsewhere, which has not shown that it forms part of the inhabitants upon whom the burden of the challenged exaction would fall, has shown no injury and therefore no right to prosecute or to appeal from the denial of that right.

Disposition

The appeal was dismissed, with costs, and the order of dismissal in favor of the municipal council of Santa Cruz de Malabon stood.

Remember This

Memorize the line: under the American system the prosecution of public offenses is reserved to the representative of the Government, and only the injured party may take part, as article 107 of General Orders, Number 58 secures. Examiners use this case to test the absence of the popular penal action and the requirement that a private complainant show personal injury before he may prosecute or appeal.