🎧 Case Brief Lecture

THE UNITED STATES, COMPLAINANT AND APPELLANT, VS. TOMASA DE LOS EEYES, DEFENDANT AND APPELLEE.

G.R. No. 504. September 16, 1902 September 16, 1902

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

United States versus De los Reyes

The Case

This is a criminal case in which the Government of the United States, as complainant and appellant, proceeded against Tomasa de los Reyes, the defendant and appellee, on a complaint for bigamy under the old Penal Code. The complaining witness was Julian Gonzalez, the defendant's first husband, who appealed from a judgment of acquittal. The case matters for two reasons. First, it fixes the rule that a mistake of fact which negatives the criminal intent defeats a charge of bigamy. Second, and more importantly for the bar, it holds that the same mistaken second marriage may still be punished, not as intentional bigamy, but as criminal negligence. It is the classic illustration of how intent and diligence divide criminal liability.

Procedural History

The complaint for bigamy was filed against the defendant in the Court of First Instance of Manila. After trial, that court rendered a judgment of acquittal, and the complaining witness, Julian Gonzalez, appealed from that judgment to the Supreme Court. The case therefore reached the Supreme Court by appeal taken by the complaining witness from an acquittal, and the Court reviewed both the acquittal and the question of the defendant's criminal negligence.

Facts

The defendant was married to Julian Gonzalez in Manila on May 27, 1897. After living together in Manila for a time, they separated, and the defendant remained in the house where they had been living until some time after July 12, 1900. On that day she was married in Manila, by a Protestant clergyman, to Ramon Martinez. Her defense was that she honestly believed her first husband was dead when she married Martinez.

After the separation, the mother and some other relatives of Gonzalez lived in the same house with the defendant. Gonzalez testified that the separation took place in March 1900, and that he also lived for some months in the lower story of the same house while the defendant lived in the upper story. He further testified that after he left that house and went to live elsewhere, he visited his relatives there nearly every day down to a few days before the trial, which took place in September 1901. He said he often saw his wife at these times and supplied her with means for her support through his relatives, but that he never spoke with her. A short time after her second marriage, the defendant moved away from the house and has since lived elsewhere.

The defendant testified that she and Gonzalez had been living together a year and two months when the separation took place, which would fix the separation in July 1898. She testified that some time during the year following the separation, she was told by the mother of Gonzalez that she had been informed that her son was dead. Thereupon prayers were said for his soul for nine nights, and she put on mourning and wore it for a year. She said she contracted the second marriage with the consent of the mother of Gonzalez, believing that the information she had received from her as to the death of Gonzalez was true. The mother of Gonzalez died before the trial. On the whole, the Court reached the conclusion, though not without some hesitation, that the story told by the defendant was in the main more likely to be true than false, and that she probably did contract the second marriage under a bona fide belief that the first marriage had been dissolved by the death of Gonzalez.

Issues

  • Whether or not the defendant may be convicted of bigamy under the Penal Code where, by reason of a mistake of fact, the intention to commit the crime did not exist.
  • Whether or not the defendant is chargeable with criminal negligence in contracting the second marriage, for failure to exercise the diligence required by law.

Applicable Provisions

The decision applies article 471 of the Penal Code, the bigamy provision under which the complaint was brought, and refers to article 475 on mistake of fact as applied in the earlier case of the United States versus Marcosa Penalosa and Enrique Rodriguez. The Court states the governing principle of that earlier ruling as follows:

There can be no conviction under article 475 of the Penal Code, where by reason of a mistake of fact the intention to commit the crime does not exist.

This principle bears directly on the bigamy charge, because the defendant's honest belief in the death of her first husband negated the criminal intent.

The Court then turns to article 568 of the Penal Code, which it applies to the defendant's negligent conduct:

The act of contracting a second or subsequent marriage, the prior marriage not having been lawfully dissolved, being one which, if done with malice, would constitute a grave crime, the offense committed by the defendant is punishable by arresto mayor in its maximum degree to prision correccional in its minimum degree.

This provision supplies the penalty for the negligence the Court found, and it is the basis for modifying the judgment of acquittal.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held that the defendant was properly acquitted of the crime charged in the complaint. Applying the rule of the earlier Penalosa case, the Court reasoned that where a mistake of fact negatives the intention to commit the crime, there can be no conviction. The defendant probably contracted the second marriage under a bona fide belief that the first marriage had been dissolved by the death of Gonzalez, and so the intent required for bigamy was absent.

On the second issue, however, the Court held that the defendant is chargeable with criminal negligence in contracting the second marriage, and should have been convicted under article 568 of the Penal Code. It did not appear that she made any attempt to ascertain for herself whether the information received by her mother-in-law as to the death of Gonzalez was to be relied upon. She never even saw or communicated directly in any way with the persons who gave her mother-in-law that information. Moreover, viewing the testimony in the light most favorable to her, she waited less than two years after hearing of the death of her husband before contracting the second marriage. The Court laid down the standard of care in these words:

The diligence with which the law requires the individual at all times to govern his conduct varies with the nature of the situation in which he is placed and with the importance of the act which he is to perform.

In a matter so important to the good order of society as that in question, where the consequences of a mistake are necessarily so serious, nothing less than the highest degree of diligence will satisfy the standard prescribed by the law. The Court could not say that the defendant acted with that diligence. Finding no aggravating circumstance, and considering that the extenuating circumstance of article 11 of the Penal Code may properly be considered, the Court applied the penalty in its minimum degree.

Doctrine

First, in bigamy, as in other crimes, a mistake of fact that negatives the criminal intent defeats conviction. An honest and bona fide belief that the first spouse is dead removes the malice required for the intentional crime.

Second, the same act may still give rise to criminal negligence under article 568 of the Penal Code where the accused fails to exercise the diligence the law demands. The degree of diligence required varies with the nature of the situation and the importance of the act to be performed. In contracting a second marriage, where the consequences of a mistake are necessarily serious, nothing less than the highest degree of diligence will satisfy the standard. A person who relies on hearsay about a spouse's death, without any attempt to verify it, is criminally negligent.

Disposition

The Court modified the judgment of the court below, acquitting the defendant of bigamy but sentencing her to four months and one day of arresto mayor, with costs.

Remember This

Memorize this line: an honest mistake of fact negates intent and defeats bigamy, but the same mistaken marriage, entered without the highest degree of diligence, is punishable as criminal negligence. Examiners use this case to test the distinction between intent and negligence, and the rule that the required diligence rises with the gravity of the act.