THE UNITED STATES, COMPLAINANT AND APPELLEE, VS. ANTONIO ACUNA ET ALV DEFENDANTS AND APPELLANTS.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
United States versus Acuna
The Case
This is a criminal appeal from the Court of First Instance of Iloilo, decided in the earliest years of the American regime in the Philippines, when the old Spanish Penal Code still governed. The United States prosecuted Antonio Acuna and five others for unlawful gaming under the Penal Code, and the accused appealed their conviction to the Supreme Court. The case matters for two reasons: it fixes what makes a house a gaming house within the meaning of the law, and it shows how the Court treats the forfeiture of gambling money and apparatus. It is a short, clean authority on the elements of the offense and on the sufficiency of circumstantial and reputation evidence to prove the character of a place.
Procedural History
The provincial fiscal of Iloilo filed a complaint with the Court of First Instance, alleging that unlawful gaming was being carried on in a certain house. Acting on that complaint, the judge of the Court of First Instance, accompanied by the fiscal, the clerk, and other officers of the court, personally visited the house on the evening of April 30, 1901. The trial court convicted the appellants under article 343 of the Penal Code — the six players as players, and Antonio Acuna as the lessee and proprietor of the premises. The court also declared forfeited, under article 345 of the Penal Code, the gambling apparatus and the money seized during the raid. The appellants brought the case to the Supreme Court by appeal. The Supreme Court affirmed the judgment of the court below, with costs, and remanded the case to that court for execution of the judgment.
Facts
On the evening of April 30, 1901, the judge of the Court of First Instance of Iloilo, together with the provincial fiscal, the clerk, and other court officers, went to a house in Iloilo in response to the fiscal's complaint that unlawful gaming was being carried on there. Upon entering, they found a number of persons engaged in playing the game known as "monte." Among those present were the six appellants, who were playing, and Jacinto Ramos, who was acting as banker. The usual apparatus of the game was in use, and the judge ordered its seizure, together with some 89 pesos in money.
Antonio Acuna was admitted to be the lessee of the premises during the period covered by the evidence, and the Court held that he could be held responsible as proprietor. The evidence also showed that the house was not used for gaming on that single evening alone. Mariano Nara testified that he had been in the house and had seen gambling going on there on an occasion distinct from the raid, and Ceferino M. Fontbuena gave evidence to the same effect. Perfecto Izar, whose testimony the Court regarded as substantially unimpeached, testified that he had been employed by Antonio Acuna to bring players to the house, receiving as compensation a percentage of the profits.
The defense offered only the statements of a number of witnesses who, in substance, merely said that they had never heard of gambling being carried on in the house except on the evening of the raid. The Court noted that the lessee had occupied the house only a short time when the raid occurred, but held that the length of time the unlawful business had continued could have no materiality once it was shown that the business had been established on the premises.
Issues
- Whether or not the appellant Teano was a mere spectator and not a participant in the game, so as to be exempt from liability as a player.
- Whether or not the house in question was a gaming house within the meaning of article 343 of the Penal Code, that is, a house specially devoted to the encouragement or promotion of gaming.
- Whether or not the money and gambling apparatus seized during the raid were properly declared forfeited under article 345 of the Penal Code.
Applicable Provisions
Article 343 of the Penal Code, which defines the offense and the persons liable, provides:
The bankers and proprietors of gaming houses (casas de juego de suerte, envite o azar) and the players in such houses shall be punished.
This is the provision under which the appellants were convicted, and it makes the character of the house as a gaming house the central question.
Article 345 of the Penal Code, which governs the forfeiture of gambling items, provides:
The money or other articles and the instruments and tools used in gambling or raffles shall be confiscated.
This is the provision under which the trial court declared the 89 pesos and the gambling apparatus forfeited.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court rejected the claim of the appellant Teano that he was a mere spectator. The act drawn up under the authority of the judge, reciting what was discovered and done at the time the premises were visited, stated that Teano was one of the players, and the Court found nothing in the evidence to justify the conclusion that this fact was incorrectly stated. He was therefore properly convicted as a player.
On the second issue, the Court held that the only substantial question was whether the house was a gaming house, which it defined as "a house specially devoted to the encouragement or promotion" of gaming. The Court found that the positive testimony of Nara and Fontbuena, who had seen gambling in the house on an occasion distinct from the raid, and of Izar, who had been employed by Acuna to bring players to the house for a percentage of the profits, established the character of the house. Against this positive evidence, the defense offered only witnesses who said they had never heard of gambling there except on the night of the raid. The Court also found that the nature of the things found in the house by the judge tended strongly to establish its character, and concluded that unlawful gaming was carried on there as a business by the lessee. The Court added that the short time the lessee had occupied the house was immaterial once the unlawful business was shown to have been established on the premises.
On the third issue, the Court upheld the forfeiture of the money and gambling apparatus under article 345 of the Penal Code, which provides that the money or other articles and the instruments and tools used in gambling shall be confiscated.
Doctrine
A gaming house under article 343 of the Penal Code is a house specially devoted to the encouragement or promotion of gaming — not merely a place where gaming happens to occur on a single occasion. To establish that character, the prosecution may rely on evidence of gambling on occasions other than the raid, on testimony that the proprietor employed a person to bring players to the house for a share of the profits, and on the nature of the apparatus and things found in the house. The length of time the unlawful business has continued is immaterial once it is shown that the business was established on the premises. The lessee of the premises may be held liable as proprietor. A person who is present in a gaming house and is identified in the record as a player is liable as a player, and a bare claim that he was a mere spectator will not prevail against the recitals of the official act. Finally, under article 345 of the Penal Code, the money and the instruments and tools used in gambling are subject to confiscation.
Disposition
The Supreme Court affirmed the judgment of the Court of First Instance of Iloilo, with costs, and remanded the case to that court for execution of the judgment.
Remember This
The single line worth memorizing is that a gaming house is a house specially devoted to the encouragement or promotion of gaming, and the lessee who runs it as a business is liable as proprietor. Examiners use this case to test the definition of a gaming house, the sufficiency of evidence of prior gambling and of paid recruiters of players, and the forfeiture of gambling money and apparatus.