FRUTO FELICIANO ET AL., PLAINTIFFS AND APPELLANTS, VS. ESCOLASTICO FERNANDEZ ET AL., DEFENDANTS AND APPELLEES.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Feliciano versus Fernandez
The Case
This is an old decision, rendered in March 1902, and it is worth studying because it shows how the Court treated the territorial jurisdiction of a notary under the Spanish notarial law that Spain had extended to the Philippines. The plaintiffs, Fruto Feliciano and others, brought an action to annul and cancel the will of the deceased Fernanda Trinidad. The defendants were Escolastico Fernandez, who had been named sole and universal heir, and after his death during the litigation, his heirs Petrona and Dionisia Fernandez y Limasin. The plaintiffs lost in the Court of First Instance and appealed. The case matters for the bar because it fixes a simple but often tested rule: a notary's competence is measured by the territorial limits of the judicial district in which his office is established, not by the town of his residence.
Procedural History
The dispute began in an intestate proceeding. After the probate of the intestate estate of Fernanda Trinidad was solicited, Escolastico Fernandez appeared as the surviving spouse and asked that the proceedings be dismissed, filing a certified copy of a will dated August 30, 1899, executed before the notary public of Pasig, Matias Salamante y Villanueva, which made him the sole and universal heir. During the pendency of the litigation Escolastico Fernandez died, and the proceedings were continued against his heirs, Petrona and Dionisia Fernandez y Limasin. The trial court, the Court of First Instance, terminated the trial, discharged the defendants from the prayer of the complaint, and perpetually quieted the claims of the plaintiffs, with costs taxed against them. The plaintiffs appealed to the Supreme Court, which affirmed the judgment of the Court of First Instance, with costs of this appeal taxed against the appellants.
Facts
Fernanda Trinidad died leaving a will dated August 30, 1899, executed before Matias Salamante y Villanueva, the notary public of Pasig. The will constituted her husband, Escolastico Fernandez, her sole and universal heir. When the intestate estate was opened, Escolastico appeared as surviving spouse and sought dismissal of the intestate proceedings on the strength of that will.
The plaintiffs then brought this action to annul and cancel the will. Their principal ground was that the notarial authority of Salamante was created by royal decree with the town of Pasig as the place of his residence, and that the will was in fact executed before him in the city of Manila, outside the jurisdiction of the notary, so that the act was null and of no force or effect.
The Court examined the notarial law then in force. By royal decree of February 15, 1889, the notarial law of May 28, 1862, prevailing in the Peninsula, that is, in Spain, was put in force in the Philippines with certain modifications, to take effect on July 1, 1889. The Court found that Tondo was in the judicial district of which the town of Pasig formed a part, and that Salamante therefore had authority to authenticate the execution of the will in the city of Manila. The remaining grounds of nullity alleged by the plaintiffs referred to formalities of little importance which did not affect the validity of the will, and the greater part of them were not in conformity with the facts as they appeared in the record.
Issues
- Whether or not the will executed in the city of Manila before a notary whose office was established at Pasig is null for having been executed outside the jurisdiction of the notary.
- Whether or not the other grounds of nullity alleged by the plaintiffs, relating to the formalities of execution, affect the validity of the will.
Applicable Provisions
Article 3 of the notarial law of May 28, 1862, put in force in the Philippines by royal decree of February 15, 1889, provides:
Article 3. The office of notary shall include the territorial limits of the judicial districts in which the same were established.
This is the provision on which the whole case turns, because it defines the territory within which a notary may validly act, and it is measured by the judicial district, not by the town of residence.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the will was not null. The plaintiffs assumed that the notary's authority was confined to the town of Pasig because that was the place of his residence. The Court rejected that assumption and looked to the statute. Under Article 3 of the notarial law, the office of notary includes the territorial limits of the judicial district in which it is established. Since Tondo was in the judicial district of which the town of Pasig formed a part, Salamante had authority to authenticate the execution of the will in the city of Manila. The contest of the will therefore could not be sustained.
On the second issue, the Court held that the other grounds of nullity alleged by the plaintiffs referred to formalities of little importance which did not affect the validity of the will. Moreover, the greater part of them were not in conformity with the facts as they appeared in the record. The judgment of the Court of First Instance was affirmed, with costs of this appeal taxed against the appellants.
Doctrine
A notary's competence is territorial, and it is measured by the judicial district, not by the town of his residence. Under Article 3 of the notarial law then in force, the office of notary includes the territorial limits of the judicial district in which the office is established. A notarial act performed within that district is valid even if performed in a place other than the notary's town of residence. Conversely, an act performed outside the district would be outside the notary's authority. Defects in the formalities of a will that are of little importance, and that are not borne out by the record, do not affect its validity.
Disposition
The Supreme Court affirmed the judgment of the Court of First Instance, upheld the will, and taxed the costs of the appeal against the plaintiffs and appellants.
Remember This
Memorize the line: the office of notary includes the territorial limits of the judicial district in which it is established, so residence in a town does not confine the notary to that town. Examiners use this case to test the territorial jurisdiction of notaries and the distinction between the place of residence and the judicial district.