🎧 Case Brief Lecture

THE UNITED STATES, COMPLAINANT AND APPELLEE, VS. LIOBRIO ABIJAN, DEFENDANT AND APPELLANT.

G.R. No. 476. January 07, 1902 January 7, 1902

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

United States versus Abijan

The Case

This is a criminal case from the early years of the American occupation, decided in January 1902. The United States, as complainant and appellee, prosecuted Liobrio Abijan, the defendant and appellant, for the killing of Andres Opao, the vice-president of the barrio of Dos Hermanas in the pueblo of Talisay. The charge arose from an assault with a dagger committed while the victim was discharging his duties as a representative of the Government. The case matters to a reviewee because it illustrates the compound crime of attack upon an agent of the Government with homicide, and because it shows how the Supreme Court, on an appeal taken by the accused, may revise the judgment and increase the penalty by applying the correct aggravating and mitigating circumstances.

Procedural History

The case was tried in the Superior Court of the Island of Negros. That court rendered judgment, and in doing so it applied the extenuating circumstances numbered four and seven of article 9 of the Penal Code, and it also took into account the intoxication of the accused. The accused then exercised his right of appeal, bringing the case before the Supreme Court of the Philippine Islands. The Supreme Court reviewed the record and revised the judgment appealed from.

Facts

On the evening of the twenty-fifth of October 1899, Andres Opao, the vice-president, was inspecting the barrio of Dos Hermanas of the pueblo of Talisay to ascertain whether its residents were complying with the order to place lights in front of their houses. He noted that Licerio Abijan, one of the residents, had not placed a light in front of his house. Abijan failed to present himself when called twice through the medium of the deputy, Eugenio Area, and so the officer stationed himself in the neighborhood of Abijan's house.

When Abijan was called anew, he descended and was taken to task for his failure to comply with the order. He then heard Opao order his arrest. Thereupon he assaulted Opao, inflicting a mortal wound in the left groin and another light wound on the palm of the hand. The defendant fled immediately. Opao died as a result of the wound in the groin, according to the medical report.

The accused confessed having attacked the deceased. His explanation was that the deceased, because of his failure to have a light in the window of his house as ordered, called him out and, on his descending, took him to task with harsh words and struck him with a cane. He said he received the blow on his hand in attempting to ward it off, and that the intense pain he suffered in his little finger blinded him, so that, drawing the dagger which he carried in his belt, he assaulted Andres Opao with it and then set out to run. The Court found these facts proved by ocular inspection, expert testimony, the declarations of credible witnesses, and by the confession of the accused. The Court held that the excuse alleged by the defendant could not be entertained for failure of proof, since it was not confirmed by the only witness who was present, Eugenio Area.

Issues

  • Whether or not the accused is guilty of the compound crime of attack upon an agent of the Government with homicide.
  • Whether or not the excuse alleged by the accused, that he was struck with a cane and blinded by pain, may be entertained.
  • Whether or not the order of arrest given by the deceased furnished cause or reason for the fatal assault.
  • Whether or not the extenuating circumstances of article 9 and the intoxication of the accused should be considered.
  • Whether or not the aggravating circumstance of making use of arms prohibited by the regulations should be appreciated, and whether or not it is offset by a mitigating circumstance.
  • Whether or not the Supreme Court may increase the penalty and apply the proper provisions of the penal law on the appeal taken by the accused.

Applicable Provisions

The decision refers to articles 249, 250, and 404 of the Penal Code, in relation with article 89, as the provisions defining the compound crime of attack upon an agent of the Government and homicide. The Court states the nature of the crime as follows:

These facts, proved in the cause by ocular inspection, expert testimony, the declarations of credible witnesses, and by the confession of the accused, constitute the compound crime of attack upon an agent of the Government and homicide—included in articles 249, 250, and 404 in relation with' article 89 of the Penal Code—in that the defendant without legal reason or justifiable motive assaulted with a dagger the local president of the barrio of Dos Hermanas while the latter was in the discharge of his duties as a representative of the Government; and in consequence of the mortal wound which he inflicted in the left groin the said president died a few moments later.

This passage bears on the case because it fixes the legal characterization of the act as a compound crime, committed against a representative of the Government in the discharge of his duties.

On the aggravating and mitigating circumstances, the Court applies the following:

For these reasons it is not proper to consider the extenuating circumstances fourth and seventh of article 9 applied by the Superior Court of Negros, nor the intoxication of the accused, for the reason that such state was habitual to him; but there should be considered the aggravating circumstance No. 24 of article 10 of the Code, since the crime was committed by making use of arms prohibited by the regulations. This circumstance is offset, however, by the mitigating circumstance established by article 11 of the Code, and therefore, according to article 89 above cited, the accused has incurred the penalty for the crime of homicide applied in the medium grade of its maximum degree.

This passage bears on the case because it explains why the penalty was fixed in the medium grade of the maximum degree of the penalty for homicide.

On the power of the appellate court, the decision states:

Furthermore, this court is fully authorized to increase the penalty and apply the proper provisions of the penal law, since the right of appeal exercised by the accused confers upon the court full jurisdiction and renders it competent to examine the record and revise the judgment appealed from.

This passage bears on the case because it is the basis for the Court's authority to revise the judgment and impose a heavier penalty than that rendered below.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held that the facts constitute the compound crime of attack upon an agent of the Government and homicide, included in articles 249, 250, and 404 in relation with article 89 of the Penal Code. The defendant, without legal reason or justifiable motive, assaulted with a dagger the local president of the barrio of Dos Hermanas while the latter was in the discharge of his duties as a representative of the Government, and the mortal wound in the left groin caused the president's death a few moments later.

On the second issue, the Court refused to entertain the excuse alleged by the defendant for failure of proof, since it was not confirmed by the only witness who was present, Eugenio Area.

On the third issue, the Court held that the order of arrest given by the deceased, for the violation of an ordinance committed by the accused, furnishes neither cause nor reason for the latter to have made a fatal assault with a deadly weapon upon the said representative of the Government.

On the fourth issue, the Court held that it is not proper to consider the extenuating circumstances fourth and seventh of article 9 applied by the Superior Court of Negros, nor the intoxication of the accused, for the reason that such state was habitual to him.

On the fifth issue, the Court held that the aggravating circumstance numbered twenty-four of article 10 should be considered, since the crime was committed by making use of arms prohibited by the regulations. This circumstance is offset, however, by the mitigating circumstance established by article 11, and therefore, according to article 89, the accused incurred the penalty for the crime of homicide applied in the medium grade of its maximum degree.

On the sixth issue, the Court held that it is fully authorized to increase the penalty and apply the proper provisions of the penal law, since the right of appeal exercised by the accused confers upon the court full jurisdiction and renders it competent to examine the record and revise the judgment appealed from.

Doctrine

A Bar candidate should retain these rules. First, the killing of a local president of a barrio, committed with a deadly weapon while he is in the discharge of his duties as a representative of the Government, and without legal reason or justifiable motive, constitutes the compound crime of attack upon an agent of the Government with homicide. Second, an excuse offered by the accused must be proved; it cannot be entertained where it is not confirmed by the only witness present. Third, the lawful order of arrest for a violation of an ordinance furnishes neither cause nor reason for a fatal assault upon the officer. Fourth, the intoxication of the accused is not considered where the state is habitual to him. Fifth, the use of arms prohibited by the regulations is an aggravating circumstance, but it may be offset by a mitigating circumstance, so that the penalty is applied in the medium grade of its maximum degree. Sixth, the right of appeal exercised by the accused confers upon the appellate court full jurisdiction to examine the record and revise the judgment appealed from, and this authority extends to increasing the penalty and applying the proper provisions of the penal law.

Disposition

The Supreme Court reversed the judgment of the Superior Court of the Island of Negros and condemned Licerio Abijan to eighteen years, two months, and twenty-one days of reclusion temporal as the perpetrator of the compound crime of attack upon an officer of the Government with homicide, to the accessory punishments provided in article 59 of the Code, to the payment of an indemnity of 1,000 pesos, Mexican, to the widow and heirs of the deceased, and to the payment of the costs in both instances.

Remember This

The single line worth memorizing is that the right of appeal exercised by the accused confers upon the Supreme Court full jurisdiction to examine the record and revise the judgment appealed from, even to the extent of increasing the penalty. Examiners like to use this case to test the compound crime of attack upon an agent of the Government with homicide, and the power of the appellate court to revise and increase the penalty on the accused's own appeal.