THE UNITED STATES, COMPLAINANT AND APPELLANT, VS. JOSE REYES, DEFENDANT AND APPELLEE.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
United States versus Reyes
The Case
This is a criminal case in which the Government of the United States, as complainant and appellant, brought proceedings against Jose Reyes, a railway employee, for the crimes of estafa and falsification. The question before the Supreme Court is not guilt but geography: which court has jurisdiction to try the offense? The case matters because it fixes a rule every bar candidate must know — that jurisdiction over a criminal case is determined by the place where the crime was committed, and that it cannot be conferred by the consent of the parties or by the mere assumption of a court.
Procedural History
The complaint was filed in the Court of First Instance of Manila, charging the defendant with estafa and falsification. The trial court took cognizance of the case on the view that the place of the commission of the crime was not clearly shown. Later, however, the proceedings revealed that the appropriation and the use of the alleged false document took place in Tarlac. On that ground the Court of First Instance of Manila declared itself without jurisdiction and dismissed the case. The Government appealed that order to the Supreme Court, which affirmed the dismissal.
Facts
Jose Reyes was an employee of the Manila-Dagupan Railway. On the eighteenth of July, 1901, he issued a ticket to a passenger traveling from Manila to Caloocan who continued his trip to Malolos. The fare actually due was one peso and twenty-two cents. The ticket he issued, however, simulated a trip from Manila to Bocaue and charged only eighteen cents. He rendered account to the company for the smaller amount and kept the difference.
The complaint did not precisely designate the place where the falsification was committed, nor where the money was appropriated. The testimony failed to establish the first point, but it did establish the second. The accused himself testified that he rendered account to the station master at Tarlac, delivered the money collected on the trip amounting to six pesos and forty-eight cents, and delivered the stub in which the simulation was committed.
The record contained an itemized account of the collections, dated in Tarlac, with an invoice of delivery signed by the accused and a receipt signed by the station master for six pesos and forty-eight cents. That sum included the eighteen cents entered on the stub. The Court found this document fully corroborated the accused, and concluded that both the appropriation and the use of the stub were consummated in Tarlac.
Issues
- Whether or not the Court of First Instance of Manila had jurisdiction to try the offense charged, the place of its commission not being clearly shown in the complaint.
- Whether or not a court that has taken cognizance of a criminal case may declare itself without jurisdiction once the lack of jurisdiction appears from the proceedings subsequently had.
Applicable Provisions
Article 29 of the General Compilation of Laws upon Criminal Procedure provides:
Jurisdiction to try the offense charged is vested in the court of the place where the crime was committed.
This is the provision the Court applied to hold that the court of Tarlac, not Manila, had jurisdiction.
Article 23 of the same compilation provides:
Jurisdiction over criminal cases can not be conferred by consent.
This answers the argument that the Manila court's assumption of jurisdiction was binding.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that jurisdiction vested in the court of Tarlac. Under article 29 of the General Compilation of Laws upon Criminal Procedure, jurisdiction to try the offense charged is vested in the court of Tarlac, not only because it was within the territory of that court that the appropriation constituting the crime of estafa was committed, but also because within the same territory the accused made use of the document alleged to be false, it not appearing with certainty at what place the falsification was committed. The Court relied on a judgment of the supreme court of Spain of October 7, 1896.
On the second issue, the Court held that the Manila court's earlier assumption of jurisdiction was no obstacle to its declaring itself without jurisdiction as soon as the lack of jurisdiction appeared from the proceedings subsequently had. Jurisdiction over criminal cases cannot be conferred by consent.
Doctrine
Jurisdiction over a criminal case is determined by the place where the crime was committed. Where the complaint does not clearly show the place of commission, the court may take cognizance, but it must decline jurisdiction once the evidence shows the offense was committed elsewhere. Jurisdiction over criminal cases cannot be conferred by consent, by waiver, or by the mere assumption of a court. A court that finds it has no jurisdiction must dismiss the case.
Disposition
The Supreme Court affirmed the order of the Court of First Instance of Manila dismissing the case for lack of jurisdiction, with costs against the appellant.
Remember This
Memorize the line: jurisdiction over criminal cases cannot be conferred by consent. Examiners use this case to test venue in criminal cases and the rule that a court must dismiss once lack of jurisdiction appears.