🎧 Case Brief Lecture

DIRECTOR OF LANDS, PETITIONER, VS. THE HONORABLE COURT OF APPEALS, SILVESTRE MANLAPAZ AND NATIVIDAD PIZARRO, RESPONDENTS.

G.R. No. 45828. June 01, 1992 June 1, 1992

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

Director of Lands versus Manlapaz

The Case

This is a petition for review on certiorari brought by the Director of Lands against the Court of Appeals and the spouses Silvestre Manlapaz and Natividad Pizarro. The spouses had applied for the judicial confirmation and registration of titles to two parcels of land in Orion, Bataan, invoking open, continuous, exclusive, and notorious possession by themselves and their predecessors-in-interest for at least thirty years. The Director of Lands opposed, insisting that the land belongs to the public domain and cannot be appropriated. The case matters because it teaches two enduring lessons: that the defense of res judicata is waived if not pleaded in the answer, and that the burden of proving the statutory period of possession rests squarely on the applicant, who must offer evidence that is well-nigh incontrovertible.

Procedural History

The spouses filed their application for registration before the then Court of First Instance of Bataan, sitting as a land registration court. The Director of Lands seasonably filed an opposition. After hearing, the trial court rendered judgment adjudicating the two parcels in favor of the spouses and ordering the issuance of a decree of registration once the decision became final.

The Director of Lands appealed to the Court of Appeals. The appellate court affirmed the trial court. It held that the defense of res judicata was raised only for the first time on appeal and was therefore waived, and it found that the thirty-year period of possession by the predecessors-in-interest had been satisfactorily proved, the Director of Lands having presented no evidence to contradict it.

The Director of Lands then came to the Supreme Court by petition for review on certiorari, assigning as errors the appellate court's rulings on waiver of res judicata, on the failure to prove res judicata by competent evidence, and on the availability of judicial confirmation of imperfect title after a cadastral declaration that the land is public land.

Facts

On January 29, 1973, the spouses Manlapaz and Pizarro applied to register two parcels of land situated at Barrio Damulog, Orion, Bataan, containing about 49,954 square meters and 54,052 square meters. Before the initial hearing, the trial court directed the Land Registration Commissioner to report whether the parcels had been patented or were the subject of pending decrees. The Commissioner's representative reported that the parcels are portions of a lot in the Orion Cadastre that had been the subject of cadastral registration proceedings in which a decision had been rendered, though the record was lost or destroyed during the last world war. The report also noted that the plans conflict with a lot covered by a sales patent.

The Director of Lands opposed, alleging that the applicants and their predecessors lacked sufficient title, had not possessed the land openly, continuously, exclusively, and notoriously for at least thirty years, and that the parcels are portions of the public domain. At the hearing, the trial court declared the case in default except as to the Director of Lands, and the parties were allowed to present evidence before the Clerk of Court.

To prove thirty years of possession, the spouses presented Crisanto Angeles, who claimed he took possession in 1931, cleared the land, planted fruit trees and crops, and converted part of it into a ricefield, although he declared the land for taxation only in 1966. He sold about five hectares to Pablito Punay in 1938, and in September 1972 sold the second parcel to the spouses, who also acquired the first parcel from Punay. The spouses' corroborating witness, Monico Balila, admitted he first lived in the locality in 1938 and became an adjoining owner only in 1953. Pablito Punay was never presented to testify. The Director of Lands presented no evidence at all.

Issues

  • Whether or not the Director of Lands waived the defense of res judicata by failing to raise it in the answer before the trial court.
  • Whether or not the Director of Lands proved res judicata by competent evidence.
  • Whether or not the private respondents established by convincing evidence the thirty-year period of open, continuous, exclusive, and notorious possession in the concept of owner required for judicial confirmation of imperfect title.

Applicable Provisions

Section 2 of Rule 9 of the Revised Rules of Court of 1964 governs the waiver of defenses not pleaded, and provides:

SEC. 2. Defenses and objections not pleaded deemed waived. - Defenses and objections not pleaded either in a motion to dismiss or in the answer are deemed waived; x x x

This provision defeats the Director's belated invocation of res judicata, because the defense was never set up in the trial court.

Section 48 of Commonwealth Act No. 141, as amended, is the statutory basis for confirmation of imperfect title, and the Court explains its operation in this wise:

A judicial declaration that a parcel of land is public, does not preclude even the same applicant from subsequently seeking a judicial confirmation of his title to the same land, provided he thereafter complies with the provisions of Section 48 of Commonwealth Act No. 141, as amended, and as long as said public land remains alienable and disposable (now sections 3 and 4, PD No. 1073).

This means a prior cadastral declaration that the land is public does not bar a later application, so long as the applicant proves compliance with the thirty-year requirement.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held that the Court of Appeals committed no error in disregarding res judicata. The Director of Lands never interposed any objection nor set up that defense in the trial court, and such failure is a procedural infirmity that cannot be cured on appeal. The Court quoted with approval its earlier ruling that all defenses not interposed in a motion to dismiss or in an answer are deemed waived, and that the defense of res judicata, when not set up in either, is deemed waived and cannot be pleaded for the first time at the trial or on appeal.

On the second issue, the Court held that even granting that the defense was properly raised, there was factually no prior final judgment to speak of. A decision in a cadastral proceeding declaring a lot public land is not the final decree contemplated in the Land Registration Act, and does not preclude the same applicant from later seeking judicial confirmation of title, provided he complies with Section 48 of Commonwealth Act No. 141 and the land remains alienable and disposable.

On the third issue, the Court ruled that the factual findings of the Court of Appeals fell within the recognized exceptions to the rule of respect for such findings, because the inference was manifestly mistaken and the judgment was based on a misapprehension of facts. The burden is on the applicant to prove his positive averments, not on the government to establish a negative proposition. The Court found the testimony of Crisanto Angeles unconvincing: he claimed possession from 1930 yet declared the land for taxation only in 1966, could not name the adjoining owners on cross-examination, could not explain how he came into possession, and showed no title granted by the State. The corroboration of Monico Balila was less than credible, since he became an adjoining owner only in 1953. Pablito Punay, the second predecessor-in-interest, was never presented. The documents offered merely showed that the land was alienable and disposable public land, not the length of possession, and the spouses' tax payments from 1972 were of no moment because what mattered was their predecessors' compliance with the thirty-year period. The Court stressed that lands of whatever classification are presumed to belong to the State, and evidence of a land grant must be well-nigh incontrovertible.

Doctrine

First, the defense of res judicata is an affirmative defense that must be pleaded in a motion to dismiss or in the answer; if not so pleaded, it is deemed waived and cannot be raised for the first time at the trial or on appeal, under Section 2 of Rule 9.

Second, a cadastral decision declaring a parcel of land public land is not the final decree contemplated in the Land Registration Act, and does not bar a subsequent application for judicial confirmation of imperfect title under Section 48 of Commonwealth Act No. 141, so long as the land remains alienable and disposable and the applicant proves compliance with the thirty-year requirement.

Third, the applicant bears the burden of proving open, continuous, exclusive, and notorious possession in the concept of owner for the required period; tax declarations and tax payments are not incontrovertible proof of ownership, and the evidence of a land grant must be well-nigh incontrovertible, since lands of whatever classification are presumed to belong to the State.

Disposition

The Court reversed and set aside the decision of the Court of Appeals, and rendered judgment dismissing the application for registration and confirmation of titles to the two parcels, with no pronouncement as to costs. The Director of Lands prevailed.

Remember This

Memorize the line that a cadastral declaration that land is public is not the final decree that bars a later application under Section 48, and that the applicant must prove thirty years of possession with evidence that is well-nigh incontrovertible. Examiners use this case on the waiver of res judicata not pleaded in the answer, and on the burden of proof in land registration where the government presents no evidence but the applicant's own proof fails.