🎧 Case Brief Lecture

THE UNITED STATES, COMPLAINANT AND APPELLEE, VS. GERONIMO LEAL ET AL., DEFENDANTS AND APPELLANTS.

G.R. No. 432. February 06, 1902 February 6, 1902

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

United States versus Leal

The Case

This is a criminal prosecution brought by the United States against Geronimo Leal and his co-accused for the killing of Segundo Labitoria in the town of Taguding in June 1900. The trial court convicted all four accused, and the case reached the Supreme Court on appeal. It matters to the reviewee for three reasons: it fixes the liability of a principal by inducement who was not the hand that struck the blow, it distinguishes principals from accessories in the concealment of a corpse, and it applies the mitigating circumstance of intoxication under the old Penal Code while refusing the benefits of the special circumstance of article 11 to the principals.

Procedural History

The accused were tried before the Court of First Instance, which found Pablo Laranang and Geronimo Leal guilty as principals and Baldomero Lacasandeli and Rufino Lastimosa guilty as accessories, and imposed the corresponding penalties. The case was elevated to the Supreme Court on appeal. On appeal, the Solicitor-General also contended that the judgment of the court below should be set aside as a nullity because it was rendered after the sixteenth of June by a judge who had by then ceased to be a judge and was therefore without jurisdiction. The Supreme Court resolved the appeal on the merits and rejected the jurisdictional objection.

Facts

On the morning of June 29, 1900, Segundo Labitoria went to the house of Geronimo Leal to ask who had stolen two jars of basi belonging to him. Pablo Laranang arrived, and the men drank basi together with Baldomero Lacasandeli until they became intoxicated. Labitoria accused Leal of the theft. Upon the prompting of Leal, Laranang assaulted Labitoria with a bolo, inflicting seven wounds which caused his death on the spot. The wounds on the head and side were necessarily mortal, and the rest were serious.

When Lacasandeli tried to leave upon seeing Labitoria dead, Laranang detained him and called to Rufino Lastimosa, who was passing in front of the house, so that they would help bury the corpse. They buried the body in a cane field near the house. Four days later, after investigations at the instance of the deceased's family, the local authorities of Taguding found the corpse.

Laranang pleaded guilty and confessed that he attacked the deceased with a bolo upon the instigation of Leal, the owner of the house, and that he was so intoxicated that he could not account for what he did after Leal told him to kill Labitoria. Leal first pleaded guilty but later withdrew the plea and denied the crime, claiming he merely assisted in the burial. The Court found his guilt established beyond doubt by Laranang's testimony, by Leal's disappearance from his house after the occurrence, and by the altercation over the stolen basi, which gave Leal alone a motive of resentment or revenge.

Issues

  • Whether or not Geronimo Leal is guilty as a principal by inducement although he did not himself inflict the fatal wounds.
  • Whether or not Baldomero Lacasandeli and Rufino Lastimosa are guilty as accessories for burying the corpse and failing to report the crime to the authorities.
  • Whether or not the intoxication of the principals may be taken in mitigation of the penalty.
  • Whether or not the principals are entitled to the benefits of the special circumstance under article 11 of the Penal Code.
  • Whether or not the judgment of the court below is a nullity because it was rendered by a judge who had ceased to be a judge.

Applicable Provisions

Article 404 of the old Penal Code, which defines and penalizes homicide, provides:

The facts related and fully proved at the trial by ocular inspection, expert evidence, the testimony of witnesses, and the confession of the accused constitute the crime of homicide defined and penalized in article 404 of the Penal Code.

This is the offense for which the principals were convicted.

Article 9, paragraph 6 of the Penal Code, on the mitigating circumstance of intoxication, provides:

The provisions of article 9, paragraph 6 of the Penal Code must be applied in mitigation of the penalty, as the crime was committed while the principals were in an intoxicated condition, and it does not appear that they were habitual drunkards.

This circumstance lowered the penalty of the principals to the minimum grade.

Article 11 of the Penal Code, on the special circumstance allowed to certain offenders, provides:

We do not think it proper to allow the principals, Leal and Laranang, the benefits of the special circumstance established in article 11 of the Penal Code, because of the conditions of these defendants, and of the fact that the crime committed by them has of late become very frequent.

The Court denied this benefit to the principals but extended it to the accessories to reduce their penalty.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held that Leal is guilty as a principal by inducement. Although Laranang was the actual author of the crime, the evidence showed that Leal induced him to kill Labitoria, that Leal witnessed the killing in his own house, that Leal alone had a motive for revenge arising from the quarrel over the stolen basi, and that Laranang had no motive of his own. The Court reasoned that if Leal had borne no ill feeling toward the deceased, he would not have been an indifferent spectator to a crime committed in his own house, which it was his duty to prevent.

On the second issue, the Court held that Lacasandeli and Lastimosa are guilty as accessories. Although neither took part in the killing itself, they aided the principals in concealing the body by unlawfully burying it in a field and by failing to inform the authorities of the facts known to them.

On the third issue, the Court applied the mitigating circumstance of intoxication under article 9, paragraph 6, since the crime was committed while the principals were intoxicated and they were not shown to be habitual drunkards.

On the fourth issue, the Court refused to extend the benefits of article 11 to the principals, considering their conditions and the frequency of the crime. It did, however, extend that benefit to the accessories, there being no aggravating circumstance against them and it being presumed that they did not fully realize their duty to report the facts to the authorities.

On the fifth issue, the Court, upon the authority of the earlier case of United States versus Abalos, held that the objection to the judgment as a nullity could not be sustained.

Doctrine

One who induces another to commit a crime is a principal by inducement even if he does not strike the fatal blow, where the evidence shows inducement, presence at the commission, and a motive on his part that the actual slayer did not share. Those who, without taking part in the killing, bury the body to conceal the crime and fail to report it to the authorities are accessories. Intoxication, where the offender is not a habitual drunkard, is a mitigating circumstance under article 9, paragraph 6 of the Penal Code. The special circumstance under article 11 may be allowed or withheld in the Court's discretion, and it was here denied to the principals but granted to the accessories.

Disposition

The Court affirmed the convictions: Laranang and Leal were each sentenced to thirteen years of reclusion temporal with the accessory penalties and to pay one thousand Mexican pesos to the widow and heirs of the deceased, while Lacasandeli and Lastimosa were each sentenced to six months and one day of prision correctional with the accessory penalties and subsidiary liability, and the jurisdictional objection of the Solicitor-General was overruled.

Remember This

The line worth memorizing is that the inducer who watches the killing in his own house, moved by a motive the slayer did not share, is a principal by inducement, not a mere bystander. Examiners use this case to test the distinction between principals by inducement and accessories, and the application of the mitigating circumstance of intoxication under the old Penal Code.