JOSE ZULUETA, PLAINTIFF AND APPELLEE, VS. FRANCISCA ZULUETA, DEFENDANT AND APPELLANT.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Zulueta versus Zulueta
The Case
This is the case of Zulueta versus Zulueta, decided in April 1902. Don Jose Zulueta and his sister, Doña Francisca Zulueta, are the sole heirs of their father, Don Clemente Zulueta, who died in Iloilo in 1900. The action concerns the settlement of the father's estate: the division of the property among the two heirs, the reports of the auditors appointed to make that division, and the consequences of the sister's failure to file her opposition within the period fixed by the law. The case matters for two reasons. First, it fixes the rule that the remedy against judgments obtained by fraud, accident, or mistake does not reach an error of law committed by the judge, which must be corrected by appeal. Second, it holds that ignorance of the law does not excuse compliance with it, even in a proceeding designed to prevent injustice.
Procedural History
Don Jose instituted voluntary testamentary proceedings in the Court of First Instance of Iloilo. Three auditors were appointed to divide the estate: one nominated by Don Jose, one nominated by Doña Francisca, and a third, the auditor umpire, chosen by common accord. The two party-nominated auditors failed to agree and each rendered a separate report. The auditor umpire accepted in its entirety the report of the auditor nominated by Don Jose. The record was delivered to Doña Francisca for examination, and she filed her opposition to the report of the auditor umpire. A meeting of the interested parties was held, and no agreement was reached. The court then directed that the procedure prescribed for declarative actions be followed, and that the record be delivered again to Doña Francisca so that she might formulate her demand. On petition of Don Jose, the court fixed a term of fifteen days for that purpose, later enlarged by seven days on her own petition.
Before the term expired, Doña Francisca asked that the proceedings be suspended until the new Code of Procedure enacted by the Civil Commission should become operative. The court denied the petition and declared that, the term having expired, she had lost her right to institute the action. She sought reform of that order, and the petition was denied by a justice of the peace who had been designated to preside over the Court of First Instance during the illness of the regular judge. The denial rested on the ground that the remedy was appeal, not reform. She then interposed an appeal, which the court, now presided over by the regular judge, declined to admit because it was not presented within three days. Upon petition of Don Jose, the partition proceedings were approved. From that approval Doña Francisca took the present appeal. While the appeal was pending, she also presented a petition under Act Number 75 of the Civil Commission, asking that the orders be set aside on the ground of mistake. The Court heard both the petition and the appeal, and resolved them together.
Facts
Don Clemente Zulueta died in Iloilo in 1900, leaving his two children, Don Jose and Doña Francisca, as sole heirs under his will. In the voluntary testamentary proceedings instituted by Don Jose, three auditors were appointed to divide the estate. Each party nominated one auditor, and the third, the auditor umpire, was chosen by common accord. The two party-nominated auditors failed to agree and each rendered a separate report. The auditor umpire agreed with and accepted in its entirety the report of the auditor nominated by Don Jose.
The record was delivered to Doña Francisca for examination, and she filed her opposition to the report of the auditor umpire. A meeting of the interested parties was held, but no agreement was reached. The court then directed that the procedure for declarative actions be followed and gave Doña Francisca the record so that she could formulate her demand. On petition of Don Jose, the court fixed fifteen days for that purpose, later enlarged by seven days on her own petition.
Instead of filing her demand, Doña Francisca asked that the proceedings be suspended until the new Code of Procedure should take effect. The court denied the petition and declared that she had lost her right to institute the action because the term had expired. Her petition for reform was denied, and her appeal from that denial was refused as filed out of time. The court then approved the partition proceedings, and she appealed. Pending the appeal, she filed a petition under Act Number 75, attributing the adverse orders to mistakes of law by the acting judge and by herself.
Issues
- Whether or not the petition under Act Number 75 may set aside the order denying reform and the order approving the partition, on the ground that these were rendered through a mistake of law by the judge.
- Whether or not Doña Francisca may be relieved, under Act Number 75, from the consequences of her own mistake of law in failing to interpose her appeal within the period fixed by law.
- Whether or not the court had the right to fix a definite term within which the declarative action had to be instituted, and whether or not Doña Francisca lost her right to institute that action upon the expiration of the term.
- Whether or not the approval of the partition proceedings was proper, there being no defect shown in them.
Applicable Provisions
Article 2 of the Civil Code provides:
Ignorance of the law does not excuse from compliance therewith.
This is the general principle the Court refuses to relax in favor of a party who misconceived the period for appeal.
Article 1071 of the Ley de Enjuiciamiento Civil provides:
If no agreement is had, the procedure prescribed for declarative actions, according to the amount involved, shall be followed, and the delivery of the papers shall be first made to the parties who first requested delivery to them of the partition report as provided in article 1067.
This provision shows that the law does not leave it to either party to commence the declarative action at pleasure, but designates the party who takes the initiative and fixes the time by reference to article 1067.
Article 1067 of the Ley de Enjuiciamiento Civil provides:
If the interested parties, or any of them, request, within eight days, that the record of the proceedings and the report on partition be delivered to them for examination, the judge shall order said delivery for a period of fifteen days to each person making such request.
This is the period, with its extension, that the Court holds the party had the benefit of, and more.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the petition must fail. Act Number 75 provides a remedy against judgments obtained in Courts of First Instance by fraud, accident, or mistake, but the mistake contemplated cannot be a mistake into which the court may have fallen in its findings of fact or conclusions of law. Otherwise every aggrieved party could bring the judgment below to the Supreme Court by this summary route, and the ordinary remedy of appeal would be superseded. The Court quoted its own recent ruling:
The meaning of the word mistake as used in the statute does not extend, nor was it intended that it should, to an error of law which may have been committed by the judge in the trial in question. Such errors may be corrected by appeal. The statute under consideration can by no means be employed as a substitute for that remedy.
Since the order denying reform and the order approving the partition both rested on alleged mistakes of law by the judge, neither could be set aside on the petition.
On the second issue, the Court held that the petitioner's own mistake of law did not entitle her to relief. Nothing was shown except the bare fact that she acted under ignorance or misconception of the law on the time within which the appeal could be taken. The general principle that ignorance of the law does not excuse compliance with it, a principle founded not only on expediency and policy but on necessity, should not be relaxed. The Court added that the framers of Act Number 75 could not have intended to abrogate that principle entirely, for then the courts would be involved in questions incapable of any just solution.
On the third issue, the Court held that the court below clearly had the right to fix a definite term within which the declarative action had to be instituted, and that its order was in exact conformity with the procedure prescribed by article 1071. The law does not treat the partition proceedings as terminated by the failure of the parties to agree; it provides that the case shall be given the procedure of the declarative action and designates the party who is to take the initiative, a provision utterly irreconcilable with the idea that it is optional for either party to commence the proceeding at his pleasure. The petitioner had the benefit of the period and an extension of seven days, and so had all the rights to which she was strictly entitled, and something more.
On the fourth issue, the Court held that since Doña Francisca had lost her right to institute the declarative action, the court had no other course than to approve the partition proceedings, no defect having been pointed out. The suggestion that the report of the auditor umpire was of prior date to that of the auditor nominated by Don Jose was not supported by the record: the latter was dated March 24 and filed March 29, while the former was dated March 28 and filed March 29.
Doctrine
First, the remedy against judgments obtained by fraud, accident, or mistake does not extend to an error of law committed by the judge in the findings of fact or conclusions of law on which the judgment is based. Such errors are corrected by appeal, and the remedy cannot be used as a substitute for appeal.
Second, ignorance of the law does not excuse compliance with it, as Article 2 of the Civil Code declares. A party who misconceives the period for appeal cannot later claim relief from the consequences of that misconception.
Third, under article 1071 of the Ley de Enjuiciamiento Civil, upon failure of the parties to agree on the partition report, the case is given the procedure of the declarative action, and the time within which that action must be instituted is fixed by reference to article 1067. It is not optional for either party to commence the proceeding at pleasure.
Disposition
The petition was denied and the judgment appealed from was affirmed, with costs against the appealing party both as to the petition and the appeal.
Remember This
The line worth memorizing is that a mistake of law by the judge is corrected by appeal, never by a petition for relief, and ignorance of the law does not excuse compliance with it. Examiners use this case to test the scope of the remedy against judgments obtained by fraud, accident, or mistake, and the rule that the period for appeal is jurisdictional and cannot be excused by the appellant's own misreading of the law.