JOSE FERNANDEZ, PLAINTIFF AND APPELLANT, VS. FRANCISCO DE LA ROSA, DEFENDANT AND APPELLEE.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Fernandez versus De la Rosa
The Case
This is an action by Jose Fernandez against Francisco de la Rosa, asking the court to declare that a partnership exists between them, that the plaintiff has a consequent interest in two cascoes, which are the flat-bottomed cargo boats used on the Pasig and in Manila Bay, alleged to be partnership property, and that the defendant be ordered to render an account of his administration of those boats and of the business carried on with them. The defendant denies that any partnership was ever formed. The case matters because it is the classic statement of what makes a partnership: mutual contribution to a common fund and a joint interest in the profits, from which the law itself supplies the incidents the parties failed to stipulate.
Procedural History
The case was tried in the Court of First Instance, which rendered judgment for the defendant, and the plaintiff appealed. The case reached the Supreme Court under the old procedure, so the Court reviewed the evidence and passed upon the facts itself. The Court reversed the judgment below and declared that a partnership existed. The defendant then moved for a rehearing, which the Court denied in a resolution explaining that the partnership was inferred from proven facts, not from mere possibility, and that the effect of the plaintiff's withdrawal of money could only be settled in a liquidation.
Facts
In January 1900 the plaintiff and the defendant discussed forming a partnership for the purchase of cascoes and the business of letting them for hire in Manila. The plaintiff furnished 300 pesos, which the defendant received, toward the purchase of casco number 1515, bought from Dona Isabel Vales, with the title taken in the defendant's own name. The plaintiff also furnished sums for repairs on that boat. On the fifth of March the plaintiff gave the defendant 825 pesos, and the defendant signed a receipt stating that he had received the money for the cost of a casco which the parties were to purchase in company. That boat was casco number 2089, bought on the twenty-second of March from Luis R. Yangco, again with the title in the defendant's name. The balance of the price of each boat was furnished by the defendant.
In April the parties tried to draw up articles of partnership, but they could not agree, the defendant being unwilling to include casco number 2089 in the partnership, and no written agreement was executed. The defendant had control and management of both boats. When the plaintiff demanded an accounting, the defendant refused and denied the partnership altogether. Later the defendant returned to the plaintiff 1,125 pesos in two sums, 300 pesos and 825 pesos, and the plaintiff accepted them while expressly reserving all his rights as a partner.
The Court found that the sale of casco number 1515 was made and the boat delivered in January, although the public document of sale was executed only on the tenth of March, and that the 825 pesos were furnished toward casco number 2089 on joint account. It discarded the testimony of Marcos Angulo, a partner of the plaintiff in a bakery, and found that the 300 pesos received in January were contributed by the plaintiff toward joint ownership of casco number 1515, not borrowed by the defendant. It found no specific verbal agreement of partnership except such as may be implied from the facts of the purchase.
Issues
- Whether or not a partnership existed between the plaintiff and the defendant.
- Whether or not the partnership, if it existed, was terminated by the defendant's return and the plaintiff's acceptance of the 1,125 pesos.
Applicable Provisions
Article 1665 of the Civil Code defines the contract of partnership:
Partnership is a contract by which two or more persons bind themselves to contribute money, property, or industry to a common fund, with the intention of dividing the profits among themselves.
This definition supplies the two essential elements on which the whole case turns.
Article 1667 of the Civil Code governs form:
A partnership may be constituted in any form, unless real property or real rights are contributed to it, in which case a public instrument is necessary.
Because only money and movable boats were contributed, no writing was needed to give the verbal contract efficacy.
Article 1689 of the Civil Code supplies the gap the parties left:
Should there be no stipulation as to the share of each partner in the profits and losses, it shall be distributed in proportion to the capital contributed by each.
The law itself fixes the shares the parties failed to agree upon.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that a partnership existed. The essential points on which the minds of the parties must meet are mutual contribution to a common stock and a joint interest in the profits. The Court found that money was furnished by the plaintiff and received by the defendant with the understanding that it was to be used to purchase the boats in question, which establishes the first element. The intention to share profits is an unavoidable deduction from the purchase of the boats in common, absent any other explanation, especially since the formation of a partnership had been under negotiation before the first purchase. The Court distinguished joint ownership: had the object been merely to make a better bargain and later divide the property, the affectio societatis, the intention to associate, would be lacking and the parties would be joint tenants only; but here the object was active use and profit. A complete and perfect contract of partnership was therefore entered into. A written agreement was not necessary, the contributions not being immovables or rights in immovables.
On the second issue, the Court held that the partnership was not terminated. The amount returned fell short of the plaintiff's contribution, since it did not include what he had furnished for repairs, and profits may have been realized while the defendant administered the business. The acceptance of the money did not convert the partnership into a societas leonina, a partnership in which one partner takes all the profits. The plaintiff expressly reserved his rights, and his acceptance was not inconsistent with the continuance of the relation; it was merely the withdrawal by one partner, with the consent of the other, of a portion of the common capital. The defendant could have terminated the relation by recognizing the plaintiff's rights, but having failed to do so he cannot force a dissolution on terms the plaintiff is unwilling to accept.
Doctrine
A partnership is formed when two or more persons bind themselves to contribute money, property, or industry to a common fund with the intention of dividing the profits among themselves. The essential elements are mutual contribution to a common stock and a joint interest in the profits; if these are present, the partnership relation results and the law supplies its incidents, including the rule that profits and losses are shared in proportion to capital contributed where the parties stipulated nothing. A partnership may be constituted in any form unless real property or real rights are contributed, in which case a public instrument is necessary. Failure to agree on minor details, such as the share of each partner, does not destroy a partnership already perfected, because those details pertain to the accidental and not the essential part of the contract. A partner's withdrawal of part of the common capital, with the consent of the other and with express reservation of his rights, does not dissolve the partnership; its effect on the partners' accounts is determined only upon liquidation.
Disposition
The Supreme Court reversed the judgment of the court below without costs, declared that a partnership was formed between the parties in January 1900, and returned the record for the execution of the judgment now rendered; the motion for rehearing was denied.
Remember This
Memorize the line that a partnership exists once there is mutual contribution to a common fund and a joint interest in the profits, and the law itself supplies the incidents the parties failed to stipulate. Examiners use this case to test the essential elements of partnership, the distinction between partnership and joint ownership through affectio societatis, and the rule that a partnership may be constituted in any form when no immovables are contributed.