🎧 Case Brief Lecture

DONALDSON, SIM & CO., PLAINTIFFS AND APPELLANTS, VS. SMITH, BELL & CO., DEFENDANTS AND APPELLEES.

G.R. No. 411. April 23, 1902 April 23, 1902

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

Donaldson, Sim and Company versus Smith, Bell and Company

The Case

This is an action for damages brought by Donaldson, Sim and Company against Smith, Bell and Company. The plaintiffs say the defendants wrongfully occupied certain warehouses in Manila during the first half of May 1900, to the plaintiffs' loss. The case matters because it fixes a boundary every law student must know: a lessee who has not yet entered into possession holds no right in the leased property that a third person is bound to respect, and so cannot sue a stranger in tort. The plaintiffs' remedy, if any, lies against their own lessor.

Procedural History

The action was tried in the court below, and judgment was rendered in favor of the defendants, Smith, Bell and Company. The plaintiffs, Donaldson, Sim and Company, appealed. The case reached the Supreme Court of the Philippine Islands on that appeal, and the Court, speaking through Justice Ladd, affirmed the judgment of the lower court.

Facts

The warehouses belonged to Luis R. Yangco. In July 1899 he leased them to the military government of the United States, and that government sublet them to the defendants, Smith, Bell and Company, under an arrangement whose details the Court found it unnecessary to state. Yangco objected to the defendants' occupancy. On the eleventh of April 1900 the Chief Quartermaster of the Army, apparently under a misapprehension of the facts respecting the defendants' arrangement with the Government, wrote to the defendants saying that the records of his office failed to show any right in them to occupy the buildings, and requesting that the buildings be vacated at once.

On the thirtieth of April 1900 the lease from Yangco to the Government was terminated by mutual consent. On the first of May 1900 Yangco leased the buildings to the plaintiffs, Donaldson, Sim and Company, for one year. On that same day the plaintiffs notified the defendants of the lease and asked them to vacate within twenty-four hours. The defendants declined, and continued in occupancy of the warehouses, or some of them, to the exclusion of the plaintiffs, until after the fourteenth of May 1900.

The plaintiffs never entered into possession under their lease. The wrongs complained of were committed between the second and the fourteenth of May 1900, before the plaintiffs' use of the property had begun.

Issues

  • Whether or not the defendants owed the plaintiffs any duty respecting the occupancy of the warehouses, such that a failure to perform it would give the plaintiffs a right of action.
  • Whether or not the plaintiffs, as lessees who had not yet entered into possession, acquired rights in the leased property in the nature of rights in rem which third persons were bound not to infringe.
  • Whether or not the plaintiffs may recover damages from the defendants under the general principle of liability for damage caused by fault or negligence.

Applicable Provisions

Article 1560 of the Civil Code, which gives the lessee a direct action against a trespasser, provides:

The lessee may bring the actions which may correspond to the lessor for the preservation of the thing leased.

The Court confined this article to the case of an actual interference with the lessee's use of the property, and here that use had not begun.

Article 1902 of the Civil Code, relied upon by the plaintiffs, provides:

A person who by an act or omission causes damage to another when there is fault or negligence shall be obliged to repair the damage so done.

The Court held that this general principle cannot apply where no obligation rested on the person causing the damage to exercise diligence toward the injured person.

Articles 1554 and 1556 of the Civil Code, which the Court pointed to as the plaintiffs' remedy against their lessor, provide:

The lessor is obliged to deliver to the lessee the thing which is the object of the contract.

The lessor is not obliged to answer for a violation of the contract of lease if the thing leased is destroyed or rendered unfit for the use for which it was intended by reason of a fortuitous event, unless he has expressly stipulated the contrary.

The Court named these articles as the source of whatever remedy the plaintiffs may have, and that remedy runs against the lessor, not against the defendants.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held that the only question is whether the defendants failed to perform any duty which they owed to the plaintiffs. The Court found no legal relation between the parties giving rise to rights in the plaintiffs and corresponding duties on the part of the defendants as respects the occupancy of the buildings, and held that this failure to establish such a relation is fatal to the plaintiffs' recovery.

On the second issue, the Court held that whatever rights the plaintiffs had during the period in question originated in and depended upon their contract with Yangco for the lease. Not having entered into possession under their lease, they had acquired no rights in the leased property in the nature of rights in rem, and which third persons were therefore bound not to infringe. On Article 1560, the Court said:

Article 1560 of the Civil Code, which gives the lessee a direct action against a trespasser, is confined to the case of an actual interference with the lessee's use of the property.

Here such use by the plaintiffs had not begun when the alleged wrongs were committed.

On the third issue, the Court held that Article 1902 establishes the general principle of liability for damage caused by fault or negligence, but that there can be no fault or negligence where there was no obligation resting upon the person causing the damage to exercise diligence as respects the injured person. The Court added that the plaintiffs' remedy, if they have any, is against the lessor under Articles 1554 and 1556 of the Civil Code.

Doctrine

A lessee who has not yet entered into possession under the lease acquires no rights in the leased property in the nature of rights in rem. Third persons are therefore not bound to respect any such right, and the lessee cannot hold a stranger liable for occupying the property.

The lessee's direct action against a trespasser under Article 1560 of the Civil Code is confined to an actual interference with the lessee's use of the property. Before possession and use begin, that action does not lie.

Liability under Article 1902 of the Civil Code requires a pre-existing obligation on the part of the person causing the damage to exercise diligence toward the injured person. There can be no fault or negligence where no such obligation exists.

The lessee's remedy for the lessor's failure to deliver the thing leased lies against the lessor under Articles 1554 and 1556 of the Civil Code, not against a third person in occupancy.

Disposition

The Supreme Court affirmed the judgment of the lower court in favor of the defendants, Smith, Bell and Company, with costs against the plaintiffs.

Remember This

Memorize this line: a lessee who has not entered into possession has no right in rem, so a trespasser owes the lessee no duty and Article 1902 cannot reach him. Examiners use this case to test the requisites of a quasi-delict, the absence of a duty owed to the plaintiff, and the rule that the lessee's remedy before possession lies against the lessor under Articles 1554 and 1556 of the Civil Code.