THE UNITED STATES, COMPLAINANT AND APPELLEE, VS. AGAPITO FORTIN,, DEFENDANT AND APPELLANT.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
United States versus Fortin
The Case
This is a criminal case from the early years of the American occupation, brought by the United States as complainant against Agapito Fortin as defendant and appellant. Fortin was prosecuted for an alleged attack upon an agent of the authorities, arising from a scuffle with the teniente of the barrio of Talaonga during a night meeting held to elect subordinate officers. The case matters because the Supreme Court acquitted him on the ground of self-defense, holding that a public officer who is himself the unlawful aggressor, and who is too drunk to represent the authorities with decorum, is divested of his official character and cannot claim the protection of the law. It is a compact lesson on the elements of an attack upon an agent of the authorities, and on how self-defense operates when the supposed offended party is the author of the provocation.
Procedural History
The accused was tried in the court below, which found him liable and rendered judgment against him. He appealed to the Supreme Court of the Philippine Islands. The Supreme Court, speaking through Justice Torres, reversed the judgment of the trial court and acquitted the accused, with the concurring votes of Chief Justice Arellano and Justices Cooper, Willard, and Ladd. Justice Mapa was absent on account of illness.
Facts
On the night of the fifteenth of February, 1897, several inhabitants of the barrio of Talaonga, in the town of Bulusan, gathered in the town hall to elect subordinate officers. The presiding officer of the meeting was Lucio Fusio, who was the teniente of the barrio, and who was at that time drunk. During the meeting Fusio got into an altercation with Agapito Fortin.
The trouble was brought on by Fusio. He approached Fortin and bit him in the left shoulder. Against this aggression Fortin defended himself, throwing the teniente to the ground. As a result of the struggle, Fusio suffered some slight bruises.
The record showed that both the provocation and the aggression came from the teniente of the barrio, who was so drunk that he could not represent the authorities with decorum. Fortin acted only in his personal defense against an unlawful attack made without provocation on his part, and by means that were entirely reasonable.
Issues
- Whether or not the accused committed the crime of an attack upon an agent of the authorities when he threw to the ground the teniente of the barrio who had bitten him.
- Whether or not the accused acted in self-defense, and is therefore exempt from criminal responsibility.
- Whether or not the drunken teniente retained his character as an agent of the authorities at the time of the incident.
Applicable Provisions
The decision refers to the provisions of the Penal Code on attacks upon agents of the authorities, which it declines to apply because the crime was not proven:
This act would constitute the crime of an attack upon an agent of the authorities and not upon the authorities themselves, inasmuch as Fusio was not an authority, but was only a cabesa de barangay and the teniente of the barrio; but in view of the fact that the commission of this crime has not been proven, the provisions of article 249 and the last paragraph of article 250 of the Penal Code can not be applied.
These provisions bear on the case because the Court first characterizes the act as an attack upon an agent rather than upon the authorities themselves, and then finds that the elements of the crime were not established, so the penal provisions cannot be applied.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the act, if it were a crime at all, would constitute an attack upon an agent of the authorities and not upon the authorities themselves, since Fusio was not an authority but only a cabesa de barangay and the teniente of the barrio. But the commission of this crime was not proven, so the provisions of article 249 and the last paragraph of article 250 of the Penal Code could not be applied.
On the second issue, the Court held that the provocation and the aggression were both on the part of the teniente of the barrio, who while drunk bit the accused in the shoulder. The accused, in repelling this aggression, threw the complaining witness to the ground. In so doing he acted in his personal defense against an unlawful attack made without provocation on his part and by means that were entirely reasonable. He therefore committed no offense and is exempt from all responsibility.
On the third issue, the Court held that the teniente, by reason of his drunkenness and because he was the aggressor, was divested of his character as agent of the authorities. The Court put the principle plainly:
The law can not grant protection to one who has himself been the first to violate it.
The Court added that the accused simply defended himself against a ridiculous and improper aggression made by a drunken man.
Doctrine
First, an attack upon an agent of the authorities is distinct from an attack upon the authorities themselves. Where the person attacked is not an authority but only a cabesa de barangay and teniente of the barrio, the act can at most be an attack upon an agent of the authorities, and the penal provisions on the crime must be applied strictly, only when its commission is proven.
Second, self-defense exempts the accused from criminal responsibility where the provocation and the aggression both came from the offended party, the attack was unlawful and without provocation on the part of the accused, and the means used to repel it were entirely reasonable.
Third, a public officer who is himself the unlawful aggressor, and who by reason of drunkenness cannot represent the authorities with decorum, is divested of his character as agent of the authorities. The law cannot grant protection to one who has himself been the first to violate it.
Disposition
The Supreme Court reversed the judgment below and acquitted Agapito Fortin, the facts not constituting an offense, with costs of both instances adjudged de oficio, and directed the judge below to act in accordance with law with respect to the attachment of the accused's property.
Remember This
Memorize the line that the law cannot grant protection to one who has himself been the first to violate it. Examiners use this case to test the distinction between an attack upon an agent of the authorities and an attack upon the authorities themselves, and to test self-defense where the supposed offended party is a drunken officer who provoked the struggle.