🎧 Case Brief Lecture

THE UNITED STATES, COMPLAINANT AND APPELLEE, VS. JACINTO ASIAO ET AL., DEFENDANTS AND APPELLANTS.

G.R. No. 310. July 30, 1902 July 30, 1902

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

United States versus Asiao

The Case

This is a criminal case from the early years of the American regime in the Philippines. The United States, as complainant and appellee, prosecuted Jacinto Asiao and Atanasio Copendit for robbery — the taking, late one night in December 1897, of a wooden trunk containing clothing, jewelry, and silver coin from the house of Dolores del Rosario in Milaor, Camarines Sur. The case matters to a reviewee for two reasons. First, it is a clean illustration of the constitutional presumption of innocence and of the rule that a conviction must rest on satisfactory testimony, not on suspicion. Second, it shows the Supreme Court applying the old Penal Code and the early procedural law of General Orders, Number 58, and reversing a judgment of conviction because the evidence fell short.

Procedural History

The two accused were tried before the Court of First Instance of the province, which found them guilty of the crime charged and rendered judgment against them. From that judgment the defendants appealed to the Supreme Court. The appeal brought the whole record before the Court, which reviewed the evidence and the law and, as we shall see, reversed the judgment of the court below.

Facts

Late on the night of the twenty-eighth of December 1897, or early in the morning of the twenty-ninth, a wooden trunk was taken from the house of Dolores del Rosario in the town of Milaor, Province of Camarines Sur. The trunk contained clothing and jewelry worth nine pesos and seven reales, fifty-six pesos and fifty cents in silver, and five reales in fractional coin. The thief or thieves entered by the street door, which they opened by thrusting a hand through the nipa wall and drawing the wooden bolt.

By chance, Dolores woke up. Missing the trunk from her room, she opened the window toward the street and saw two men running away with it. She recognized one of them as Jacinto Asiao, and because he lived with Atanasio Copendit, she concluded that the two were the thieves. The trunk was later found some distance away, its top broken in and the money missing, though the clothing and jewelry were recovered. The damage to the trunk was estimated at fifty cents.

At trial, the prosecution relied on the testimony of the complaining witness and of her servant. The servant identified Atanasio Copendit in the ring of prisoners as the other thief, but elsewhere testified that, owing to the darkness of the night, he could not recognize the man whom he challenged when running after the two thieves.

Issues

  • Whether or not the guilt of Jacinto Asiao and Atanasio Copendit was proven beyond reasonable doubt by satisfactory testimony.
  • Whether or not the unsupported identification by the complaining witness, and the contradictory testimony of her servant, sufficed to establish the responsibility of the accused.
  • Whether or not the judgment of conviction should be reversed and the accused acquitted.

Applicable Provisions

Article 502 of the Penal Code, as discussed in the decision, defines the crime of robbery in an inhabited house:

The crime of robbery without arms, in an inhabited house, of goods and money of which the total value does not exceed 1,250 pesetas, and the breaking of a locked trunk, outside of the place from whence it was taken, is a crime defined and punished by article 502 and the last paragraph of article 508 of the Penal Code.

This provision fixes the nature and penalty of the offense charged, and it is the law the Court applies in characterizing the facts.

Section 57 of General Orders, Number 58, as invoked in the decision, governs the effect of a reasonable doubt:

They must be presumed to be innocent until their guilt is proven by satisfactory testimony, and even in case there is a reasonable doubt as to their innocence they are entitled to an acquittal.

This provision is the basis for reversing the conviction, because the evidence left the guilt of the accused in doubt.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held that the record did not sufficiently demonstrate the guilt of the two accused. The unsupported allegation of the complaining witness that she recognized Jacinto Asiao on the night of the robbery was not sufficient to satisfactorily establish his responsibility. Neither was the testimony of her servant, who identified Atanasio Copendit in the ring of prisoners but elsewhere admitted that, owing to the darkness, he could not recognize the man he challenged.

On the second issue, the Court held that the contradictory statements of the witness, and the absence of any other evidence for the prosecution, entitled the defendants to an acquittal. The Court stated the governing rule in these words:

They must be presumed to be innocent until their guilt is proven by satisfactory testimony, and even in case there is a reasonable doubt as to their innocence they are entitled to an acquittal.

On the third issue, the Court held that, in accordance with section 57 of General Orders, Number 58, the judgment of the court below must be reversed and the defendants acquitted, with the costs of both instances declared de oficio, that is, at public expense. The order declaratory of insolvency was approved, and the judge was directed to act in accordance with law with respect to the property of Copendit, which had been attached.

Doctrine

Every accused is presumed innocent until guilt is proven by satisfactory testimony, and even where there is a reasonable doubt as to guilt, the accused is entitled to an acquittal. A conviction cannot rest on the unsupported identification of a single witness, nor on testimony that is contradicted by the same witness's own statements. Where the prosecution's evidence is insufficient and contradictory, the judgment of conviction must be reversed and the accused acquitted, with costs de oficio.

Disposition

The Supreme Court reversed the judgment of the court below and acquitted Jacinto Asiao and Atanasio Copendit, with costs of both instances de oficio, and directed the trial judge to act in accordance with law regarding the attached property of Copendit.

Remember This

The single line worth memorizing is that the accused must be presumed innocent until guilt is proven by satisfactory testimony, and even a reasonable doubt entitles him to an acquittal. Examiners use this case to test the sufficiency of identification evidence and the application of the presumption of innocence in criminal appeals.