🎧 Case Brief Lecture

THE UNITED STATES, COMPLAINANT AND APPELLEE, VS. LUCIO BARBASA ET AL., DEFENDANTS AND APPELLANTS.

G.R. No. 241. August 06, 1902 August 6, 1902

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

United States versus Barbasa

The Case

This is a criminal appeal from a conviction for falsification of public documents, decided in the earliest years of the American regime in the Philippines. The Government of the United States, as complainant and appellee, prosecuted Lucio Barbasa, the former gobernadorcillo of Ermita, and Teodoro Luna, an attesting witness, together with several others, for the alteration of a baptismal certificate and the issuance of false certificates and a false personal cedula. The case matters because it fixes the dividing line of criminal responsibility between a public officer who signs a false document in the exercise of his official duties and a mere private individual who attests to it, and because it shows how the old Penal Code provisions on falsification were applied and graded.

Procedural History

The case was tried in the Court of Intramuros in Manila, which rendered judgment on the twenty-fourth of December, 1897. That court convicted Lucio Barbasa and Teodoro Luna of falsification of cedula and of two offenses of falsification of certificates, imposing on each of them arresto mayor and fines, with accessories. It acquitted Tomas Acosta and Ignacio Jacobo of falsification of cedula and of certificates, and it acquitted all four accused of the falsification of a certificate of baptism for lack of evidence of their participation. Barbasa and Luna appealed from that judgment to the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court reviewed the record and rendered its decision, modifying the penalties and acquitting the appellants of the falsification of cedula.

Facts

Julio Lagrimas del Rosario arranged with one Catalino Gaza that Gaza would act as his substitute in the military service under the Spanish Government. Gaza received a sum of money from Lagrimas through Tomas Acosta, a sergeant of the engineer corps which the substitute was to join. Acosta undertook to prepare the necessary documents: the certificate of baptism of Lagrimas, his personal cedula, and two certificates to be issued by Lucio Barbasa as gobernadorcillo of Ermita, with two attesting witnesses, Miguel Abalos and Teodoro Luna.

The investigation showed that the certificate of baptism had been altered by erasing the year of birth and writing over the erasure the year 1864 in place of 1874, the year originally entered. The personal cedula of Lagrimas, issued on the fourth of July, 1894, by Barbasa and the cabeza de barangay Miguel Abalos, stated that Lagrimas was thirty years of age and a resident of Ermita, when in truth he was only twenty years of age and a resident of Santa Cruz.

In a certificate dated the tenth of July, 1894, issued by Barbasa with Abalos and Luna as attesting witnesses, it was stated that Lagrimas, whose name was registered in the district under the charge of Abalos, was free from forced military service for that year, when in fact he was included in the list of conscripts of the district of Santa Cruz. In another certificate of the same date, issued by the same gobernadorcillo and witnesses, it was recited that Eleuterio Lagrimas, the father of Julio, had given his consent to the latter's enlistment, the certificate purporting to bear the signature of Eleuterio, who in fact was unable to write and who denied having given such consent.

Issues

  • Whether or not the crime of falsification of a public document was committed by the alteration of the certificate of baptism.
  • Whether or not Lucio Barbasa participated in the falsification of the personal cedula of Julio Lagrimas.
  • Whether or not Barbasa and Teodoro Luna are criminally responsible for the two falsified certificates, and under which articles of the Penal Code each is liable.
  • Whether or not the special circumstance of Article 11 of the Penal Code should be applied in favor of the accused.

Applicable Provisions

Article 301 of the Penal Code, in connection with Article 300, defines and punishes the falsification of a public or official document, and the Court applied it to the altered certificate of baptism:

The crime of falsification of a public document has been committed, inasmuch as a certificate of baptism is of a public or official character, this crime being defined and punished in article 301, in connection with article 300 of the Penal Code.

Article 307 of the same Code punishes the falsification of a personal cedula, which the Court found was also committed:

The facts also show the commission of another crime, consisting in the falsification of a personal cedula, punished by article 307 of the same Code.

Article 310 defines and punishes the falsification of certificates committed by a public officer, and it is the provision under which the gobernadorcillo was held liable:

The offense being specifically punished by article 310 of the Code.

Article 311 governs the liability of a private individual who attests to a false certificate, and it is the provision under which the attesting witness Luna was held liable:

However, the responsibility of Teodoro Luna, as a mere attesting witness, and therefore a mere private individual, and not in the exercise of any public, permanent office, falls within the provisions of article 311 of Code.

Article 11 of the Penal Code supplies the special circumstance that the Court applied in favor of the accused:

In the commission of the two crimes above mentioned, we are of the opinion that the especial circumstance of article 11 of the Code should be applied, in view of the character of the crimes prosecuted and the personal conditions of the accused, there being no aggravating circumstance to offset the effect of this article.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held that the crime of falsification of a public document was indeed committed, because a certificate of baptism is public or official in character, and the alteration of the year of birth brought the act within Article 301 in relation to Article 300 of the Penal Code.

On the second issue, the Court held that Barbasa could not be held liable for the falsification of the cedula. His signature was simply appended to attest that the cedula was issued, as it in fact was, by the cabeza de barangay, upon whom alone rests the responsibility for the validity and authenticity of the cedula. Since Abalos, the cabeza de barangay, was absent, the question of his guilt was not before the Court.

On the third issue, the Court held that Barbasa and Luna were responsible for the two falsified certificates. Barbasa, acting as a local authority, issued and signed the certificates under his name and official title, sealed with the seal of the municipal court of Ermita, so that the documents had an official character and the offense fell under Article 310. Luna, a mere attesting witness and therefore a private individual not in the exercise of any public, permanent office, fell under Article 311. The Court explained the basis of liability in these terms:

Hence, the attesting witness Teodoro Luna and the gobernadorcillo who signed the certificates are responsible for the falsification committed by the mere fact of having certified to the truth of statements therein contained.

On the fourth issue, the Court applied the special circumstance of Article 11 of the Penal Code, there being no aggravating circumstance to offset it, and adjusted the penalties accordingly.

Doctrine

A certificate of baptism is a public or official document, and its alteration constitutes falsification of a public document under Article 301 in relation to Article 300 of the Penal Code. The gobernadorcillo who signs and issues a false certificate in the exercise of his official duties is liable under Article 310, while a mere attesting witness, being a private individual not in the exercise of a public, permanent office, is liable under Article 311. A public officer who merely attests that a cedula was issued by the cabeza de barangay does not thereby participate in the falsification of that cedula, the responsibility for its validity and authenticity resting on the cabeza de barangay alone. Finally, the special circumstance of Article 11 of the Penal Code may be applied in view of the character of the crimes and the personal conditions of the accused where no aggravating circumstance offsets it.

Disposition

The Supreme Court modified the judgment below: it acquitted Barbasa and Luna of the falsification of cedula, sentenced Barbasa for each of the two crimes of falsification of certificates to two years and one day of suspension from public office, the right of suffrage, and the exercise of any trade or profession, and to a fine of 700 pesetas, with subsidiary imprisonment and costs, and sentenced Luna for each crime to one month and fifteen days of arresto mayor, with accessories and costs, affirming the judgment below insofar as it conformed to this opinion and reversing it insofar as it conflicted with it.

Remember This

The single line worth memorizing is that the officer who signs a false certificate in the exercise of his office answers under Article 310, while the private attesting witness answers under Article 311, and that the mere attestation of a cedula issued by the cabeza de barangay does not make the gobernadorcillo a participant in its falsification. Examiners like to use this case to test the distinction between the liability of a public officer and that of a private individual in falsification, and the application of the special circumstance of Article 11 of the old Penal Code.