SIMONA BRILLANTES, PLAINTIFF AND APPELLEE, VS. MANUEL BRILLANTES ET AL., DEFENDANTS AND APPELLANTS.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Brillantes versus Brillantes
The Case
This is the case of Brillantes versus Brillantes, an old decision of the Philippine Supreme Court from December 1902, in which Simona Brillantes was the plaintiff and appellee and Manuel Brillantes and others were the defendants and appellants. The action below was one in which judgment had been rendered in favor of the plaintiff, and the defendants appealed. The case matters to a Bar candidate not for the merits of the original dispute but for what it teaches about the perfection and prosecution of appeals: an appeal may be declared abandoned and the judgment below allowed to become final when the appellant fails to prosecute it within the period fixed by law, and the appellant cannot escape that consequence by a bare claim of force majeure that he never bothers to prove.
Procedural History
The case began in the trial court, where judgment was rendered in favor of the plaintiff, Simona Brillantes, against the defendants, Manuel Brillantes and others. The defendants appealed. The appeal, however, was not prosecuted, and by an order of July 30 the appeal was declared abandoned, the appellants' rights were declared to have lapsed by the expiration of more than two years, and the judgment appealed from was declared final.
Notice of that order was served upon Manuel Brillantes at his residence through the judge of Abra. On the very next day after such service, Manuel Brillantes filed a petition asking that the order be vacated and that he be allowed the period of twenty days or more provided by the old Code of Civil Procedure so that he could arrange for a solicitor to represent him before the Supreme Court. He alleged, among other grounds, that he had been prevented from prosecuting the appeal by force majeure, namely, by war, and that the period prescribed by law had not yet expired when the force majeure ceased. The matter thus came before the Supreme Court for resolution of his petition.
Facts
Simona Brillantes obtained a judgment in her favor against Manuel Brillantes and the other defendants. The defendants appealed, but the appeal was not prosecuted within the period allowed by the rules then in force.
Because of this inaction, the court issued an order on July 30 declaring the appeal abandoned and the appellants' rights to have lapsed by the expiration of more than two years, and declaring the judgment appealed from final. Notice of this order was served on Manuel Brillantes at his residence through the judge of Abra.
On the following day, Manuel Brillantes filed a petition to vacate the order. He claimed that he had been prevented from prosecuting the appeal by force majeure, specifically by war, and that when the force majeure ceased the period allowed by law had not yet expired, so that he was entitled to the remedy he invoked. The Court noted, however, that the petitioner neither proved nor even offered to prove that he had been prevented from prosecuting his appeal before the expiration of the two-year period by force majeure or by any cause independent of his own will.
Issues
- Whether or not the appeal should be declared abandoned and the judgment appealed from declared final for failure to prosecute the appeal within the period fixed by law.
- Whether or not the appellant is entitled to have the order of abandonment vacated on the ground of force majeure, consisting of war, when he neither proved nor offered to prove that such force majeure prevented him from prosecuting his appeal.
Applicable Provisions
The decision refers to the old Code of Civil Procedure, particularly its provisions on the period for prosecuting an appeal and on relief from the lapse of that period. The Court framed the governing rule in these words:
The petitioner has not proven, nor has he even offered to prove, that he was prevented from prosecuting his appeal before the expiration of the term of two years by force majeure, or by any cause independent of his own will.
This language bears directly on the case because it fixes the burden on the appellant claiming force majeure: he must prove it, and a mere allegation will not suffice to excuse his failure to prosecute the appeal.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court gave effect to the order of July 30. The appeal had been declared abandoned, the appellants' rights had lapsed by the expiration of more than two years, and the judgment appealed from had been declared final. The Court directed that the directions contained in that order be carried into effect.
On the second issue, the Court denied the petition to vacate the order. The petitioner had not proven, and had not even offered to prove, that he was prevented from prosecuting his appeal before the expiration of the two-year term by force majeure or by any cause independent of his own will. Because the factual basis for relief was entirely unsubstantiated, the application, brought under the pertinent provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure, had to be overruled. The Court put the point squarely:
For this reason his application, brought conformably to the provisions of articles 395, 399, and 400 of the Code of Civil Procedure, must be overruled, and consequently the vacation of the order prayed for by Manuel Brillantes in his petition of September 20 last is denied, with the costs.
The Court thus resolved both issues against the appellant and in favor of the finality of the judgment below.
Doctrine
Three rules may be drawn from this case and written in an answer. First, an appeal not prosecuted within the period fixed by law may be declared abandoned, and upon such abandonment the judgment of the trial court becomes final and executory. Second, the remedy of relief from the lapse of the period for appealing on the ground of force majeure requires that the appellant prove that he was prevented from prosecuting his appeal by force majeure or by some cause independent of his own will; a bare allegation of war, without proof or even an offer of proof, is insufficient. Third, the burden of establishing the ground for relief lies on the party invoking it, and failure to discharge that burden means the order of abandonment stands, with costs against the petitioner.
Disposition
The petition to vacate the order was denied with costs, and the order declaring the appeal abandoned and the judgment final was directed to be carried into effect, so that Simona Brillantes, the plaintiff and appellee, prevailed.
Remember This
The single line worth memorizing is that force majeure excusing the failure to prosecute an appeal must be proven, not merely alleged, or the judgment below becomes final. Examiners use this case to test the requisites for relief from the lapse of the period to appeal and the doctrine of finality of judgments.