🎧 Case Brief Lecture

JOSE MENCHAVEZ, JUAN MENCHAVEZ JR., SIMEON MENCHAVEZ, RODOLFO MENCHAVEZ, CESAR MENCHAVEZ, REYNALDO, MENCHAVEZ, ALMA MENCHAVEZ, ELMA MENCHAVEZ, CHARITO M. MAGA, FE M. POTOT, THEL…

G.R. NO. 153201. January 26, 2005 January 26, 2005

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

Menchavez versus Teves

The Case

This is a petition for review filed by the Menchavez family against Florentino Teves Jr. The dispute arises from a contract of lease over a fishpond in Tabuelan, Cebu. The lessors leased out property that did not belong to them, because fishponds belong to the State and may only be leased, never sold or subleased. The case matters because it is the Supreme Court's clean statement of the in pari delicto rule — in plain English, the rule that parties equally at fault are left where the law finds them — and of the principle that a void contract produces no legal effect, so that even liquidated damages stipulated in it cannot be recovered.

Procedural History

Teves sued the Menchavez family for damages in the Regional Trial Court, alleging breach of the warranties of peaceful enjoyment in the contract of lease. The lessors in turn filed a third party complaint against the Allego spouses and others, who had acted as agents in demolishing the fishpond dikes. The trial court dismissed Teves's complaint. It held that the lease was void from the start because the fishpond belonged to the State, and that both parties were in pari delicto, so neither could recover from the other. It also dismissed the third party complaint and upheld the third party defendants' counterclaims.

Teves appealed to the Court of Appeals. The appellate court modified the trial court's decision. It found that Teves had no actual knowledge of the lessors' lack of ownership, awarded him actual damages and liquidated damages, and dismissed the third party complaint while upholding the counterclaims. The Court of Appeals denied the lessors' motion for reconsideration. The Menchavez family then came to the Supreme Court by petition for review under Rule 45.

Facts

On February 28, 1986, the Menchavez family, as lessors, executed a contract of lease with Florentino Teves Jr. as lessee. The contract covered an area of about ten hectares in Tabuelan, Cebu, and recited that the lessors were the absolute and lawful co-owners of the area covered by a fishpond application filed by Juan Menchavez Sr. in 1972. The lease was for five years, with annual rent of 40,000 pesos. The lessors warranted that the property was fit for use as a fishpond, that the lessee would enjoy it peacefully for the entire term, and that it was free from liens and encumbrances. They bound themselves jointly and severally to pay liquidated damages of not less than 50,000 pesos for any violation.

Unknown to the lessee, the same property had been the subject of an earlier case, in which the Menchavez spouses were ordered to remove the dikes illegally constructed and to pay damages. On June 2, 1988, court sheriffs demolished the dikes Teves had built and delivered possession of the property to other parties.

Teves then sued for damages, claiming the cost of the demolished dikes, unearned income, and the rentals he had paid. The lessors, for their part, impleaded the agents of the parties who had obtained the property. The evidence showed that the lessors' fishpond application had never been approved, and that Teves knew this when he signed the contract, which itself recited that the area was still covered by an application.

Issues

  • Whether or not the parties to the void contract of lease were in pari delicto, or equally at fault, such that neither may recover from the other.
  • Whether or not the Court of Appeals erred in awarding actual damages and liquidated damages to the lessee despite the nullity of the contract.

Applicable Provisions

Article 1412 of the Civil Code provides:

Art. 1412. If the act in which the unlawful or forbidden cause consists does not constitute a criminal offense, the following rules shall be observed: (1) When the fault is on the part of both contracting parties, neither may recover what he has given by virtue of the contract, or demand the performance of the other's undertaking; (2) When only one of the contracting parties is at fault, he cannot recover what he has given by reason of the contract, or ask for the fulfillment of what has been promised him. The other, who is not at fault, may demand the return of what he has given without any obligation to comply with his promise.

This is the provision that governs whether a party to a void contract may recover what he gave, and it turns on whose fault caused the nullity.

Section 45 of Republic Act Number 8550, the Philippine Fisheries Code of 1998, provides:

Section 45. Disposition of Public Lands for Fishery Purposes. — Public lands such as tidal swamps, mangroves, marshes, foreshore lands and ponds suitable for fishery operations shall not be disposed or alienated.

This confirms that fishponds are public lands that the State does not alienate, which is why the lessors had no right to transfer to the lessee.

Section 46 of the same Code provides:

Section 46. Lease of Fishponds. — Fishpond leased to qualified persons and fisherfolk organizations/cooperatives shall be subject to the following conditions: a. Areas leased for fishpond purposes shall be no more than 50 hectares for individuals and 250 hectares for corporations or fisherfolk organizations; b. The lease shall be for a period of twenty-five (25) years and renewable for another twenty-five (25) years: Provided, That in case of the death of the lessee, his spouse and/or

This provision, like its predecessor decree, allows fishponds to be leased but not subleased, which is why the lessors could give the lessee no transferable right.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held that the parties were in pari delicto. The finding of fault is a question of fact, but the Court reviewed it because the appellate court's findings contradicted those of the trial court and rested on a presumption rebutted by the evidence. The lessors leased property that did not belong to them and that they had no authority to sublease. The lessee, however, admitted that he knew the fishpond application had not been approved, and the contract itself recited that the area was still covered by an application. The existence of a pending application necessarily contradicts a claim of ownership. He negotiated in the office of his own lawyer, who was expected to know that fishponds belong to the State. As the party alleging that he was misled, he bore the burden of proving it by preponderance of evidence, and he failed. Both being equally at fault, neither may recover against the other.

On the second issue, the Court held that the award of liquidated damages was improper. Liquidated damages are accessory and subsidiary obligations, meant to secure performance of the principal obligation. Since the principal obligation was void, there was no contract that could have been breached, and the stipulation on liquidated damages was inexistent. The Court stated the rule plainly:

A void contract is equivalent to nothing; it produces no civil effect.

No damages may be recovered on the basis of a void contract. Being nonexistent, the agreement produces no juridical tie between the parties. The injured party may recover only through other sources of obligations, such as law or quasi-contract, and a party recovering through those sources may not claim liquidated damages, which arise only from a contract.

Doctrine

A void contract is equivalent to nothing and produces no civil effect. It creates no juridical relation, and the courts leave the parties as they are, because they are deemed in pari delicto, in equal fault. Under Article 1412 of the Civil Code, when the fault is on the part of both contracting parties, neither may recover what he has given by virtue of the contract, or demand the performance of the other's undertaking. Only the party not at fault may demand the return of what he has given.

Because a void contract produces no juridical tie, no damages, including liquidated damages, may be recovered on its basis. Liquidated damages are accessory to the principal obligation; the nullity of the principal carries with it the nullity of the accessory. Recovery, if any, must rest on another source of obligation, such as law or quasi-contract.

Disposition

The petition was granted. The Court set aside the decision and resolution of the Court of Appeals and reinstated the decision of the trial court, with no pronouncement as to costs.

Remember This

Memorize the line: a void contract is equivalent to nothing and produces no civil effect, so parties equally at fault are left where they are. Examiners use this case to test the in pari delicto rule under Article 1412 of the Civil Code and the rule that liquidated damages cannot survive the nullity of the principal obligation.