🎧 Case Brief Lecture

POWTON CONGLOMERATE, INC., AND PHILIP C. CHIEN, PETITIONERS, VS. JOHNNY AGCOLICOL, RESPONDENT.

G.R. No. 150978. April 03, 2003 April 3, 2003

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

Powton Conglomerate versus Agcolicol

The Case

This is a petition for review on certiorari brought by Powton Conglomerate, Incorporated and its president and chairman of the board, Philip Chien, against Johnny Agcolicol, the proprietor of Japerson Engineering who contracted to install the electrical facilities of the Ciano Plaza Building. Agcolicol sued for a sum of money, claiming the unpaid balance of the contract price and the cost of additional electrical works, and the lower courts awarded him both. The case matters because the Supreme Court uses it to draw a hard line under Article 1724 of the Civil Code: a contractor under a lump-sum contract cannot recover an increase in price unless the change in plans was authorized in writing by the owner and the additional price was itself agreed upon in writing. It also reminds us that a corporate officer who signs for the corporation is not personally liable for its debts absent any of the recognized exceptions.

Procedural History

Agcolicol filed a complaint for sum of money with the Regional Trial Court of Pasay City, Branch 115. After trial, the court rendered judgment in his favor, ordering Powton and Chien, jointly and severally, to pay the total unpaid obligations plus legal interest from the filing of the complaint. Powton and Chien appealed to the Court of Appeals, which affirmed the trial court in full. Their motion for reconsideration was denied. They then came to the Supreme Court by petition for review on certiorari.

Facts

In November 1990, Johnny Agcolicol, doing business as Japerson Engineering, entered into an Electrical Installation Contract with Powton Conglomerate, Incorporated, acting through its president and chairman of the board, Philip Chien. For a fixed contract price of 5,300,000 pesos, Agcolicol undertook to supply the electrical works, including the necessary labor and materials, for the Ciano Plaza Building in Makati. The contract provided that any addition or reduction in the cost of work shall be mutually agreed in writing by both the owner and the contractor, upon the recommendation of the architect or engineer, before execution. In August 1992, the Makati City Engineer's Office inspected the installations, found them in good condition, and issued the corresponding certificate of electrical inspection.

During construction, several revisions and deviations from the original plan and specification of the building were introduced. Agcolicol was aware of these revisions and of the consequent increase in the cost of the electrical works, yet he completed the installation without first entering into a written agreement with Powton for the increased costs. The demand letter notifying Powton of the increase was sent only after the project was completed.

In December 1994, Agcolicol sued. He alleged that of the contract price, only 5,031,860 pesos and forty centavos had been paid, leaving a balance of 268,139 pesos and eighty centavos, and he also claimed 722,730 pesos and thirty-eight centavos for additional electrical works. Powton and Chien answered that the installations were defective and were completed beyond the agreed period. At pre-trial, the parties stipulated that the unpaid balance claimed is 268,139 pesos and sixty centavos and the cost of additional work is 722,730 pesos and thirty-eight centavos. Chien testified that an independent engineer had certified the job incomplete, and promised to present that engineer, but never did.

Issues

  • Whether or not the petitioners are liable to pay the balance of the contract price despite their claim that the electrical installations were defective and completed beyond the agreed period.
  • Whether or not the respondent may recover the cost of additional electrical works allegedly necessitated by revisions in the structural design of the building, absent a prior written agreement authorizing the increase.
  • Whether or not petitioner Philip Chien may be held solidarily liable with petitioner Powton Conglomerate, Incorporated for the latter's obligation.

Applicable Provisions

Article 1724 of the Civil Code provides:

Article 1724. The contractor who undertakes to build a structure or any other work for a stipulated price, in conformity with plans and specifications agreed upon with the landowner, can neither withdraw from the contract nor demand an increase in the price on account of the higher cost of labor or materials, save when there has been a change in the plans and specifications, provided: (1) Such change has been authorized by the proprietor in writing; and (2) The additional price to be paid to the contractor has been determined in writing by both parties.

This is the specific provision governing the contractor's claim for additional costs, and its two requisites are conditions precedent to recovery.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court ruled for the respondent. The petitioners' justification for withholding the balance rested solely on Chien's self-serving testimony. He promised to present the independent engineer who supposedly certified the job incomplete and defective, but no such engineer or other competent witness was ever presented. Bare assertions of unsatisfactory and delayed installation cannot justify non-payment. The Court therefore affirmed the award of the balance of 268,139 pesos and eighty centavos.

On the second issue, the Court ruled for the petitioners. Both lower courts had sweepingly applied unjust enrichment without discussing Article 1724. The Court stressed that the present provision added substantive requisites to its Spanish predecessor: the change must be authorized by the proprietor in writing, and the additional price must be determined in writing by both parties. These requisites are a safeguard and a substantive condition precedent to recovery, meant to prevent litigation over additional costs. Here, although revisions were introduced and Agcolicol knew of the increased cost, he completed the work without any prior written agreement on the increase. The demand letter came only after completion. The Court also held that the change in plans referred to in Article 1724 pertains to the very contract between owner and contractor; the revision here concerned the structural design of the building, not the electrical installation contract, and consent to the former does not extend to the latter. The Court quoted its earlier ruling with approval:

Compliance with the two requisites in Article 1724, a specific provision governing additional works, is a condition precedent to recovery. The absence of one or the other bars the recovery of additional costs.

Unjust enrichment cannot be invoked by a contractor who, through his own act or omission, took the risk of being denied payment by failing to give prior notice and secure written consent.

On the third issue, the Court ruled for Chien. A corporation has a personality separate and distinct from the persons composing it, and corporate officers who contract in its behalf cannot be held personally liable for its liabilities, save for certain exceptions: assenting to a patently unlawful act, bad faith or gross negligence, conflict of interest, consenting to watered-down stocks, agreeing to hold oneself personally and solidarily liable, or being made personally answerable by a specific provision of law. None of these exceptions was established. Chien, who contracted as president and chairman of the board, cannot be held solidarily liable.

Doctrine

Under Article 1724 of the Civil Code, a contractor who undertakes to build a structure or other work for a stipulated price cannot demand an increase in price on account of higher labor or material costs unless two requisites concur: the change in plans and specifications was authorized by the proprietor in writing, and the additional price was determined in writing by both parties. These are conditions precedent to recovery, and the absence of either bars the claim; neither may be proved by other evidence. The written consent of the owner is not a mere formality but a vital precondition to the validity of a subsequent contract authorizing a higher price. The principle of unjust enrichment cannot substitute for the statutory requisites where the contractor assumed the risk by failing to secure prior written consent. Finally, a corporate officer who enters into a contract in behalf of the corporation is not personally liable for the corporation's obligations absent any of the recognized exceptions.

Disposition

The petition was partially granted: Powton Conglomerate, Incorporated was ordered to pay Johnny Agcolicol the unpaid balance of 268,139 pesos and sixty centavos, while Philip Chien was absolved from personal liability, and the award for additional works was set aside.

Remember This

Memorize the two written requisites of Article 1724: written authorization of the change by the owner and a written agreement on the additional price, both conditions precedent to recovery. Examiners use this case to test the contractor's claim for additional costs in a lump-sum construction contract and the personal liability of corporate officers who sign for the corporation.