🎧 Case Brief Lecture

CATALINA VDA. DE RETUERTO AS SURVIVING WIDOW OF THE LATE PANFILO RETUERTO; LORETO RETUERTO, REPRESENTED BY HIS SURVIVING HEIRS NAMELY: ROMEO RETUERTO; ANTONIA RETUERTO, NARCISA …

G.R. No. 148180. December 19, 2001 December 19, 2001

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

Retuerto versus Barz

The Case

This is a petition for review on certiorari brought by the surviving heirs of the late Panfilo Retuerto, together with the spouses Jose Gesalem and Rosa Gesalem, against Angelo Barz and Melinda Barz. The Barzes had sued the Retuerto heirs to quiet title over two subdivision lots, Lot 896-A and Lot 896-B, which formed part of a larger parcel covered by an original certificate of title in the name of the Barzes' predecessor, Pedro Barz. The Retuerto heirs countered that their own predecessor, Panfilo Retuerto, had bought a portion of that land long before, and that the Barzes' title was therefore held in trust for them. The case matters because it is the Supreme Court's clean statement of the indefeasibility of a Torrens title after one year, of the ten-year prescriptive period for an action for reconveyance based on a constructive trust, and of the rule that a certificate of title cannot be collaterally attacked.

Procedural History

Angelo Barz and Melinda Barz filed a complaint for quieting of title, damages and attorney's fees before the Regional Trial Court of Mandaue City against Catalina Retuerto and the other heirs of Panfilo Retuerto, including the spouses Gesalem. On April 3, 1997, the trial court ruled for the Barzes. It declared them the absolute owners in fee simple of Lots 896-A and 896-B, declared the documents adduced by the Retuerto heirs unenforceable and ineffective against the original certificate of title, nullified the deed of sale between the Retuerto heirs and the spouses Gesalem, and ordered the Retuerto heirs to vacate the premises. The Retuerto heirs and the Gesalem spouses appealed to the Court of Appeals. On December 29, 2000, the Court of Appeals affirmed the trial court in all respects except that it deleted the award of attorney's fees. The losing parties then came to the Supreme Court by petition for review on certiorari, assigning three errors: that the Court of Appeals wrongly held they had only ten years from the issuance of the title within which to seek reconveyance despite their possession since time immemorial; that the Court of Appeals erred in not finding that the Barzes' right to question their ownership and possession had been lost through laches; and that the Court of Appeals erred in holding that they could not ventilate their claim of title by way of affirmative defense because that would be a collateral attack on the title.

Facts

From September to October 1911, a parcel of land in Mandaue, Cebu, identified as Lot 896 of a subdivision plan and forming part of the Hacienda de Mandaue, was surveyed. The survey was amended in the period from November 1926 to March 1927, and the lot then had an area of 20,486 square meters. The land was occupied by the spouses Esteban Perez and Lorenza Sanchez. When they died intestate, their daughter Juana Perez, married to Numeriano Barz, inherited their rights and declared the property for taxation purposes under her name. On April 16, 1929, Juana Perez executed a deed confirming her sale of a portion of the land, identified as Lot 896-A with an approximate area of 2,505 square meters, in favor of Panfilo Retuerto, married to Catalina Ceniza. On April 26, 1935, Panfilo Retuerto also purchased the same parcel from the Archbishop of Cebu for 150 pesos, and declared it for taxation purposes effective 1937. In the meantime, the San Carlos Seminary of Cebu filed a petition for the issuance of titles over several parcels in the Hacienda de Mandaue, including Lot 896-A. In August 1937, the court declared Panfilo Retuerto the owner of that lot, and on July 22, 1940, it ordered the issuance of the appropriate decree in his favor. No decree was ever issued, because the Second World War intervened, and Panfilo Retuerto failed to secure the decree after the war.

Two decades passed. Juana Perez Barz died intestate and was survived by her son Pedro Barz. Sometime in 1966, Pedro Barz filed an application with the Court of First Instance of Cebu for confirmation of his title over Lot 896. The spouses Panfilo Retuerto filed no opposition. The court declared Pedro Barz the lawful owner, finding that he and his predecessors had been in peaceful, continuous and open possession in the concept of owner since 1915. A decree was issued in his favor in 1966, and on November 13, 1968, Original Certificate of Title No. 521 was issued in his name. The property was then subdivided into four lots, among them Lot 896-A and Lot 896-B. Pedro Barz sold Lot 896-C to Jose Gesalem in 1967, and a transfer certificate of title was issued to the vendee. Panfilo Retuerto continued to declare the property for taxation purposes under his name effective 1974. He died intestate on December 29, 1975, survived by his widow Catalina and their children. On January 4, 1976, the heirs executed an extrajudicial settlement and sale of his estate, adjudicating a portion of 1,703 square meters to Loreto Retuerto and a portion of 440 square meters to Efigenia Retuerto, who then declared the portions under their own names for taxation purposes.

Pedro Barz later died intestate, survived by Angelo Barz and Melinda Barz. Loreto Retuerto also died intestate, survived by Romeo, Antonia, Narcisa, Corazon and Patrocinia, all surnamed Retuerto. The heirs of Panfilo Retuerto then claimed ownership over Lot 896-B and a part of Lot 896-A, which were covered by the original certificate of title. Lot 896-B was subdivided by the Retuerto heirs, and one subdivision lot of 440 square meters was sold to the spouses Jose Gesalem and Rosa Gesalem. When the Barzes learned of these events, a confrontation took place, during which the Gesalem spouses admitted having purchased a portion of Lot 896-B. On September 5, 1989, the Barzes filed their complaint for quieting of title. The Retuerto heirs answered that Panfilo Retuerto had been the lawful owner, that they were unaware that the land sold to him had been included in the Barzes' title, and the Gesalem spouses answered that the inclusion of the property in the Barzes' title made Pedro Barz a mere trustee under a constructive trust, and that the Barzes' action was barred by laches.

Issues

  • Whether or not the Court of Appeals erred in holding that the petitioners had only ten years from the issuance of the original certificate of title within which to ask for reconveyance, despite their claimed possession of the property since time immemorial.
  • Whether or not the Court of Appeals erred in not finding that the respondents' right to question the petitioners' ownership and possession over the subject property had been lost through laches.
  • Whether or not the Court of Appeals erred in holding that the petitioners could not ventilate their claim of title over the subject property by way of affirmative defense, as this would constitute a collateral attack on the respondents' original certificate of title.

Applicable Provisions

Section 48 of Presidential Decree No. 1529, the Property Registration Decree, provides:

A certificate of title cannot be subject to collateral attack; it cannot be altered, modified or cancelled except in a direct proceeding.

This is the provision the Court invokes to reject the petitioners' attempt to assert ownership of the land merely as an affirmative defense in the Barzes' action for quieting of title.

Section 32 of Presidential Decree No. 1529, which the petitioners themselves invoked as the basis for an action for reconveyance on the ground of fraud, is discussed by the Court in connection with the ten-year prescriptive period for such an action.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held that the Court of Appeals correctly applied the principles of the Torrens system. A certificate of title serves as evidence of an indefeasible and incontrovertible title in favor of the person whose name appears therein, and that indefeasibility commences after the lapse or expiration of one year from the date of entry of the decree of registration. Registration is constructive notice to all persons, so after one year the title can no longer be contested. Original Certificate of Title No. 521 was issued in the name of Pedro Barz on November 13, 1968, so after one year, on November 13, 1969, the title became indefeasible. The petitioners' claim that Panfilo Retuerto bought the property in 1929 and that it was adjudicated to him in 1937 did not help them, because no decree of registration was ever issued, the earlier sale was not registered, and Panfilo Retuerto never intervened in the 1966 confirmation proceedings. Even assuming that Pedro Barz acquired title through mistake or fraud, the Court held that an action for reconveyance based on an implied or constructive trust prescribes within ten years from the time of its creation or upon the alleged fraudulent registration of the property, and since registration is constructive notice, the ten-year period is reckoned from the time of registering. The petitioners should have filed an action for reconveyance within ten years from the issuance of the title in November 1968, and they did not. On the argument drawn from the Heirs of Jose Olviga case, that the ten-year period applies only when the person enforcing the trust is not in possession, the Court held that the 1966 decision of the land registration court had found Pedro Barz and his predecessors in peaceful, continuous and open possession in the concept of owner since 1915, so the premise of the petitioners' argument failed.

On the second issue, the Court rejected the claim that the respondents' right had been lost through laches, because the respondents held an indefeasible title and had been in possession, and it was the petitioners who slept on their rights for twenty-one years.

On the third issue, the Court held that the petitioners' claim of ownership, raised for the first time in their answer and by way of affirmative defenses in 1989, could not be allowed. Under Section 48 of the Property Registration Decree, a certificate of title cannot be subject to collateral attack, and the issue of the validity of a title, that is, whether or not it was fraudulently issued, can only be raised in an action expressly instituted for that purpose.

Doctrine

A Torrens certificate of title is evidence of an indefeasible and incontrovertible title in favor of the person named in it, and it becomes indefeasible after the lapse of one year from the entry of the decree of registration. Registration is constructive notice to all persons, so after that year the title can no longer be contested. An action for reconveyance based on an implied or constructive trust prescribes in ten years from the time of its creation or from the alleged fraudulent registration of the property, and because registration is constructive notice, the period is counted from the date of registration. The rule that the prescriptive period does not run against one in actual possession applies only where the claimant is in fact in possession, and it cannot be invoked where the registration court has found the registered owner and his predecessors in peaceful, continuous and open possession in the concept of owner. Finally, under Section 48 of the Property Registration Decree, a certificate of title cannot be collaterally attacked; the validity of a title, including a claim that it was fraudulently issued, can be raised only in a direct proceeding instituted for that purpose, not by way of an affirmative defense in another action.

Disposition

The Supreme Court denied the petition and affirmed the decision of the Court of Appeals, so the Barzes won and were confirmed as owners of Lots 896-A and 896-B, with the deed of sale to the Gesalem spouses nullified and the Retuerto heirs ordered to vacate.

Remember This

Memorize this line: after one year from the entry of the decree, the Torrens title becomes indefeasible, and an action for reconveyance on a constructive trust prescribes in ten years counted from registration, which is constructive notice to all. Examiners use this case to test the one-year indefeasibility rule, the ten-year prescriptive period for reconveyance, and the prohibition against a collateral attack on a certificate of title.