ANGELITO CABATULAN, PETITIONER, VS. HON. MUSIB M. BUAT, PRESIDING COMMISSIONER, OSCAR M. ABELLA AND LEON G. GONZAGA, JR., (BOTH COMMISSIONERS), NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS COMMISSI…
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Cabatulan versus Buat
The Case
This is a labor case about the wages of a man who was illegally dismissed. Angelito Cabatulan sued his employers, the spouses Julio and Cecilia Cosmiano, who ran a trucking business called J.C. Trucking, after they removed him from his post as operations manager and purchasing officer. The Labor Arbiter and later the National Labor Relations Commission found that he had been illegally dismissed, but the monetary awards kept shrinking along the way, and the Court of Appeals reinstated a resolution that deducted his earnings elsewhere from his backwages. The case matters because it fixes the rule on full backwages under Article 279 of the Labor Code, as amended by Republic Act Number 6715: an illegally dismissed employee is entitled to full backwages without deduction or qualification, and separation pay may be awarded in lieu of reinstatement in addition to those backwages.
Procedural History
Cabatulan filed a complaint for illegal dismissal and money claims before the Labor Arbiter. The Labor Arbiter ruled in his favor, declaring the termination illegal and awarding backwages, separation pay, unpaid wages, proportionate thirteenth month pay, moral damages, and attorney's fees. The employers appealed to the National Labor Relations Commission. The Commission affirmed the finding of illegal dismissal but reduced the monetary awards, deleted the moral damages, and reduced the attorney's fees. Cabatulan did not move for reconsideration of that resolution. The employers did, and the Commission granted their motion, dismissing the complaint for illegal dismissal, deleting the backwages and accrued salaries, and awarding instead separation pay of one-half month for every year of service as a measure of social justice, plus a small indemnity.
Cabatulan then moved for reconsideration, which was denied. He went to the Court of Appeals on a petition for certiorari, seeking to nullify the later resolutions. The Court of Appeals granted the petition, nullified those resolutions, and reinstated the earlier resolution of the Commission. Both sides moved for reconsideration and both were denied. Cabatulan then filed a petition for review on certiorari before the Supreme Court, raising the question of whether he was entitled to backwages and other monetary benefits under Article 279 despite his failure to move for reconsideration of the earlier resolution.
Facts
On March 16, 1987, the spouses Julio and Cecilia Cosmiano, who operated J.C. Trucking in Bislig, Surigao del Sur, employed Angelito Cabatulan, a close relative of Julio, as operations manager and purchasing officer. On April 8, 1993, the spouses left on a world tour and entrusted the business operations to Cabatulan.
On May 11, 1993, an altercation arose between Cabatulan and Isidro Alaan, a police officer who served as Julio's security aide, over the purchase of spare parts. Later that day, Cabatulan was told that Julio's brother, Vincent Cosmiano, wanted to see him. On his way, Cabatulan passed the premises of J.C. Trucking but was refused admission by Alaan, who was armed with a rifle. Vincent advised Cabatulan not to report for work in the meantime and to await the arrival of the spouses. Cabatulan agreed and went home.
On May 25, 1993, Cabatulan reported for work, knowing the spouses would arrive that day. He was summoned to their residence the next day and told his services were no longer needed. He was given a pre-drafted resignation letter, which he refused to sign, even after Julio offered him five thousand pesos to sign it. On June 11, 1993, he filed his complaint. The employers defended on the ground that Cabatulan had abandoned his job and that he was abusive, but the Labor Arbiter and the Commission both found that he had been illegally dismissed.
Issues
- Whether or not Cabatulan is entitled to backwages and other monetary benefits under Article 279 of the Labor Code notwithstanding his failure to file a motion for reconsideration of the May 28, 1997 Resolution of the National Labor Relations Commission.
- Whether or not the award of backwages should be reduced by the earnings Cabatulan derived elsewhere during the period of his illegal dismissal.
- Whether or not separation pay may be awarded in lieu of reinstatement, and in addition to full backwages.
Applicable Provisions
Article 279 of the Labor Code of the Philippines, as amended by Section 34 of Republic Act Number 6715, provides:
Article 279. Security of Tenure. In cases of regular employment, the employer shall not terminate the services of an employee except for a just cause or when authorized by this Title. An employee who is unjustly dismissed from work shall be entitled to reinstatement without loss of seniority rights and other privileges and to his full backwages, inclusive of allowances, and to his other benefits or their monetary equivalent computed from the time his compensation was withheld from him up to the time of his actual reinstatement.
This is the provision that fixes the relief owed to an illegally dismissed employee, and the case turns on the meaning of its phrase "full backwages."
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court ruled in favor of Cabatulan. As a general rule, a party who did not appeal cannot obtain affirmative relief other than that already granted, and this applies to decisions of quasi-judicial tribunals. But Cabatulan could not be faulted for not appealing, because the decision was in his favor. The Commission had found him illegally dismissed, and it was therefore mandated to award the monetary benefits due him under the law. The Court held that it would be absurd for the Commission, and for the Court of Appeals, to rule that he was dismissed without valid cause and yet declare that he was not entitled to the monetary benefits provided by law. Where an ironhanded application of the rules would result in a miscarriage of justice, technicalities should be transgressed.
On the second issue, the Court agreed with Cabatulan that the deduction of his earnings elsewhere was error. Quoting its landmark ruling in Bustamante versus National Labor Relations Commission, the Court held:
In other words, the provision calling for full backwages to illegally dismissed employees is clear, plain and free from ambiguity and, therefore, must be applied without attempted or strained interpretation.
The reason is that the employee, while litigating the legality of his dismissal, must still earn a living, while full backwages are paid by the employer as part of the penalty for illegally dismissing him. Employees dismissed before the effectivity of Republic Act Number 6715 were granted backwages up to three years without deduction, while those dismissed after were granted full backwages inclusive of allowances and other benefits from the time compensation was withheld up to actual reinstatement.
On the third issue, the Court held that reinstatement is not always practicable, as when relations have been so severely strained that it is no longer fitting, or when the employee chooses not to return. Here the employers had charged Cabatulan with qualified theft and even coerced him into withdrawing the labor case, showing severe strain. Separation pay does not impede an award of backwages, because the latter represents the earnings lost by reason of the unjustified dismissal. A more equitable settlement is separation pay of at least one month pay for every year of service in addition to full backwages, allowances, and other benefits.
Doctrine
An employee who is unjustly dismissed is entitled to full backwages, inclusive of allowances and other benefits or their monetary equivalent, computed from the time his compensation was withheld up to actual reinstatement, and these backwages are not diminished by the earnings he derived elsewhere during the period of his illegal dismissal. This flows from the clear language of Article 279 as amended by Republic Act Number 6715, which the Court applied without strained interpretation.
Where reinstatement is no longer practicable because of severely strained relations, separation pay equivalent to at least one month pay for every year of service may be awarded in lieu of reinstatement, and this does not bar an award of full backwages, since separation pay and backwages serve different purposes.
Finally, the rule that a party who did not appeal cannot obtain affirmative relief yields to the higher interest of justice where the tribunal that found an illegal dismissal nonetheless withheld the benefits the law mandates.
Disposition
The petition was partially granted. The Court of Appeals decision was affirmed with modifications, and the respondent spouses were ordered to pay Cabatulan separation pay equivalent to one month's salary for every year of service in lieu of reinstatement, plus full backwages without deduction or qualification from the date of dismissal until finality of the decision, and an indemnity of two thousand pesos.
Remember This
Memorize this line: full backwages means exactly that, without deducting the earnings the employee derived elsewhere during his illegal dismissal. Examiners use this case to test the Bustamante rule on full backwages under Article 279, and the rule that separation pay in lieu of reinstatement may be awarded on top of, not instead of, full backwages.