REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES, REPRESENTED BY NATIONAL TELECOMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION, PETITIONER, VS. EXPRESS TELECOMMUNICATION CO., INC. AND BAYAN TELECOMMUNICATIONS CO., INC., R…
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Republic versus Express Telecommunication
The Case
This is a petition for review on certiorari brought by the Republic of the Philippines, represented by the National Telecommunications Commission, against Express Telecommunication Company, Incorporated, commonly called Extelcom, and Bayan Telecommunications Company, Incorporated, commonly called Bayantel. The dispute concerns the authority of the National Telecommunications Commission to revive an archived application for a cellular mobile telephone service and to grant the applicant a provisional authority to operate. The case matters because it settles two things every regulator and every applicant must know: how an administrative agency may revive a dormant application, and when the agency's own rules of procedure take effect. The Court holds that rules of procedure take effect only after publication in the Official Gazette or in a newspaper of general circulation, and that the filing of the rules with the University of the Philippines Law Center does not give them force and effect.
Procedural History
Bayantel, then still named International Communications Corporation, filed its application for a certificate of public convenience or necessity with the National Telecommunications Commission, praying for a provisional authority. The Commission archived the application because no frequencies were available, expressly without prejudice to reinstatement. Years later, after new frequencies were allocated, Bayantel moved to revive the case, and the Commission revived it and later granted a provisional authority. Extelcom challenged both orders before the Court of Appeals by petition for certiorari and prohibition. The Court of Appeals granted the writs, annulled the order reviving the application and the order granting the provisional authority, dismissed the amended application without prejudice to the filing of a new one, and made permanent its writ of preliminary injunction. Bayantel, the Commission, and Extelcom all sought reconsideration, and the Court of Appeals denied all of them. The Commission then came to the Supreme Court by petition for review on certiorari, and Bayantel filed its own petition for review. The Court consolidated the two petitions because they involved identical matters.
Facts
On December 29, 1992, International Communications Corporation, now Bayantel, filed with the National Telecommunications Commission an application for a certificate of public convenience or necessity to install, operate, and maintain a digital cellular mobile telephone system and service, with a prayer for a provisional authority. Shortly thereafter, the Commission issued a memorandum circular directing all interested applicants for nationwide or regional cellular mobile telephone service to file their applications on or before February 15, 1993, and deferring the acceptance of any application filed after that date. Before any notice of hearing was issued on the original application, Bayantel filed an urgent ex parte motion to admit an amended application. The notice of hearing on the amended application was published, copies were mailed to all affected parties, and hearings were conducted. Before Bayantel could complete its evidence, the Commission issued an order archiving the case, because the recent grant of two separate provisional authorities had closed out all available frequencies, and it archived the case without prejudice to reinstatement if and when the requisite frequency became available.
On June 18, 1998, the Commission issued a memorandum circular reallocating five megahertz of the radio frequency spectrum for the expansion of cellular mobile telephone networks. On March 23, 1999, another memorandum circular reallocated an additional five megahertz. On May 17, 1999, Bayantel filed an ex parte motion to revive the case, citing the availability of new frequency bands. On February 1, 2000, the Commission granted the motion to revive and set the case for hearings. Extelcom filed an opposition with a motion to dismiss, arguing that the application was almost eight years old and outdated, that there was no public need because five cellular operators more than adequately addressed market demand, that no frequencies were available, and that Bayantel was its substantial stockholder to the extent of about forty six percent of its outstanding capital stock.
On March 9, 2000, the Commission issued another memorandum circular reallocating additional radio frequency bands for assignment to existing cellular operators and to public telecommunication entities authorized to install, operate, and maintain cellular networks. On May 3, 2000, the Commission issued an order granting Bayantel a provisional authority to operate a nationwide cellular mobile telephone system. The Commission found that operational mergers among the existing operators threatened free and effective competition, that forty eight percent of the total number of cities and municipalities were still without telephone service, and that there was prima facie evidence that Bayantel was legally, technically, and financially qualified. Extelcom then went to the Court of Appeals, which annulled the orders and dismissed the amended application.
Issues
- Whether or not the order reviving the archived application violated Extelcom's right to procedural due process of law.
- Whether or not the order granting Bayantel a provisional authority to operate a cellular mobile telephone system was in substantial compliance with the Commission's rules of practice and procedure and its memorandum circular on the requirements for a provisional authority.
- Whether or not the Court of Appeals erred in not dismissing Extelcom's petition for failure to exhaust administrative remedies by first filing a motion for reconsideration.
- Whether or not the archiving of the application was valid even in the absence of a specific rule on archiving, and whether the revival of the application was a grave abuse of discretion.
- Whether or not the 1993 Revised Rules of the Commission, filed with the University of the Philippines Law Center but not published in a newspaper of general circulation, had taken effect at the time the provisional authority was granted.
Applicable Provisions
Section 29 of the Public Service Act provides:
All hearings and investigations before the Commission shall be governed by rules adopted by the Commission, and in the conduct thereof, the Commission shall not be bound by the technical rules of legal evidence.
This provision is the statutory basis for the Commission's own rules of practice and procedure, which are the very rules whose effectivity is in dispute.
Section 3, Rule 15 of the Commission's 1978 Rules of Practice and Procedure provides:
Sec. 3. Provisional Relief. — Upon the filing of an application, complaint or petition or at any stage thereafter, the Board may grant on motion of the pleader or on its own initiative, the relief prayed for, based on the pleading, together with the affidavits and supporting documents attached thereto, without prejudice to a final decision after completion of the hearing which shall be called within thirty (30) days from grant of authority asked for.
This is the rule the Commission applied when it granted the provisional authority, and it allows the grant even on the Commission's own initiative, without a prior motion.
Book Seven, Chapter Two, Section Three of the Administrative Code of 1987 provides:
Filing. — (1) Every agency shall file with the University of the Philippines Law Center three (3) certified copies of every rule adopted by it. Rules in force on the date of effectivity of this Code which are not filed within three (3) months from the date shall not thereafter be the basis of any sanction against any party or persons. (2) The records officer of the agency, or his equivalent functionary, shall carry out the requirements of this section under pain or disciplinary action. (3) A permanent register of all rules shall be kept by the issuing agency and shall be open to public inspection.
This provision shows that filing with the Law Center is a separate requirement from publication, and it does not by itself give a rule force and effect.
Executive Order Number 200 provides:
Laws shall take effect after fifteen days following the completion of their publication either in the Official Gazette or in a newspaper of general circulation in the Philippines, unless it is otherwise provided.
This is the general rule on effectivity that the Court applies to the Commission's rules of procedure.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court holds that the revival of the application did not violate Extelcom's right to procedural due process. The order archiving the case was expressly without prejudice to reinstatement if and when the requisite frequency became available, and the Commission acted within its prerogative when it revived the case upon the availability of frequencies. The fact that the motion for revival was made ex parte is of no moment, so long as the oppositors were given the opportunity to be heard later and to present the merits of their oppositions. Extelcom was in fact heard on its opposition and motion to dismiss.
On the second issue, the Court holds that the grant of the provisional authority was in substantial compliance with the Commission's rules. The Commission applied Section 3, Rule 15 of its 1978 Rules of Practice and Procedure, which allows the grant of provisional relief on the Commission's own initiative, based on the pleadings and supporting documents, without prejudice to a final decision after the hearing. The Court notes that the 1993 Revised Rules deleted the phrase on the Commission's own initiative, but holds that those Revised Rules had not taken effect.
On the third issue, the Court holds that the petition before the Court of Appeals was not barred by the failure to exhaust administrative remedies, because the orders challenged were issued with grave abuse of discretion, and the doctrine of exhaustion of administrative remedies admits of exceptions.
On the fourth issue, the Court holds that the archiving of the application was a valid act of the Commission even in the absence of a specific rule on archiving, because rules of procedure are liberally construed in proceedings before administrative bodies and should give way to public welfare and public interest. The archiving was not a grave abuse of discretion, and the revival was a proper exercise of the Commission's prerogative.
On the fifth issue, the Court holds that the 1993 Revised Rules had not taken effect at the time the provisional authority was granted, because they were not published in a newspaper of general circulation. The Court quotes its ruling in Tañada versus Tuvera:
We hold therefore that all statutes, including those of local application and private laws, shall be published as a condition for their effectivity, which shall begin fifteen days after publication unless a different effectivity is fixed by the legislature. Covered by this rule are presidential decrees and executive orders promulgated by the President in the exercise of legislative power or, at present, directly conferred by the Constitution. Administrative Rules and Regulations must also be published if their purpose is to enforce or implement existing law pursuant also to a valid delegation.
The Court stresses that the filing of the Revised Rules with the University of the Philippines Law Center on February 3, 1993 is of no moment, because there is nothing in the Administrative Code of 1987 which implies that filing with the Law Center is the operative act that gives the rules force and effect. The National Administrative Register is merely a bulletin of codified rules. Publication in the Official Gazette or in a newspaper of general circulation is a condition sine qua non, a condition without which the rules cannot take effect.
Doctrine
First, administrative rules and regulations whose purpose is to enforce or implement an existing law pursuant to a valid delegation must be published in the Official Gazette or in a newspaper of general circulation before they take effect. The only exceptions are interpretative regulations, those merely internal in nature, and letters of instructions.
Second, filing the rules with the University of the Philippines Law Center does not give them force and effect. The National Administrative Register is merely a bulletin of codified rules, and publication, not filing, is the operative act.
Third, an agency may archive a case without prejudice to reinstatement, and may revive it when the condition for revival arises, provided the oppositors are later given the opportunity to be heard. Rules of procedure before administrative bodies are liberally construed and give way to public welfare and public interest.
Disposition
The Court granted the petitions, reversed and set aside the decision and resolution of the Court of Appeals, and upheld the orders of the National Telecommunications Commission reviving the application and granting Bayantel a provisional authority to operate a nationwide cellular mobile telephone system.
Remember This
Memorize this line: publication in the Official Gazette or a newspaper of general circulation is a condition sine qua non before administrative rules take effect, and filing with the University of the Philippines Law Center does not cure the defect. Examiners like to use this case on the effectivity of administrative rules and regulations, and on the liberal construction of procedure before administrative agencies.