RICHARD TEH, PETITIONER, VS. THE HONORABLE COURT OF APPEALS, HON. ALFREDO C. FLORES, PRESIDING JUDGE, REGIONAL TRIAL COURT OF PASIG CITY, BRANCH 167, EIM INTERNATIONAL SALES, IN…
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Richard Teh versus EIM International Sales
The Case
This is a petition for review brought by Richard Teh against EIM International Sales, Inc. and the Court of Appeals, arising from a complaint for collection of a sum of money with a prayer for preliminary attachment filed by the respondent corporation in the Regional Trial Court of Pasig City. Teh was impleaded as a defendant because he was the President of the two corporate defendants. The case matters because it teaches the bar candidate two enduring lessons: that a denial of a motion to dismiss is an interlocutory order that ordinarily cannot be the subject of a petition for certiorari, and that a trial court does not gravely abuse its discretion when, instead of dismissing the case, it orders the service of an alias summons so that it may acquire jurisdiction over the person of a defendant and fully resolve the controversy.
Procedural History
EIM International Sales, Inc. filed its complaint for collection of a sum of money with a prayer for preliminary attachment in the Regional Trial Court of Pasig City, Branch 167, against Wood Based Panels, Inc., Sinrimco, Inc., Manfred Luig, and Richard Teh. Summons were served on the two corporations and on Luig, but the sheriff failed to serve summons on Teh because he could not locate the address stated in the complaint. The defendants filed a motion to dismiss, which the trial court denied, and they thereafter filed their answers. The trial court set the case for pre-trial. On the day of the pre-trial, Teh filed a motion to dismiss on the ground that the trial court had not acquired jurisdiction over his person for want of summons. The trial court denied the motion in an Omnibus Order and directed the issuance of an alias summons. Teh moved for reconsideration, which the trial court denied. Teh then filed with the Court of Appeals a petition for certiorari and prohibition. The Court of Appeals dismissed the petition for failure to attach certified true copies of the relevant documents. On reconsideration, the appellate court conceded that the rule required certified true copies only of the challenged orders, but it nevertheless dismissed the petition on the merits, holding that the order denying a motion to dismiss was an interlocutory order beyond the scope of certiorari and that the trial court did not abuse its discretion. Teh then elevated the matter to the Supreme Court by petition for review under Rule 45.
Facts
On August 20, 1998, EIM International Sales, Inc. filed a complaint for collection of a sum of money with a prayer for preliminary attachment against Wood Based Panels, Inc., Sinrimco, Inc., Manfred Luig, and Richard Teh. Teh was impleaded because he was the President of both corporations. Summons were served on the two corporations and on Luig, but the sheriff could not serve summons on Teh because the address stated in the complaint, taken from the General Information Sheets the corporations had filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission, could not be located.
The defendants filed a motion to dismiss, which the trial court denied, and they filed their answers. The trial court then set the case for pre-trial and sent notices to the defendants, including Teh, at the address stated in the complaint. On the day of the pre-trial, Teh filed a motion to dismiss on the ground that the trial court had not acquired jurisdiction over his person because he had never been served with summons. The trial court cancelled and reset the pre-trial and directed the respondent to comment. The respondent explained that the sheriff could not locate the address stated in the complaint. The trial court then issued an Omnibus Order denying Teh's motion to dismiss and directing that an alias summons be issued and served on him at the address stated in the complaint. The respondent thereafter filed a manifestation informing the court that the correct address was in Sta. Mesa Heights, Quezon City.
Teh moved for reconsideration, arguing that the case should be dismissed for failure to acquire jurisdiction over his person and for failure to prosecute, since more than a year had passed without summons being served on him. The trial court denied the motion. Teh then filed a petition for certiorari and prohibition in the Court of Appeals, which dismissed it, first on a technical ground and then, on reconsideration, for lack of merit. Hence this petition for review.
Issues
- Whether or not the Court of Appeals erred in dismissing the petition for certiorari on grounds other than the technical ground stated in its earlier resolution.
- Whether or not the order of the trial court denying the motion to dismiss is an interlocutory order that is beyond the scope of a petition for certiorari.
- Whether or not the trial court committed grave abuse of discretion in denying the motion to dismiss and in ordering the issuance of an alias summons instead of dismissing the case for lack of jurisdiction over the person of the petitioner.
Applicable Provisions
Section 6 of Rule 65 of the 1997 Rules of Civil Procedure provides:
If the petition is sufficient in form and substance to justify such process, the court shall issue an order requiring the respondent to comment on the petition within ten (10) days from receipt of a copy thereof. Such order shall be served on the respondent in such manner as the court may direct and shall be sufficient in form and substance to justify such process.
This provision governs the dismissal of a petition for certiorari that is insufficient in form, which was the ground on which the Court of Appeals first dismissed Teh's petition.
Section 3 of Rule 16 of the 1997 Rules of Civil Procedure provides:
After the hearing, the court may dismiss the action or claim, deny the motion, or order the amendment of the pleading.
This provision is the source of the trial court's discretion to deny the motion to dismiss and to order the issuance of an alias summons instead of dismissing the case.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the Court of Appeals was not required to look into the merits of the petition before issuing its first resolution, because it ruled in good faith that the petition was defective in form. When the appellate court later studied the motion for reconsideration and found the petitioner's contention correct, it proceeded to look into the merits and dismissed the petition for lack of merit. There was no error in this.
On the second issue, the Court agreed with the appellate court that the order sought to be reversed was an interlocutory order denying a motion to dismiss, which is beyond the scope of a petition for certiorari.
On the third issue, the Court held that there was no abuse of discretion on the part of the trial court when it denied the motion to dismiss and ordered the issuance of an alias summons. Although the respondent should have resorted to other means to determine the correct address of the petitioner, the respondent was not entirely to blame because the address indicated by the two corporations in their General Information Sheets was itself incorrect. Moreover, the trial court was merely exercising its discretion under Rule 16, Section 3, which provides:
After the hearing, the court may dismiss the action or claim, deny the motion, or order the amendment of the pleading.
The trial court denied the motion based on its finding that the issues in the complaint could not be resolved fully in the absence of the petitioner, and it deemed it fitting to acquire jurisdiction over his person by ordering the issuance of an alias summons. The trial court acted well within its discretion.
Doctrine
A denial of a motion to dismiss is an interlocutory order, and as such it is beyond the scope of a petition for certiorari. A petition for certiorari may be dismissed outright if it is insufficient in form under Section 6 of Rule 65. Under Section 3 of Rule 16, after hearing a motion to dismiss, the court may dismiss the action, deny the motion, or order the amendment of the pleading; the choice rests in the sound discretion of the trial court. A trial court does not gravely abuse its discretion when, instead of dismissing the case for lack of jurisdiction over the person of a defendant, it orders the issuance of an alias summons so that it may acquire jurisdiction and fully resolve the issues in the complaint.
Disposition
The petition was denied for lack of merit, and the resolutions of the Court of Appeals were affirmed.
Remember This
The single line worth memorizing is that a denial of a motion to dismiss is an interlocutory order beyond the scope of a petition for certiorari, and the trial court may instead order an alias summons under Rule 16, Section 3. Examiners like to use this case to test the distinction between interlocutory and final orders, and the scope of the trial court's discretion in resolving motions to dismiss.