AUGUSTUS CAEZAR R. GAN, PETITIONER, VS. HON. ANTONIO C. REYES, IN HIS CAPACITY AS PRESIDING JUDGE OF RTC-BR. 61, BAGUIO CITY, ALBERT G. TOLENTINO, IN HIS CAPACITY AS RTC SHERIFF…
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Gan versus Reyes
The Case
This is a petition for review brought by Augustus Caezar R. Gan against Judge Antonio C. Reyes, in his capacity as presiding judge of the Regional Trial Court of Baguio City, Branch 61, and against the sheriff, arising from a judgment for support in favor of a child and the immediate execution of that judgment. The child, Francheska Joy S. Pondevida, suing through her mother Bernadette S. Pondevida, obtained a judgment ordering Gan to recognize her as his illegitimate child and to pay monthly support. Gan attacks the writ of execution issued while his appeal was pending. The case matters because it settles a rule every practitioner must know: a judgment for support is immediately executory and cannot be stayed by an appeal, and the child's welfare is the paramount concern.
Procedural History
Bernadette S. Pondevida, on behalf of her daughter, filed a complaint for support with a prayer for support pendente lite before the Regional Trial Court of Baguio City, Branch 61. Gan moved to dismiss on the ground that the complaint failed to state a cause of action, because the child's certificate of birth listed her father as unknown. The trial court denied the motion. Gan then failed to file his answer within the reglementary period, and the trial court declared him in default. It received the evidence of the private respondent ex parte and rendered judgment ordering recognition and support. The private respondent moved for execution, and the trial court issued a writ of execution. Gan appealed the judgment to the Court of Appeals and, separately, filed a petition for certiorari and prohibition with the Court of Appeals, imputing grave abuse of discretion to the trial court for ordering immediate execution. The Court of Appeals dismissed the petition, holding that under Section 4, Rule 39 of the 1997 Rules of Civil Procedure, judgments for support are immediately executory and cannot be stayed by an appeal, and that substantial justice outweighed the technical objection on notice. Gan's motion for reconsideration was denied, and he came to the Supreme Court by petition for review, impugning the dismissal of his certiorari petition.
Facts
Bernadette S. Pondevida wrote to Gan demanding support for their love child, Francheska Joy, then three years old, out of apprehension that she would not be able to send the child to school. Gan replied denying paternity. Bernadette then instituted, in behalf of her daughter, a complaint for support with a prayer for support pendente lite. Gan moved to dismiss, arguing that since the child's certificate of birth indicated her father as unknown, there was no legal or factual basis for the claim of support. The trial court denied the motion.
Despite the denial, Gan failed to file his answer within the reglementary period. The private respondent moved that he be declared in default, and the trial court granted the motion, noting that Gan's motion to admit answer was filed more than ninety days after the expiration of the reglementary period and only after the motion for default had been filed. Gan's motion for reconsideration was denied, and the trial court received the private respondent's evidence ex parte. Finding the claim of filiation and support adequately proved, the trial court rendered judgment ordering Gan to recognize Francheska Joy as his illegitimate child and to support her with 20,000 pesos every month, to pay accumulated arrears from the day she was born, attorney's fees of 50,000 pesos, litigation expenses of 25,000 pesos, and alimony pendente lite.
The private respondent moved for execution, citing the child's immediate need for schooling, and the trial court issued a writ of execution. Pursuant to the writ, the sheriff levied upon a motor vehicle found within the premises of Gan's warehouse in Caloocan City. Gan appealed the judgment to the Court of Appeals and filed a petition for certiorari and prohibition, arguing that the writ was issued despite the absence of a good reason for immediate enforcement, that the judgment had not yet attained finality, and that the writ was issued without notice to him. The Court of Appeals dismissed the petition, and the matter reached the Supreme Court.
Issues
- Whether or not a judgment for support may be immediately executed pending appeal even without a good reason for its immediate execution.
- Whether or not the writ of execution is void for having been issued without notice and hearing to the petitioner.
- Whether or not the Court should set aside the order of default and the judgment rendered thereafter, and allow DNA testing to resolve the issue of paternity.
Applicable Provisions
Section 4, Rule 39 of the Rules of Court provides:
Unless ordered by the court, the judgment in an action for support shall be immediately executory and shall not be stayed by an appeal.
This provision is the core of the case, because it makes judgments for support an exception to the general rule that an appeal stays execution.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that there was no grave abuse of discretion in issuing the writ. Section 4, Rule 39 peremptorily calls for immediate execution of all judgments for support and makes no distinction between those which are the subject of an appeal and those which are not. To require good reasons for advance execution would violate the clear and explicit language of the rule. The Court reminded that to the plain words of a legal provision we should make no further explanation, and it invoked the maxim that a clear provision needs no interpreter. The interpretation urged by the petitioner would only lead to absurdity.
On the second issue, the Court refused to annul the writ on the ground of lack of notice. The petitioner had done enough to delay execution: he surrendered a sedan that was not his and was later ordered released to a third party, and he filed a motion for leave to deposit support pendente lite but never deposited any amount. The Court stressed that it was not saying the right to notice and hearing can be disregarded in every case, but that a technicality should be an aid to justice and not its great hindrance and chief enemy. To void the writ on this ground alone would let procedural rules acquire a new sanctity at the expense of equity and justice.
On the third issue, the Court held that no useful purpose would be served by dwelling on the validity of the judgment by default and the request for DNA testing. It was not for the Supreme Court at that instance to review or revise the decision of the trial court, for to do so would pre-empt the decision that may be rendered by the Court of Appeals in the main case for support. The Court also quoted the early case of De Leon versus Soriano:
The money and property adjudged for support and education should and must be given presently and without delay because if it had to wait the final judgment, the children may in the meantime have suffered because of lack of food or have missed and lost years in school because of lack of funds.
In all cases involving a child, the Court declared, the child's interest and welfare are always the paramount concerns.
Doctrine
A judgment in an action for support is immediately executory and cannot be stayed by an appeal, unless the court otherwise orders. This is an exception to the general rule that the taking of an appeal stays execution. The rule makes no distinction between judgments that are the subject of an appeal and those that are not, and no good reason for advance execution need be shown. The plain words of a legal provision need no further explanation. The right to notice and hearing, while not to be disregarded in every case, yields to substantial justice where a party has temporized and delayed execution. And in all cases involving a child, the child's interest and welfare are the paramount concerns, so support must be given presently and without delay.
Disposition
The petition was denied, and the decision of the Court of Appeals dismissing the petition for certiorari and upholding the validity of the writ of execution was affirmed, with costs against the petitioner.
Remember This
The single line worth memorizing: a judgment for support is immediately executory and cannot be stayed by an appeal, because the child's welfare is the paramount concern. Examiners like to use this case on the exception to the rule that appeal stays execution, and on the primacy of substantial justice over technical rules of notice.