THE PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, PLAINTIFF-APPELLEE, VS. GERRICO VALLEJO Y SAMARTINO @ PUKE, ACCUSED-APPELLANT.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Gerrico Vallejo versus People of the Philippines
The Case
This is the People of the Philippines against Gerrico Vallejo, known by the alias Puke, on automatic appeal from a conviction for the rape and killing of a nine-year-old child. The case matters for two reasons a reviewee must hold onto: it shows how a conviction for so grave a crime can rest entirely on circumstantial evidence when no eyewitness survives, and it shows how the Court weighs an extrajudicial confession against the constitutional rights of a person under custodial investigation. It is a study in proof beyond reasonable doubt built from a chain of small, proven facts.
Procedural History
Gerrico Vallejo was charged by Information with rape with homicide before the Regional Trial Court, Branch 88, Cavite City. He was arraigned, assisted by counsel, and pleaded not guilty, after which trial proceeded. The prosecution presented ten witnesses, among them the victim's mother, the National Bureau of Investigation medico-legal officer, the forensic biologist, the forensic chemist, the investigating policeman, and two neighbors. The defense presented the accused himself and his sister. On the last day of July in the year 2000, the trial court rendered its decision, finding him guilty beyond reasonable doubt and imposing the supreme penalty of death, with an order to indemnify the heirs of the victim. From that judgment he elevated the case directly to the Supreme Court on automatic appeal, assigning three errors: the insufficiency of the circumstantial evidence, the weight given to the alleged oral confessions, and the probative value given to his written extrajudicial confession.
Facts
At about one o'clock in the afternoon of the tenth of July, 1999, Ma. Nida Diolola sent her nine-year-old daughter Daisy to the nearby house of Aimee Vallejo, the accused's sister, for tutoring. The accused was also staying in that house. An hour later, Daisy returned with the accused to get a book from which he could copy a drawing for her school project, and then the two went back to his house. When the mother woke from her nap at about five-thirty in the afternoon, Daisy was not home. She searched, and the accused told her that Daisy had gone to a classmate's house, which proved false. A neighbor, Jessiemin Mataverde, testified that she saw the accused come to her house, say something to Daisy, and lead her toward the compuerta. Another neighbor, Charito Yepes, testified that at about four-thirty in the afternoon she met the accused near the seashore, looking pale, uneasy, and troubled, his shorts and shirt wet although his face and hair were not.
The following morning, the child's body was found tied to the root of an aroma tree by the river near the compuerta. Her sleeveless shirt was tied around her neck. The autopsy showed contused abrasions all over the body, a fracture of the tracheal rings, and fresh lacerations of the hymen, with the cause of death stated as asphyxia by manual strangulation. The clothes the accused wore the day before were recovered and were bloodstained. The forensic biologist found human blood of Group A on the accused's shirt and shorts and on the child's clothing, while the accused himself belongs to blood Group O. The forensic chemist testified that the vaginal swabs taken from the victim contained the DNA profiles of both the accused and the victim.
The accused gave statements at different points. He confessed to the mayor and to a lawyer that he had strangled the child, claiming he was under the influence of drugs. He gave a sworn statement before the investigator, in the presence of counsel, admitting the killing but denying molestation. He later executed a handwritten confession before the inquest prosecutor, assisted by a lawyer from the Public Attorney's Office, admitting that he had raped the child before killing her. At trial he denied everything, claiming the police maltreated him and that he merely copied his handwritten confession from a pattern. The trial court convicted him of rape with homicide and sentenced him to death.
Issues
- Whether or not the circumstantial evidence presented by the prosecution was sufficient to sustain a conviction for rape with homicide beyond reasonable doubt.
- Whether or not the trial court erred in giving evidentiary weight to the alleged oral confessions of the accused.
- Whether or not the trial court erred in giving probative value to the written extrajudicial confession despite the claim that it was obtained through force and intimidation and that the assisting lawyer did not render effective legal assistance.
Applicable Provisions
Rule 133, section 4 of the Revised Rules on Evidence, as quoted by the Court, provides:
(a) there is more than one circumstance; (b) the facts from which the inferences are derived are proven; and (c) the combination of all circumstances is such as to produce conviction beyond reasonable doubt.
This is the test the Court applied to uphold the conviction on circumstantial evidence alone.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that an accused may be convicted even without an eyewitness, provided sufficient circumstantial evidence proves beyond reasonable doubt that he committed the crime. In rape with homicide, the Court observed, the evidence is more often than not circumstantial, because only the victim and the rapist are present at its commission and the victim can no longer testify. The Court then listed the proven circumstances: the child went to the accused's house for tutoring; the accused and the child went together to get a book and returned to his residence; the accused led the child toward the compuerta; he was seen coming out of it with wet clothes but a dry face and hair, looking pale and troubled; he was seen buying a cigarette shortly before five o'clock, again with wet clothes; he falsely told the mother that the child had gone to a classmate's house; the body was found tied to an aroma tree near the compuerta; he had scratches on his feet like those caused by aroma thorns; his clothes were bloodstained with blood of the same Group A found on the child's clothing; and the vaginal swabs contained both his DNA profile and the victim's. The combination of these circumstances, the Court held, produced conviction beyond reasonable doubt.
On the bloodstain objection, the Court held that even without a direct determination of the victim's blood type, it can reasonably be inferred that she was blood type A, since the contused abrasions all over her body would necessarily produce the bloodstains on her clothing, and the dominant blood in a mixture is the one that registers.
On the second and third issues, the Court found no merit in the claim that the confessions were hearsay or extracted by force. The oral admissions were testified to by witnesses who heard them, and the written confession was executed with the assistance of counsel after the accused was informed of his constitutional rights and warned that the document could be used against him. The Court gave weight to the testimony that no maltreatment was observed and that the accused said he executed the document freely because his conscience bothered him.
Doctrine
First, circumstantial evidence is sufficient for conviction when there is more than one circumstance, the facts from which the inferences are derived are proven, and the combination of all the circumstances produces conviction beyond reasonable doubt. Second, in rape with homicide, resort to circumstantial evidence is inevitable and reasonable, because the nature of the crime leaves only the victim and the rapist present, and the victim can no longer testify. Third, bloodstains of the same type on the accused's clothing and the victim's clothing, together with DNA profiles from vaginal swabs matching both, are strong links in the chain of circumstantial proof. Fourth, an extrajudicial confession given with the assistance of counsel, after a warning of constitutional rights, is admissible and carries probative weight.
Disposition
The Supreme Court affirmed the conviction of Gerrico Vallejo for rape with homicide and upheld the penalty of death and the award of civil indemnity and moral damages to the heirs of the victim.
Remember This
Memorize the three-part test for circumstantial evidence: more than one circumstance, facts proven, and a combination producing conviction beyond reasonable doubt. Examiners use this case to test whether a candidate can build a conviction for rape with homicide from a chain of circumstantial facts, and to test the admissibility of an extrajudicial confession made with the assistance of counsel.